There’s nothing like insincere flattery to kill your chances of landing a big job.
One of the toughest hurdles to gaining influence with high-status people is what’s known as the ingratiator’s dilemma. It means high-level people, who tend to receive a lot of flattery, are good at detecting suck-ups.
“The more attractive the target of social influence, the more they can do for you, the more sophisticated they tend to be about flattery,” said Jim Westphal, professor of strategy at the University of Michigan Ross School of Business.
“If you don’t come across as genuine, they will see through it,” and the flattery will backfire, he said.
New research by Mr. Westphal found that the people who were the most successful at landing top jobs and influential roles such as corporate board appointments overcame the ingratiator’s dilemma because they were good at preparing for encounters with high-status individuals by thinking about what they have in common and focusing on those similarities.
“Maybe you went to the same school or both are marketing people,” Mr. Westphal said. “It could be a common club membership or political party or even a personality characteristic in common with the other person, like being someone who is a leader in a meeting.”
His research showed that reflecting on commonalities before a meeting made flattery seem more sincere.
“Your flattery comes across as more genuine, so it works,” he said.
His research focused on top managers below the CEO level, such as chief financial officers and division heads.
But the results have implications for lower-level workers, too, he said.
“Before you have an interaction with a high-status person, you want to have firmly in mind the things you have in common. Focus on what unites you and not what divides you.
“For some people, that’s natural. For others, it’s not.”
The benefits go beyond just getting ahead, he said.
“It’s about finding ways to get along with your colleagues.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.