Fifteen feet underground, a construction worker looked up at a site supervisor last May while installing stormwater drains to support dozens of new townhouses in Lawrenceville.

He asked: Is it safe to leave the “trench box” — protective steel barriers that hold up the trench’s walls — to check the slope of the stormwater pipe? The supervisor responded, according to a federal investigation of the incident, “Hurry.”

The worker didn’t move quickly enough. The unprotected walls of the trench buried the man, shattering two ribs, breaking his pelvis and dislocating his right hip and left shoulder, according to the federal investigation. His employer, Alton Industries Inc. of Eighty Four, was penalized $29,400, though regulators eventually settled for a fine of $22,050.

The narrative is familiar to officials with the Occupational Health and Safety Administration. In excavations across southwestern Pennsylvania, companies have been found to routinely neglect the widely recognized dangers posed by trenches and in many instances fail to correct them, according to a Post-Gazette analysis of inspection data and accident investigations from the federal agency.

Advertise with us

In about 70 percent of workplace inspections that OSHA’s Pittsburgh office conducted over the past eight years, water and sewer line construction sites have been issued at least one trench-related violation. In total, those companies paid at least $706,000 in penalties for 311 violations issued from January 2008 to April 2016, according to OSHA data. 

The string of violations and the failures to correct them illuminate the challenges regulators face in ensuring workplace safety. But employment law experts say the agency relies too much on financial penalties and scathing press releases, decrying its policy of “regulation by shaming” as at best ineffective, at worst an unfair destroyer of reputation.

Meanwhile, the problems continue. Three collapses occurred in the Pittsburgh area in 2015, including one that killed a 21-year-old worker.

A targeted enforcer

By all accounts, workplace injuries and deaths have fallen precipitously in the 45 years since Congress established OSHA to oversee employee health and safety. Even as U.S. employment has doubled during that time, on-the-job fatalities have dropped from about 38 deaths a day in 1970 to 13 in 2014, according to the agency.

Advertise with us

In the Pittsburgh area, fatalities dropped to 18 in 2014, the lowest recorded level. The construction sector recorded four worker deaths. The transportation and government sectors recorded four fatalities each.

Yet construction workers — who dangle from scaffolds, come within feet of rushing highway traffic, and drag pipelines through deep trenches  — remain exposed to dangerous job sites. OSHA, which tasks about 2,000 investigators nationally with oversight of about seven million workplaces, is focused on improving their safety.

And one key danger comes in trenches, a key component of many construction sites.

Dug to install and replace underground water and sewer pipelines, trenches can collapse in an instant without proper protection. One cubic yard of soil can weigh as much as 3,000 pounds.  

Unless dug in stable rock, excavations more than five feet deep are required to have a system in place to brace the walls. Additionally, companies can adjust the slope of the trench walls depending on the type of soil: Stable rock is permitted to be a vertical 90 degrees. The most unstable, sandy soil, should be sloped to 34 degrees.

Advertise with us

PG graphic: Meeting OSHA standards

(Click image for larger version)

Despite a 30-year-old enforcement program, Pittsburgh-area excavation sites have in recent years failed to keep up to code. Of at least 170 inspections conducted since January 2008, OSHA has issued violations in 118 of them, according to inspection data.

The settled penalties averaged $6,306, ranging from a low of $370 — for failing to have a protection system registered by a professional engineer — to a high of $174,000 issued earlier this year to A Rooter Man of Pittsburgh after the death of a 21-year-old employee. That penalty is being contested.

A Rooter Man of Pittsburgh declined comment. The company does not have a history of violations, according to OSHA records.

Advertise with us

“Traditionally with trenching, we hold a hard line,” said Christopher Robinson, director of OSHA’s regional office in Pittsburgh. “What I try to convey to the management officials is they have a responsibility to protect the workers.”

Complicated rules

OSHA standards on trenching can be complicated to meet, employment experts said, especially on a rapidly changing work site that may start and finish in a day.

Given changes with weather and soil types at different depths, “You really can’t generalize” what protections need to be put in place, said Ben Huggett, an employment lawyer at Littler Mendelson, Downtown.

“Construction is dynamic,” he said. “In any given situation, it can be different.”

Advertise with us

Still, the expectation falls on supervisors and employees to be well-versed in OSHA standards and to plan to have the correct equipment on site, said Chris Reefer, assistant safety director for Fay, an i+iconUSA Co. The Tarentum construction company shows no history of violations from seven inspections since 2008, according to OSHA’s database.

