Sandra Speicher was fed up with Uber. She and other Pittsburgh-area drivers had watched their pay rates drop twice since last summer — first by 15 percent in July, then by another 20 percent in January.
Partly inspired by recent organizational efforts and strikes in New York City and San Francisco, she started a Facebook page to express her frustration and test drivers’ appetite to protest in Pittsburgh where Uber has been operating since early 2014. Last week, she called for local drivers to refuse to accept rides from Feb. 12 to Feb. 14.
By all accounts, the impact was minimal — the Facebook page indicates 55 drivers were invited, and the service has some 4,000 active drivers in Pittsburgh. The company reported no problems in picking up riders. The page showed eight drivers “went” to the strike.
Still, Ms. Speicher characterized the work stoppage as a successful first step toward building rider unity and spreading the word. On Monday, she announced the formation of a committee to meet monthly beginning in March to discuss further organizing efforts. Pittsburgh United, a North Side-based workers advocacy group that successfully campaigned last year for the city’s paid sick leave law, has expressed interest in lending help.
But any path toward unionization would be mired in legal complications and practical challenges, as has been seen around the country.
San Francisco-based Uber, along with ride-sharing rivals Lyft and zTrip, classifies employees as independent contractors and has resisted unionization efforts elsewhere. And the Pittsburgh organizers face a real challenge in gaining traction, considering drivers tend to work for such services in their free time for extra money and may have little interest in honoring a virtual picket line.
“More money for me,” wrote a Pittsburgh driver under the screen name Shiro-Kami on Uber People, an online forum for drivers. “Please go on strike so I can make double what I usually make on a weekend.”
“I laughed when asked by a driver if I was going to participate in the strike,” wrote another driver, under the screen name MikesUber. “Go ahead and strike as I make 2x, 3x, hell 4x what I normally make depending if this triggers surge [pricing],” referring to a policy that raises prices when riders outnumber drivers.
Ms. Speicher and other drivers claim Uber has made false promises and then unreasonably cut the money that drivers make on every ride, which is measured in a base rate in addition to shares of each minute and each mile they transport passengers.
Uber said in a prepared statement that price cuts were necessary to adjust to seasonal changes in demand: With fewer ride requests in the winter, the company wants to encourage business. The policy has been working in Pittsburgh, Uber contends, because hourly earnings in fares were up 20 percent after the price cuts.
“Drivers did substantially more trips per hour last week, which means less time wasted without a rider in the back seat,” the company wrote, adding that the company also has hourly fare guarantees during peak times for drivers who may not get enough business.
The company also said it’s willing to reverse course if price cuts dig into drivers’ earnings. It completely reversed a price cut in Seattle and scaled back one in Charlotte, N.C., from 40 percent to 29 percent.
Workers’ advocates argue drivers should have a say in determining prices. Ride-share companies are no different than traditional employers, they say, hiding behind the independent contractor classification to avoid bargaining with workers.
“Workers everywhere want the ability to collectively bargain, and that is true whether you’re in a factory or a hospital or you’re an Uber driver,” said Alex Wallach, organizer for Pittsburgh United.
Though Pittsburgh United will support Ms. Speicher’s organization efforts, Mr. Wallach said, the group is still trying to find “the right organization to represent them in negotiations with their employer.”
In Seattle, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters stepped forward to help grow the App-Based Drivers Association, which organized largely around social media with the hashtag #DearUber or #DearLyft. In December, Seattle City Council extended collective bargaining rights to drivers for ride-hailing apps, allowing them negotiate for better wages and working conditions. The companies have threatened to sue.
According to an Uber survey from December, 81 percent of drivers reported being satisfied with their experience with the company. Nearly nine in 10 said they started driving with Uber because it fit their life well, not because it was their only option. Half work fewer than 10 hours a week.
Ms. Speicher, a resident of Forest Hills, works for a home health care service about 19 hours a week; driving for Uber, she puts in another 12 to 16 hours a week completing between 240 to 300 rides each month.
She’s advertising for a nine-member committee that includes a president, vice president, recording secretary, treasurer, outreach, publicity and fundraising chairs. Five people have expressed interest so far, she said.
“What I decided to do was an experiment,” Ms. Speicher said. “I wanted to see how many people were willing to take an action instead of just grumbling, to take that negative energy and turn it into something good. ... Now we need to build on our success.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.