Pittsburgh’s metal workers unions shouldered a lot of the blame when manufacturing in general, and the steel industry in particular, collapsed here in the 1980s. If only they’d realized how replaceable they were; if they’d only capitulated on lower wages and benefits; if they’d only known how they’d soon be undone by cheap foreign labor, by robots and computerization — perhaps Pittsburgh could have forestalled the inevitable for a few more years, critics said at the time.
“The educated elite looked on with benign condescension. Too bad for those people whose jobs were mindless enough to be taken over by third-world teenagers or, more humiliatingly, machines,” writes Barbara Ehrenreich in her New York Times Sunday Book Review column on “Rise of the Robots: Technology and the Threat of a Jobless Future,” the new hardcover by Martin Ford (Basic Books, $28.99, 334 pages).
But today, “The job-eating maw of technology now threatens even the nimblest and most expensively educated. Lawyers [and] software designers, among others, have seen their work evaporate to India or China.” Unmanned drones are replacing military pilots. Bank tellers have gone the way of the ATM. 3D printing could wipe out what’s left of high-tech manufacturing. Police in the United Arab Emirates hope to have “police bots” on patrol by 2020.
There’s no small amount of irony to be found in the fact that many of the computer programs and robot technologies that are replacing the white-collar, advanced-degree workers are being developed in Pittsburgh at Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh. And down the line it will go: entry-level food and retail workers, the ones now clamoring for $15 an hour to do their jobs, soon may not have a job to clamor about.
“It is quite easy to imagine that a typical fast-food restaurant may eventually be able to cut its workforce by 50 percent, or perhaps even more,” Mr. Ford writes in his book. “Technology has the potential to [shape] employment in the retail sector going forward” with a combination of computers, websites and robotic drones that promise same-day delivery “undermining one of the last major advantages that local retail stores still enjoy: the ability to provide immediate gratification after a purchase.”
But the biggest workforce overhaul may come in health care. Doctors will be replaced, to an increasing degree, by computer-assisted physician programs that can analyze thousands of similar medical cases and predict outcomes and the best course of treatment. In-person checkups and blood draws could be replaced by a variety of wearable devices. And why can’t robots dispense pills as effectively as pharmacists?
Pitt and CMU (and UPMC) may again play a starring role in the coming displacement. In March, the trio of institutions announced the formation of the Pittsburgh Health Data Alliance, aimed at revolutionizing health care so that it is both more computerized, yet more personalized. It’s a partnership that UPMC CEO Jeffrey Romoff predicted could result in “doctor-less health care,” and a new form of medically focused artificial intelligence.
Many have predicted a jobless future before, but historically, new jobs have replaced the ones that disappeared. This time, Mr. Ford writes, the robots and computer programs may finally have the upper hand.
Earlier this year, the Boston Consulting Group predicted “robots will cut labor costs by 33 percent in South Korea, 25 percent in Japan, 24 percent in Canada and 22 percent in the United States and Taiwan,” with robots taking over a growing percentage of jobs globally as the cost of such devices continues to plummet.
And outside of manufacturing, office drones who do “routine, formulaic tasks” are particularly at risk of having their jobs stolen by computers, Mr. Ford said.
He pointed to a May 5 Wall Street Journal story (“The New Bookkeeper is a Robot”), which reported that accountants and payroll employees are being wiped out by computer software.
In other words, the “educated elite” won’t be elite for long. “It’s technology,” Mr. Ford said last week. “It’s inevitable.”
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.