Working in or around Conway Terminal, the sprawling testament to the might of the U.S. freight railroad system, it might be easy to forget the storm of troubles brewing at Norfolk Southern Corp.

The Virginia-based rail carrier has long experienced the booms and busts of products and commodities in the broader U.S. economy, and so have its workers at Conway Terminal, one of the largest rail yards in the country that hugs the Ohio River in Beaver County.  

But the recent and historic decline of coal — long the most important commodity hauled through Pennsylvania — has represented a significant hit for the financially ailing Norfolk Southern, which owns Conway and all the traffic that moves through it.

Furloughs that began last month served as a wake-up call for Heath Vezza, vice president of the workers union representing about 325 track maintenance employees in the central operating division in Pennsylvania. Mr. Vezza said 12 of his union workers — younger employees hired from 2012 to 2015 — have been furloughed at the moment. There have been handfuls of layoffs at other divisions through January, he added, and it’s hard to know how many jobs in total were cut.

Advertise with us

“That’s your new generation of railroaders that need to learn from the older employees and to be trained,” Mr. Vezza lamented.

Layoffs, facility closures, and the downgrading and selling of rail lines are all on the table as part of Norfolk Southern’s four-year plan presented Jan. 27 to shareholders following a fourth-quarter earnings report. The carrier reported a profit of $1.6 billion in 2015, down 22 percent from $2 billion in 2014. The decline was spearheaded by a 23 percent drop in coal revenue, the commodity that makes up nearly a fifth of Norfolk Southern’s total revenue.

The pullback isn’t only being seen at Norfolk Southern.

CSX Corp., which owns a competing rail line across the river from Conway Yard and follows a similar path through Pittsburgh, also plans to continue its years-long effort to reshape its business after coal revenue dived 19 percent in 2015. The Jacksonville, Fla.-based carrier reported annual earnings of $2 billion in 2015, up 2 percent from 2014.

Traditionally, coal is the single-most important commodity that freight railroads move, said Noël Perry, a freight transportation expert based in Cornwall, Pa., with consulting firm FTR Associates. With steady contracts to supply electric utilities or export terminals that guarantee high volumes with little competition, he said, coal has been highly profitable for rail companies.

Advertise with us

Coal movement also tends to be more localized than other commodities, meaning entire lines and networks were built and devoted to moving coal from mines to power plants and ports. 

“There’s usually nothing else around that the railroads can move easily,” Mr. Perry said. “When and if coal goes away, there’s nothing to replace it. So major facilities and major lines get completely abandoned.”

Many of these are smaller, less-trafficked lines owned by short-line companies, such as a 39-mile stretch of the Buffalo & Pittsburgh Railroad that brings coal to the Homer City Generating Station in Indiana County from surrounding mines. Connecticut-based Genesee & Wyoming Inc. spent $21 million in the mid-2000s to revive the line, which had been abandoned years before.

Norfolk Southern plans to downgrade or dispose of 1,500 miles of track by 2020 — shedding 1,000 miles of that this year alone — and collaborate with short-line railroads to manage other segments of track. It plans to lay off 2,000 more employees in “areas affected by lower coal traffic,” cut overtime levels in half from 2015 levels and reduce operations in secondary yards.

The company plans to thin its operational structure, eliminating 10 percent of its divisions and consolidating from three regions into two. Norfolk Southern and CSX each employ about 29,000 people across their operating networks in the Eastern United States.

Advertise with us

“I want to emphasize that we are laser-focused on ensuring Norfolk Southern has the most efficient and appropriate operating plan,” said Mike Wheeler, senior vice present of operations, in presenting the plan to investors last month.

He noted the company is shutting down a 250-mile coal line from Columbus, Ohio, to Charleston, W.Va., and idling a Cleveland-area coal terminal to focus Northern Ohio coal traffic in Sandusky.

“We are adapting rapidly and consistently,” he said.

Norfolk Southern declined to comment for this story, and it’s unclear how the plans will affect Pennsylvania workers.

Meanwhile, CSX has been planning for a transition away from coal since 2008, when the company caught wind of federal rules limiting mercury and toxic air emissions from power plants, said Fredrik Eliasson, chief sales and marketing officer. Despite planning for environmental regulations, cheaper natural gas pushed out coal “much faster than we thought,” Mr. Eliasson said.

Advertise with us

CSX has reduced coal’s share of revenues from 31 percent in 2011 to 19 percent in 2015. Last fall, the company shuttered two coal facilities in Tennessee and Kentucky, resulting in the loss of hundreds of jobs.

It’s also built up its intermodal operations, a rail business segment that connects goods to multiple forms of transportation, most commonly connecting with freight trucks. The company is building a $60 million, 70-acre intermodal terminal in McKees Rocks that by the middle of next year will connect double-stacked containers from Mid-Atlantic ports to Midwestern customers.

Mr. Perry said intermodal is one of the only short-term hopes for the freight rail carriers, whose traditional products — coal, steel and other metals — are being squeezed by persistently low prices and a strong dollar abroad. But because intermodal is more complicated and inefficient than, say, moving a steady stream of mile-long coal trains, railroads need to truly innovate to make it profitable, he said.

“It won’t not be solved by just a shifting of business,” Mr. Perry said. “It will require some substantial innovation.”

Adding to the pressure at Norfolk Southern, Canadian Pacific disclosed in November a $28 billion offer to buy the carrier, which Norfolk Southern soundly rejected. In a letter dated Jan. 27, Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., led a group of lawmakers opposed to the deal, raising antitrust concerns.

Advertise with us

Mr. Vezza, the track union leader, said the boom of crude oil rail traffic in recent years had helped soften the blow from the steady decline of coal. “There were oil trains sitting on the main lines for hours and hours,” waiting to get though Conway, he remembers.

And though Conway Terminal has been seeing less traffic, the yard — which commands the view from the boroughs of Conway and Freedom — still sees plenty of activity.

On a recent afternoon, empty crude oil trains idled at the east end of the yard, waiting to roll through back to North Dakota. Welders worked on minor rail repairs. Locomotives filled up with diesel at the fueling station. At the shift change at 3 p.m., white and silver company Durangos lined up on the yard’s exit ramp.

Though permanent layoffs have yet to hit here, the company has already been “systematically” using contractors for work traditionally performed by union labor, Mr. Vezza said The reduction in overtime has resulted in track maintenance crews deferring more work to the following weeks, he said.

Paul Pokrowka, Pennsylvania legislative director for the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers, said the negative effects would be highly concentrated on rail facilities close to coal fields. A former Norfolk Southern locomotive engineer, he hauled coal from Harrisburg to Baltimore for 15 years.

Advertise with us

“You knew if it dried up, your job would be gone,” Mr. Pokrowka said. “It’s feast and famine on the railroad, it always has been.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.