For example, trench boxes are manufactured for various depths and soil conditions, so it’s possible to fail an inspection because the wrong type trench box is on site. Given the time it takes to slope the walls of a trench and the expense of purchasing a trench box to shore up walls, it can be tempting to cut corners, Mr. Reefer said.

“The companies that don’t use that stuff see it as a hindrance, as opposed to enhancing safety,” he said.

Another explanation for the high number of recorded violations is that trenching work can unfold in public view, subject to inspections that might not happen if it were inside a building.

OSHA acknowledges trench inspections most often result “during the course of routine travel.” Inspectors may not need access to the sites if “violations are in plain view.”

Advertise with us

“They will see a trenching operation going on, they’ll just drive by and park in a nearby lot and take pictures,” said Bill Wahoff, an employment lawyer based in Columbus, Ohio, with Steptoe & Johnson PLLC. “Then, and only then, will they come up and present their credentials.”

High fines and press releases

When collapses happen, companies are required to immediately notify OSHA, which begins an investigation after local law enforcement rules out criminal charges. Investigations can take weeks or months, depending on the complexity of the case.

Once OSHA reaches its initial findings, it notifies the company. If there are violations and penalties, the agency gives the company 15 days to pay the fine or schedule a meeting to discuss the circumstances.

If the agency finds the initial penalties to be significant, it will send media releases that, critics say, sometimes wax a little too poetic.

Advertise with us

“Twenty-one-year-old Jacob Casher was still a ‘new guy,’” began a news release from March announcing penalties for the fatality at A Rooter Man of Pittsburgh. “He probably never imagined that, as he worked to install a sewer line 11 feet underground in Butler, it was to be the last day of his life.”

Mr. Robinson, the OSHA director, added in his accompanying statement: “Common sense safety practices would have prevented this trench from turning into a worker’s grave.”

Ben Huggett of Littler Mendelson encourages his clients to meet with OSHA because it’s the employer’s first true chance to defend itself. “The citations are in fact nothing more than an allegation of a violation of the law,” Mr. Huggett said.

He criticized OSHA’s practice — called “regulation by shaming” — of issuing statements announcing initial penalties but rarely doing so when the penalty is settled. “It’s hard to walk back from some of those statements once they’ve thrown it out there,” Mr. Huggett said.

A Labor Department spokeswoman said that while all OSHA’s inspection data is available online, the press releases “help assure that increased inspections and higher penalties becomes an effective deterrent for all employers.”

Advertise with us

According to the agency’s data, monetary penalties assessed to trenching companies since 2008 have been about 37 percent less than what OSHA initially announced. Almost all cases have been settled for less money.

At the conference with OSHA, employers have the opportunity to dispute the violations by presenting new evidence or — if there are agreed-upon violations — show they’re working to correct the problem, Mr. Huggett said. Construction companies can also win penalty reductions if they provide regulators advance notice of where they plan to dig next, OSHA said.

“A company’s really going to have to show an overall safety and health investment” to knock down penalties, Mr. Robinson at OSHA said. At the same time, he said, “We understand we have to work with companies. We don’t want to put people out of business.”

Repeat failures

The stick-and-carrot approach of announcing fines and then working with companies to improve their practices has produced mixed results.

Advertise with us

OSHA records show Alton Industries was cited and penalized after inspections in 2008, 2009 and 2012 — and then cited and penalized again last October, just five months after the Lawrenceville collapse. Those four failed inspections and the Lawrenceville collapse yielded total initial penalties of $90,000, but regulators settled for $59,000.

According to the OSHA investigation of Alton Industries’ May 2015 collapse, a supervisor stated he was aware of OSHA trenching standards and chose not to follow them. He also admitted that he failed to test the soil and that he permitted the worker to exit the trench box.

Alton Industries could not be reached for comment, but in a written statement to OSHA investigators, Shane Alton, a vice president, said the company has weekly safety meetings. “We have done this for years,” he stated. “I can assure that everyone in the company knows the OSHA trenching standards.”

Alton Industries hired Lancaster Safety Consulting Inc., a Wexford-based firm that helps companies meet OSHA standards, to review its safety program, Mr. Alton said.

Jeffrey Lancaster, who founded the safety consulting firm, would not comment on Alton’s failed inspection in October. But he said employers need to see there’s profitability in maintaining a safe record. Mr. Lancaster’s firm helps employers by, among other things, conducting mock OSHA inspections and making sure written programs would pass regulatory muster.

Advertise with us

“It’s like a final exam,” Mr. Lancaster said. “If you have all your homework done, sometimes the test is the easiest part.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.