True or false: the retirement benefits of the 100 Fortune 500 CEOs with the biggest retirement packages equal the retirement savings of about 50 million American families?

True, according to a recent study by the Center for Effective Government and the Institute for Policy Studies, two Washington, D.C., research outfits that aren’t big fans of income inequality.

The findings are based on 2014 compensation disclosures that the companies filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and an analysis of Federal Reserve data on assets in pension, 401(k), IRA and other individual retirement accounts.

Based on their math, the 100 CEOs are entitled to $4.9 billion in retirement benefits. That’s an average of $49.3 million each, or enough to provide a monthly check of $277,686 for the rest of their lives. (The paycheck estimate is based on an annuity calculator at www.immediateannuities.com.)

Advertise with us

“The CEO-worker retirement divide turns our country’s already extreme income divide into an even wider economic chasm,” the report states.

The 10 CEOs with the biggest retirement accounts are all white males whose retirement benefits total $1.4 billion. The 10 female CEOs with the most lucrative retirement benefits are only entitled to $280 million collectively, while the total for the 10 largest CEOs of color is $196 million.

YUM Brands CEO David Novak tops the list at $234.2 million, or $1.3 million per month.

Pittsburgh-based CEOs cited in the report are PPG’s Charles E. Bunch ($40.1 million); PNC Financial Services’ William S. Demchak ($7.8 million); Dick’s Sporting Goods’ Edward W. Stack ($7.2 million); Wesco International’s John J. Engel ($1.9 million); and U.S. Steel’s Mario Longhi ($300,000).

The two groups have some ideas for closing the retirement pay gap, including ending the ability of executives to contribute as much as they want to tax-deferred compensation plans. The plans work like 401(k) accounts and include money contributed by the executive and their company.

Advertise with us

They’d also like to eliminate tax deductions that companies enjoy for pension and retirement costs — if the companies have frozen worker pension plans, closed pension plans to new hires or have pension plans that are not at least 90 percent funded.

◊ ◊ ◊

Alcoa’s name for the new company it will create later this year frosts one credit analyst, who has an “underperform” rating on the metal producer’s debt.

Alcoa is separating its downstream business from its upstream business. Alcoa believes the commodity aluminum business, burdened by a glut of aluminum from cheaper, offshore competitors, is depressing the value of the downstream business, which makes higher-margin products for the aerospace, automotive and other industries. Alcoa hopes creating separate companies and stocks will unlock that value.

For help with the project, Alcoa turned to Landor, a San Francisco brand consulting firm that helped Oscar Meyer launch its Thick Cut Bacon and Cracker Barrel develop its Holler & Dash Biscuit House.

Advertise with us

Aided by more than 800 suggestions from Alcoa employees, the name they came up with for the downstream company is “Arconic.” According to Alcoa, the “A” reflects Alcoa’s proud heritage; “Arc represents the arc of progress and the continued pursuit of advancement for customers, employees, shareholders and communities;” and “conic” stands for the iconic products the company makes.

Carol Levenson, director of research for Gimme Credit, thinks that’s a bunch of hooey.

“As for the no doubt vast amounts of money and time spent to come up with “Arconic” ... well, all we can say is the company (which lost money in 2015) must be flush with cash and superfluous management not needed for more important endeavors,” she wrote in an April 1 note to clients.

A spokeswoman for Alcoa could not provide an estimate of what the initiative cost.

Whatever the cost and whatever the name, shareholders just want to see results. Based on the March 31 closing price, Alcoa shares have fallen 26 percent over the last year, 46 percent over the last five years and 69 percent over the last decade.

Advertise with us

How’s that for an arc of progress?

Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.