A job seeker’s chances of landing a job can easily be knocked off track by a bad reference from a former employer.

One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming that former employers, when contacted for a reference, will only confirm employment dates and titles.

“That is the policy of just about every major company in the U.S.. However, the reality is about half of all references checked by Allison & Taylor give negative commentary about the applicants in question,” said Jeff Shane, president of the company based in Rochester, Mich.

Allison & Taylor has been in the business of checking references for corporations and individuals since 1984 and its employees know there’s no guarantee companies will abide by strict guidelines. Consider these verbatim comments documented by the Michigan company’s staff in checking employment references on behalf of job seekers:

Advertise with us

“She didn’t resign from our company. She was terminated.”

“I am not allowed to say anything about this person as they were fired.”

“Is there a rating less than inadequate?”

“I’d rather not comment. You can take that any way you like.”

The old saying to “never assume anything” definitely applies to job references. Former employers are not lawfully forbidden from saying anything negative to prospective employers as long as they provide an honest assessment of the former employee’s job performance.

Advertise with us

Telling outright lies and spreading false information that damage a person’s chance of getting a job could be cause for the former employee to pursue a defamation lawsuit. The challenge with defamation lawsuits is proving that a former supervisor made damaging comments to a prospective employer.

“The moral of the story is, with your future employment at sake, you had better know what your former employers are saying about you, especially if you left on less than optimal terms and want to be on the safe side,” Mr. Shane said.

According to a Society for Human Resource Management survey, more than 8 of 10 human resource professionals said they regularly conduct reference checks for professionals (89 percent), executive (85 percent), administrative (84 percent) and technical (81 percent) positions. Regular reference checks were less likely, but still possible, for skilled labor, part-time and seasonal positions.

On average, employers check three references for each job candidate.

According to Carlin & Buchsbaum, employee rights lawyers based in Long Beach, Calif., if you are getting rejected for job after job when you are on the verge of being hired, it is likely that you are getting a bad reference from a former employer. To find out if this is happening, they suggest having a friend pose as a business that is considering hiring you and call your former employer.

Advertise with us

With professional firms charging in the neighborhood of $150 an hour for this service, asking a favor from a friend might be the most cost-effective way of getting information about what former employers are saying. But there are other ways to smooth out the rough spots in the job search.

You could speak directly to a former boss to get a feeling if he or she will mention something you believe is false, and remind him that he is required by law to give an honest assessment of your time at the company. You can check with the human resources department at your old company and ask what they will say if called by a prospective employer. You also could find a person other than your former boss to serve as a reference.

Companies like Allison & Taylor call former employers on behalf of job seekers and ask questions to get a sense of how the former employer responds. They ask things like:

“Can you enthusiastically recommend this person?”

“Are they eligible for rehire?“

Advertise with us

”What were the circumstances which led to them leaving the company?“

“What were their strengths and weaknesses?”

While it is almost always a violation of company policy to provide negative comments about a former employee during a reference check, not all negative comments are illegal. It may be a negative statement to say a person is not eligible for rehire, but as long as it is a true statement, it’s not illegal.

One option that Mr. Shane said is better than 99 percent effective is a cease-and-decease letter. The letter is a document stating the sender’s intent to sue the receiver of the letter if certain harmful or illegal activity does not stop.

”Supervisors tend to be the most talkative of all references,“ Mr. Shane said. ”You need to get actual documentation of negative comments being made or else you won’t have much recourse without proof.“

Advertise with us

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.