Lawsuits by unpaid interns, which flourished in recent years, may face tougher tests under new court rulings.

In its July 2 decision to send a lawsuit involving two former interns of Fox Searchlight Pictures back down to district court, the Second Circuit rejected the U.S. Department of Labor’s “six-prong test” to assess whether internships can be unpaid, arguing that it was too rigid.

Instead, the court established its own set of guidelines for characterizing unpaid internships. The court’s jurisdiction includes New York, Connecticut and Vermont, but such cases tend to be watched by legal observers elsewhere who are looking for precedents.

“It’s a big win for employers,” said Joseph Leonoro, attorney for the Charleston, W.Va., office of Steptoe & Johnson.

Advertise with us

About three years ago, lawsuits by former unpaid interns began to increase dramatically after a couple of New York cases came down in their favor, recalled Mr. Leonoro. Just last year, the now-defunct Pittsburgh Power football team confidentially settled with a former photography intern, one of a number of such cases that have been resolved through settlements.

Michael True, senior associate at the Career and Professional Development Center at Messiah College in Mechanicsburg and former director of the college’s internship center, said the labor department’s “fourth prong” has always been the sticking point and is almost impossible to achieve.

It states, in part, “The employer that provides the training derives no immediate advantage from the activities of the intern.”

But, Mr. True noted, “Every employer derives some advantage [from interns] unless its job shadowing.”

The Second Circuit felt the same way, stating, “The proper question is whether the intern or the employer is the primary beneficiary of the [internship] relationship.”

Advertise with us

Mr. True said the July 2 ruling is a two-edged sword. On the one hand, it helps employers to offer unpaid internships without worrying as much about lawsuits.

On the other hand, businesses may now offer more unpaid internships in lieu of paid internships, which would make it harder for financially disadvantaged students.

The ruling comes in the midst of summer intern season, a time when young people all over the country are working short-term positions in hopes of getting experience to help them in their careers.

Mr. Leonoro said some companies that he advised last summer ended up scrapping unpaid internship programs because they were nervous about satisfying the strict six-prong test and the potential for litigation. Other companies shifted to paying interns.

“Before the [Second Circuit] case came out a week ago, it was very difficult for any employer to beat [the six-prong] test, he said.

Advertise with us

Although the Second Circuit ruling essentially disposed of one of the Department of Labor’s core definitions of an unpaid internship, the court did incorporate other parts of the “six-prong test” into its own guidelines. For example, it said courts should consider “the extent to which the intern and the employer understand that the internship is conducted without entitlement to a paid job at the conclusion of the internship.”

Mr. Leonoro believes it will be easier now for employers to justify their unpaid internship programs. He noted it’s too early to say what effect the ruling will have on states such as Pennsylvania that lie outside of the Second Circuit court’s jurisdiction.

The New York City district court will have to rule again on the Fox case using the new guidelines of the Second Circuit. The interns could still win the case if their internship at Fox — which consisted of filing paperwork, purchasing supplies and taking out the trash, among other responsibilities — is shown to have benefited Fox more than them.

Eddy Wang: cwang@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1969, or on Twitter @eddywang21