On a recent Sunday night, the Olive Garden in Monroeville was packed and a party of about a dozen people faced a long wait for a table. Management tried to make up for it, bringing them breadsticks and three free appetizers.

Still, they were “extremely upset,” as server James Conway recounted this week. And though he spent a good chunk of his shift tending to their needs, he bore the brunt of the customers’ dissatisfaction: Mr. Conway and another server shared an $8 tip on a $180 meal.

In the past, Mr. Conway worked with the knowledge that this wouldn’t happen. The restaurants required customers in parties of six or more to pay a classically fair tip by adding an automatic 15 to 20 percent to the bill — protection for waitstaff against those who, inadvertently or not, would stiff their server.

Mr. Conway is now among thousands of restaurant servers nationwide fighting to win back that guarantee after Florida-based Darden Restaurants — chain operator of brands like Olive Garden, Red Lobster, LongHorn Steakhouse and others — decided to end it.

Advertise with us

The decision followed a federal tax change that folds the mandatory tips into a server’s wage — meaning that restaurants must treat tips as income. When the change was put into effect by the Internal Revenue Service beginning Jan. 1, 2014, Darden put the tipping power back into the hands of large groups of customers.

The disappearing automatic tip is just one of several issues upending the restaurant and broader service industry, whose workers are demanding a higher minimum wage and paid sick leave. With tips in particular, some restaurants locally have experimented with eliminating them altogether and raising menu prices.

Tips are traditionally “a direct transaction between the customer and server,” said John Graf, state chairman for the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association. “Now, what the IRS has done is made the employer an integral part of that.”

Restaurants are hesitant to count tips as income, he said, especially when automatic gratuities account for a substantial portion of overall revenue. If kept as part of the payroll and folded into paychecks, automatic gratuity tips are subject to Social Security tax, Medicare tax and federal income tax.

Darden spokesman Rich Jeffers said the company found that workers have not seen a decline in average tip percentages for large parties. Mr. Jeffers also claimed waitstaff expressed a preference for receiving tips from large groups the same way they do from individuals or small groups who are rarely subject to automatic gratuities. Receiving tips from large parties at the end of a shift would not have been possible if Darden kept the automatic tips.

Advertise with us

“We acknowledge this is a complicated subject, which is why we spent a lot of time examining it,” Mr. Jeffers said in an emailed statement. “Ultimately we made a decision that was best for our guests and our team members ... We recognize there are differing opinions on the issue, and we’ll continue to look at it and evaluate our approach.”

Earlier this month, Restaurant Opportunities Centers United, a restaurant workers advocacy organization, delivered two petitions that had together garnered nearly 8,000 signatures online to management at Olive Garden and TGI Friday’s in Monroeville.

Workers at those restaurants depend heavily on tips to supplement the current non-tip minimum wage of $2.81, said Jordan Romanus, an organizer with ROC United, based locally on the North Side. If wages and tips together do not equal the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour during any pay period, the employer is required to compensate the difference. 

“Instead of absorbing the slightly higher cost and making sure their employees are taken care of, many chain restaurants decided they would rather drop auto-grat and leave the workers to fend for themselves,” Mr. Romanus said.

In its ROC United’s own survey, conducted online from December 2014 to February 2015, 95 percent of 461 Darden workers across the country wanted the automatic tip restored, according to a spreadsheet of results shared with the Post-Gazette. Many surveyed workers said they had experienced customers simply not tipping.

Advertise with us

“It has been a negative experience for me at least 98 percent of the time,” wrote one server at the Monroeville Olive Garden. “I think people assume it’s still on the check and sometimes don’t tip at all ... I’ve had a fellow coworker get $5 on a $245 check. She almost cried.”

While Darden’s policy change has an extensive impact on the restaurant world, smaller operators have confronted the ambiguity of what’s best for their business and their workers, as well.

Church Brew Works, which employs about 40 waitstaff at the brewpub in Lawrenceville, has never instituted automatic gratuity over legal and ethical concerns that it would be compelling customers to do something against their will, said founder Sean Casey.

Church Brew Works experimented with printing receipts that included tables showing the amount that customers would tip for 15, 18 and 20 percent. Servers elected to do away with that, Mr. Casey said. He said they hoped that would help them earn tips higher than 18 percent, the level that most customers tended to select simply because it was the middle figure.

Big Y Restaurant Group, operator of Market Square restaurants Nola on the Square, Poros and Perlé, decided to eliminate automatic tips after the IRS ruling.

Advertise with us

Pete Landis, a partner with Perlé, said the company keeps meticulous records of all tips reported by waitstaff, given by both cards and cash, and tips have actually been ranging a bit higher since the change. Customers in large groups are now giving about 18 to 20 percent, he said.

“There are still some days where you’ll get on the lower end, but overall, if you aggregate the totals, it actually increased their pay,” he said.

It’s the days that they earn the lower end that concern the Darden workers.

Mr. Conway, a 12-year veteran at Olive Garden’s Monroeville location, said that uncertainty of having a bad night or week worries him. “It’s hit or miss,” he said. “But I can’t afford to miss.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.