A promising promotion into middle management can deliver a lot more than a raise and a corner office.
Supervisors wedged between executives and rank-and-file workers face higher rates of depression and anxiety than either other group, Columbia University researchers say. They estimate about 18 percent of supervisors and managers report symptoms of depression, compared with 12 percent of lower-ranking workers.
The findings released this summer don’t shock management experts in Western Pennsylvania. The pressures are especially sharp for mid-level managers juggling executive expectations while motivating workers, said business administration professor James Craft.
“These middle managers and these supervisors are dependent on the rank-and-file employees who are not typically engaged,” said Mr. Craft, who teaches in the Katz Graduate School of Business at the University of Pittsburgh.
Surveys show about 20 percent of workers are disconnected from their work, but managers often don’t have authority to fire people for lackluster performance, Mr. Craft said. The separate Columbia research appears online in the journal Sociology of Health & Illness.
At the same time, managers are becoming “an endangered species” as companies thin their ranks, said human resources consultant Chris Posti, founder of Posti & Associates Inc. in Green Tree. She said some supervisors who once managed fewer than 10 workers now watch over dozens.
“The expectations are not changing except to increase. The pressure is enormous,” said Ms. Posti, who called middle management “the engine of a company.”
Some companies are experimenting with dropping middle management entirely while others shift to more team-based organizations, part of an overall push to better engage and motivate employees.
If they’re successful, the efforts could ease stress on the supervisors who remain, industry observers said. In the meantime, they suggested managers might stave off anxiety by guarding — and using — personal time to decompress.
That includes putting away cell phones during off hours, said Ramesh G. Soni, the management department chairman at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.
“People will have to learn to leave work when they leave work,” Mr. Soni said.
Mr. Craft said counselors and other professional help can be useful in navigating anxiety, too. Ms. Posti recommended setting aside time for both physical and spiritual health. She finds relaxation in yoga.
“It helps me keep things in proper perspective,” she said. “It doesn’t have to be jogging.”
Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625 or on Twitter @asmeltz.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.