The importance of a strong U.S. manufacturing base is something on which most Americans agree. But just how strong manufacturing is and how well manufacturers are paying their workers are debatable.

A group that regularly documents the plight of low-paid workers says manufacturing is not the source of good paying jobs that it frequently is made out to be.

The National Employment Law Project said that, adjusted for inflation, the country’s 6.2 million production workers made about 4 percent less in 2013 than in 2003. The authors of the report, Catherine Ruckelshaus and Sarah Leberstein, based their calculations on U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data. They said workers at the lower end of the pay scale, including new hires who typically make less, were paid just over 5 percent less last year than in 2003.

Moreover, the median wage for the 6.1 million production workers the law project looked at was 7.7 percent lower than the median wage for all workers in the public and private sectors.

Advertise with us

The shortfall surprised Ms. Leberstein, who noted that manufacturing workers made more than other private-sector workers prior to the recession. Talk of how good manufacturing jobs are “may be based on outdated perceptions of what the work is and what it pays,” she said.

The figures do not tell the whole story, according to the National Association of Manufacturers. Chad Moutray, chief economist for the lobbying group, said manufacturing “continues to be a pathway to the middle class for millions of Americans.”

He also cited U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data showing that average weekly earnings for manufacturers have risen 20 percent to $1,018 since January 2007. The average manufacturing worker took home total compensation — wages and benefits — of $77,506 in 2013, nearly $15,000 more than the average worker, Mr. Moutray added. On an hourly basis, total compensation for manufacturing workers was $35.74 an hour in the second quarter, he said.

Much of the difference in the two views stems from what kind of numbers at which each group looked. Each consulted different BLS databases. Unlike the statistics the law projects cites, the National Association of Manufacturers’ numbers aren’t adjusted for inflation. According to Ms. Leberstein, the National Association of Manufacturers’ statistics include engineers, supervisors and other white-collar employees who were left out of the law project’s report. The 6.1 million production workers the law project’s data are based on account for about half of the nation’s 12 million or so manufacturing jobs.

Alan Tonelson — who writes a blog on trade, economic and related issues — said there is truth in both reports. But he said there is little doubt manufacturing workers have lost ground since the recovery began in June 2009.

Advertise with us

“In real terms, manufacturing wages have been falling very rapidly, especially during this economic recovery,” he said.

Through September, inflation-adjusted wages for manufacturing workers had fallen 2 percent since the recovery began, Mr. Tonelson said. Meanwhile, manufacturing’s share of the overall workforce fell to 8.7 percent, an all-time low, Mr. Tonelson said. There has not been much of a difference since 2001 in the pace of increases in total employment costs — what employers pay in wages and benefits — between manufacturing workers and all private-sector workers, he said.

Ms. Leberstein said the law project’s research indicates a big gap in the data: the lack of information about the growing number of workers that manufacturers hire through staffing agencies.

Those workers, who typically are paid less and do not get the benefits full-time workers do, are not included in the hourly wage figures cited in the report, she said. The staffing industry’s single biggest source of revenue comes from filling industrial and factory jobs, she said.

“There’s some real economic incentives for companies to rely on staffing agencies,” Ms. Leberstein said, citing the flexibility it gives them to adjust to changes in demand.

Muddled and missing statistics make it hard for government officials overseeing economic development incentive programs to determine what they are buying when they provide low-cost loans, tax credits, grants and other aid to lure manufacturers to their dominions. You would think they, and taxpayers, have a vested interest in assembling better data to justify these decisions.