It’s a problem a lot of companies deal with: A job candidate who seemed great on paper and nailed the interview process, but once hired has proven to be less-than-perfect when it comes down to getting the job done.
At what point do you cut loose a new employee who is a bad fit?
It’s a lot harder to fire than to hire, especially if there are work contracts involved. So it behooves companies to take their time choosing new employees, and be prepared to make changes quickly when it’s apparent things won’t work out.
“We’re a firm believer in hiring slow, firing fast,” said Dan Courser, CEO of Predictive Synergistic Systems. The North Side company specializes in talent management, and uses a scientific method to help businesses avoid employee turnover due to a bad hiring process.
Mr. Courser said most companies hang on way too long and fail to recognize a bad fit early on. He says a company should know within 90 days whether a new hire is working out.
It’s not easy to calculate the dollar cost of a hire, Mr. Courser said, but he thinks a 1.6 multiplier is probably a good basic metric: If you really blow it on a hire who makes a salary of $100,000, it would cost the company about $160,000. For a higher-level manager who’s a bad fit, the real cost to the company could be closer to triple that person’s salary.
A bad fit is going to drain a lot more from a company than monetary costs, Mr. Courser added. “There are so many related issues that can be affected: morale, direction, strategy.”
The hiring process for most companies begins with a hiring manager working with human resources to find candidates, then narrowing them down to the top two or three choices, Mr. Courser noted.
“We recommend turning it upside down,” he said. The manager of record needs to help create a talent pool with HR, he said, then turn things over to a hiring manager when there’s a role to be filled.
It’s understandable that a company might be reluctant to let someone go, but Mr. Courser said there’s at least one thing to attempt before taking that step. “The first thing I would do is take a look: Is there a better role?” he said. “Obviously, you hire a person because you saw something in the interview process. Maybe they have just been put in the wrong role.”
Not only is it unfair to the co-workers of a bad hire to keep that individual on in the wrong role, it’s unfair to the person hired.
“You might have to make a tough call,” Mr. Courser said. “But you have to let them get on with their career, as opposed to struggling for 12 or 18 months having a miserable experience.
“Part of being a manager is your accountability to the person, and to the company.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.