Overshadowed by the very public efforts to update the Fair Labor Standards Act to increase the minimum wage is a concerted effort to change which employees have to be paid overtime — even if they are considered to be in some ways managerial.

The Fair Labor Standards Act calls for employees to be paid at least the minimum wage for all hours worked, and for overtime pay of time and a half if an employee works more than 40 hours in a week.

But there is an exemption to the rule, and that is where this latest battle is brewing.

Employees who make $455 a week or more whose primary duty is in the management or general business operations and whose duties include “the exercise of discretion and independent judgement with respect to matters of significance” can be exempted from overtime provisions.

Advertise with us

The debate is centered on whether $455 a week — which has been the standard since 2004 — is enough to legitimately exempt an employee from overtime compensation.

In March 2013, President Barack Obama signed a presidential memorandum calling for the Department of Labor to update the regulations governing the overtime exemption.

A fact sheet issued by the White House states “the threshold has failed to keep up with inflation, since it has only been updated twice in 40 years and leaving millions of low-paid salaried workers without those basic protections.”

In 1975, the threshold for overtime pay was $250 a week or less. If that standard had kept up with inflation, the threshold would now be $1,090 a week.

The threshold was updated in 2004 to $455, which in today’s dollars would be $565, according to the Department of Labor’s inflation calculator.

Advertise with us

While the White House needs Congressional approval to raise the minimum wage, the administration of regulations regarding overtime pay is up to the executive branch, so it is within the president’s purview to raise the threshold.

The White House, in 2013, said only 12 percent of salaried workers qualified for overtime under the $455 threshold, while 65 percent of salaried workers qualified in 1975.

Earlier this month, the Department of Labor sent a proposal to the Office of Management and Budget for a review. The specifics were not made public.

Still, advocates on both sides of the argument have come out with opinions about proposed changes.

The National Retail Federation in Washington, D.C., had Oxford Economics of London calculate the cost to businesses if the threshold were raised and if businesses did not react by changing employee hours to lower their costs.

Advertise with us

The current threshold of $455 a week means that managers who earn more than $23,660 annually can be exempted from overtime.

According to the retail federation’s economic consultants, raising the overtime threshold to $610 a week, or $31,720 a year, would cost companies $1.1 billion a year and affect 800,000 workers. Their report assumes that front-line managers in retail and restaurants — those making the lowest salaries — work an average of 50 hours a week.

Raising the threshold to $808 a week, or $42,000 a year, would cost businesses $5.2 billion a year and affect 1.7 million workers; while an increase to $984 a week, or $51,000 a year, would cost businesses $9.5 billion a year and affect 2.2 million workers, according to the trade group’s calculations.

David French, who handles government relations for the retail trade group, said businesses will not just take the financial hit.

He said instead of paying employees more in overtime, businesses will convert more jobs to part-time and eliminate many jobs that are pathways to the management ladder.

Advertise with us

“The income lift promised by the administration is a mirage,” he said.

Judy Conti, who coordinates federal lobbying efforts for New York City-based National Employment Law Project, said she did not see a downside to the rules.

If employers are required to pay workers overtime for working more than 40 hours, then either those employees will get paid more or they won’t have to work as many hours, she said, giving them more time off for leisure or even to seek a second job.

“It is important to remember that one of the two main reasons why we passed an overtime premium during the Great Depression was to spread work among more people. Yes, we wanted to prevent against sweatshop abuses, but we also wanted to make sure that workers couldn’t be forced to work so many hours that it kept employers from adequately staffing their businesses and creating new jobs,” she said.

“We have an economy where there are still too many unemployed people. … If employers do cut hours and hire new people, hurrah.”

Ann Belser: abelser@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.