When it wanted to better engage and provide feedback to its workforce, Cargill Inc. interviewed and surveyed many of its 155,000 employees worldwide — including managers and top leaders.

But what the Minneapolis food producer and distributor learned was that once-a-year employee evaluations motivated very few people to do a better job.

So Cargill scrapped its traditional rating and review system. In 2012, it introduced an “Everyday Performance Management” system that encourages bosses and teams to talk on a daily basis and to provide feedback as a primary part of the conversation.

Human resources experts hold up Cargill, a family owned company and among the largest privately held firms in the world, as a model for shifting from old-style evaluations to a process that provides real insight into how and why employees perform and how they can improve.

Advertise with us

“There’s a growing concern among organizations that are spending a lot of time on administrative processes like filling out forms, doing ratings and having long meetings to discuss who will get what raise,” said Rose Mueller-Hanson, director, talent solutions at CEB, a research and technology firm in Arlington, Va.

“The truth is we do all this because we hope it will improve performance in organizations and there’s no real evidence it helps,” said Ms. Mueller-Hanson. “Employees don’t like it and managers don’t like it much either because it’s hard on them.”

A study last year by Deloitte Consulting found that 70 percent of about 1,700 companies surveyed were re-thinking how to conduct performance management.

Ms. Mueller-Hanson co-authored a recent journal article for the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology in which the authors said formal performance management systems were “increasingly bureaucratic and disconnected from day-to-day work and the behaviors they were initially designed to promote.”

While she doesn’t endorse eliminating reviews altogether, Ms. Mueller-Hanson said they should focus on constructive feedback “that tends to be forward looking, not just looking backwards about what went well or didn’t in the past.”

Advertise with us

As for actual ratings systems like the one Cargill tossed out, she said they can still be effective if they are simplified or revised into documents that reflect the time that employees and managers spend checking in with each other.

For companies that continue to use ratings as part of performance evaluations, they should be customized for different purposes such as promotions, compensation or job improvement, Ms. Mueller-Hanson said.

“A well-designed rating scale may not be a one-fits-all scale; it should be customized to fit how management wants to help the employee.”

Other companies that have eliminated ratings include the Gap retail chain and Pfizer Inc., she said.

“In most organizations, it’s a challenge for managers to give candid and clear feedback. So helping equip managers and employees with skills for high-quality conversations is probably the most impactful thing an organization can do to drive performance.”

Joyce Gannon: jgannon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1580. Twitter @joyce_gannon.