Better hours, more pay and expanded benefits — after stagnating in the years following the Great Recession, these may arrive in 2016 as hiring managers seek to attract and retain employees from a shrinking pool of workers.

Competition for employees could be particularly intense in retail, food service and convenience stores, where companies are trying to not only hire more people but also move more of them into full-time positions.

A skirmish in the battle for workers has been on display this month in the Keystone State, with two Pennsylvania convenience store chains upping the ante.

Sheetz Inc. announced Jan. 12 plans to boost wages for all store employees to at least $10 an hour — sales associates can expect a 5 percent to 10 percent raise, while supervisors will get 11 percent to 12 percent. The Altoona-based restaurant and convenience store chain, which has 500 stores across six states, plans to hire 8,000 workers in 2016 and continue its annual expansion rate of about 30 new stores.

Advertise with us

A few days later, Wawa Inc., a Media-based convenience store chain, said it will increase starting pay for all store workers to $10 an hour. Wawa’s shift supervisors will start at $13 an hour and its assistant general managers at $17.

In an indication of how competitive the recruiting issue is, Wawa spokeswoman Lori Bruce told The Philadelphia Inquirer that the company made the decision before the Sheetz announcement. Ms. Bruce could not be reached for comment.

Sheetz and Wawa are both facing stiff competition from other employers, too.

PG graphic: Wage growth

(Click image for larger version)

Advertise with us

Wal-Mart said last week it would invest $2.7 billion over two years to give a pay bump to 1.2 million U.S. hourly workers, increasing wages to $10 an hour beginning next month. It also will provide full-time workers basic short-term disability and paid vacation days.

And in advertising six hiring events around Pittsburgh in October, grocery store chain Aldi touted its “generous pay and benefits well above the industry standard.” Starting pay for store associates is $11.50 per hour and workers averaging more than 25 hours a week are eligible for health insurance benefits and dental coverage.

It costs money for employers to raise wages and benefits. Sheetz said its promised wage bump will cost the company $15 million. The company reported $6.9 billion in revenue during the 2014 fiscal year.

The changes being announced at companies competing for employees appear designed to counter previous industry strategies in which retail workers might not get a lot of hours each week or might be sent home if business was slow. 

“We want to help the part-time worker working multiple jobs select Sheetz as a career,” said Stephanie Doliveira, Sheetz vice president of human resources.

Advertise with us

That may mean doing things a bit differently.

To both hire more workers and give them more hours, Ms. Doliveira said, requires a better distribution of employees among Sheetz locations, which are often densely packed within a geographic region. There are 45 locations and 1,400 employees in southwestern Pennsylvania alone.

Ms. Doliveira has asked store managers to talk to managers of other stores, and allow employees to choose hours among several locations. “It’s about us doing better job of communicating to our employees which stores have better hours,” she said.

Meanwhile, the slow growth of wages since the recession has been largely overshadowed by the good news of growing overall employment.

Last year ended with consistent job growth in the Pittsburgh area and an unemployment rate hovering around 5 percent. Regional unemployment hit a high of 9.5 percent in early 2010.

Advertise with us

In December, the Federal Reserve sent a strong signal of confidence in the U.S. job market by raising interest rates from near zero for the first time since the financial crisis began.

Still, as more workers found employment, paychecks were not similarly rebounding, said Elise Gould, senior economist for the Economic Policy Institute. An analysis of wage growth by the left-leaning Washington, D.C.-based think tank shows the median wage the last seven years has hovered around 2 percent year-over-year.

EPI believes workers will begin to reap the benefit of an improving economy with wage growth at around 3.5 percent to 4 percent — the rate before the recession hit, Ms. Gould said. 

“Employers still hold the cards in setting worker contracts, in terms of wages and hours,” Ms. Gould said.

Ms. Gould pointed to a slew of other factors tracked by the EPI that show the labor market has not recovered from the recession: Workforce participation is the lowest since the 1970s, meaning more workers are not actively looking for work; the “quit rate” is far from recovered, meaning fewer workers are comfortable leaving their current job for other positions; and workers’ share of corporate income remains far below pre-recession levels.

Advertise with us

The latter suggests companies could boost wages by simply reining in profits and without affecting the broader economy, she said.

Still, the U.S. labor market is headed in the right direction, Ms. Gould said. Wages in December 2015 averaged $25.24 an hour, about 2.5 percent higher than in December 2014 — the highest year-over-year growth rate since the recession.

A study released in October by Headlight Data, an Austin, Texas-based software and data company, found Pittsburgh experienced among the highest median wage growth of any major metro area from 2005 to 2014. Further, it found Pittsburgh was one of only six metro areas that showed positive growth for low-income workers earning around $23,000 a year.

At a news conference this month, while reiterating Gov. Tom Wolf’s call for raising the state minimum wage to $10.10 from $7.25 an hour, Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry Secretary Kathy Manderino mentioned Sheetz’ decision to increase wages as a sign companies recognize they stand to benefit from higher pay.

“I think that is not only good for workers, but that is good for companies,” Ms. Manderino said. “Despite all of the rhetoric that might come across ... we've had a minimum wage for a long time, and we keep growing jobs.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.