Years of chronic back pain eventually steered Yael Silverstein and her doctors toward a delicate spinal fusion surgery, an eight-hour procedure that was scheduled for last Wednesday -- until her health insurer, Aetna, canceled the surgery just a few days before, saying it was medically inappropriate.
In other words, Aetna wouldn't pay for it. And Ms. Silverstein, a recent Columbia Business School graduate and resident of New York City, wouldn't stand for it.
What transpired over the next few days was a crash course -- for both Aetna and Ms. Silverstein -- in health insurance policy, customer service and the power of social media.
"I said, 'Why don't I just send them an angry tweet?' " Ms. Silverstein, 29, recalled. The impulse was "more reactive than responsive, and not how I normally operate."
But it worked.
Tweet begot tweets, while a Facebook posting urging friends to get involved turned into a minor online crusade. Another friend pitched in with a Storify timeline, a digital curation of events as they unfolded online.
By Wednesday afternoon, hundreds of Ms. Silverstein's friends, and then their friends, were involved, tweeting and retweeting and, in many cases, directing the tweets to Aetna's Twitter help-line account (@AetnaHelp). Soon, AetnaHelp responded -- but mainly to Ms. Silverstein's advocates, telling them Aetna was on the case.
"Aetna kept saying, 'We're helping, we're helping, we're helping,' " Ms. Silverstein said. But, she said, the initial contact seemed more like damage control and less like customer service.
Social media as we know it are now more than a decade old (Friendster launched in 2002), but businesses are still figuring out the best way to engage customers across a variety of platforms: Facebook, Twitter, Foursquare, Pinterest and more. It's a good space for interaction, but it can also be a venue where small controversies mushroom into big ones at light speed.
And while using social media to reach out to dissatisfied customers might work for the Comcasts and Verizons of the world, for health insurers and providers -- with their unique set of privacy rules -- the devil is very much in the details.
"We're in a new frontier," said Alice Leiter, policy counsel for the Center for Democracy & Technology, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit that researches technology and Internet policy issues. "Privacy laws in HIPAA weren't written [with] this environment in mind." HIPAA stands for the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, a federal law that includes several patient privacy provisions.
Aetna said the denial followed the company's standard procedure, and because this was an elective surgery, certain clinical standards had to be satisfied before the operation could be carried out or be covered by Aetna.
"Prior to the previously scheduled, elective surgery, an Aetna neurosurgeon spoke with the member's doctor to ensure we understood the member's condition and reviewed all available clinical information. Her doctor was aware at that time that the member did not meet the clinical policy's criteria for the surgery," said Cynthia Michener, an Aetna spokeswoman.
"We wanted to help the member. Contrary to public statements, Aetna was in regular contact with either the member, her doctor, her mother or her university since first making the coverage decision the week prior to [her] surgery."
Ms. Silverstein carries a comprehensive Aetna policy made available through Columbia.
While Aetna said it made the coverage decision in the last week of May, Ms. Silverstein said she wasn't alerted to the decision until Monday night, when she received a message from her surgery coordinator.
The next day, Tuesday, she confirmed the news with her doctor.
She was stunned, she said, not just at the cancelation, but at the timing and the reasoning -- the surgery, called off at the last minute, had been scheduled since January, giving Aetna plenty of time to raise coverage issues. Aetna, however, says it was notified of the surgery "just a few weeks before" it was to take place.
Meanwhile, her surgeon told her that Aetna wouldn't pay for the operation because it was applying, in her words, "pediatric guidelines," and those guidelines call for aggressive physical therapy rather than back surgery.
"I kind of look like I am 16," she joked, "but I'm not."
Ms. Silverstein was diagnosed last year with a bilateral spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis -- spinal conditions that cause back pain and restrict mobility, especially during flare-ups. For years she'd thought the issue was running-related, treatable with rest and less time at the gym.
After receiving the diagnosis, she said, she visited three spinal orthopedists last fall. "All three told me in no uncertain terms that my only option was to proceed with a spinal fusion," she said.
She put off the surgery until June because she wanted to finish her coursework at Columbia on time. Sean McCance, co-director of spinal orthopedics at Mt. Sinai Hospital in New York City, was to perform the surgery Wednesday.
As her doctor dueled with Aetna's appeals team, and as her mother collected paperwork from doctors' offices across the city, Ms. Silverstein spent Wednesday on the Internet. She tweeted. Her friends tweeted.
Aetna tweeted back: "We're glad we were able to talk with you a short time ago & determine the best next steps. We'll continue to be here for you."
To her friends, Aetna wrote: "We appreciate your concern. We have reached out to @YaelSNYC and will be assisting her with this issue. Thanks!"
And then, finally, a public tweet to Ms. Silverstein, Thursday afternoon: "@YaelSNYC We're so glad we got the information needed to properly assess your case and approve it. Best wishes for a successful surgery!"
Aetna reversed course and approved the surgery, now scheduled for this week.
Lessons learned?
Ms. Silverstein said the social media experiment worked for her, and while it wasn't the determining factor in the approval of her surgery, it hastened the appeals process, at least in her eyes.
"My guess is that Twitter played a role," she said. "I don't think they wanted a PR nightmare on their hands."
But she wonders if the process would have worked as quickly for someone in a different situation -- without a sympathetic surgeon, a mother willing to fetch documents and a mob of friends with pitchforks.
And what about that final tweet from Aetna? The one wishing Ms. Silverstein good luck on her upcoming surgery?
Ms. Silverstein, in broadcasting her plight, put her own medical information on the Internet for worldwide consumption. But that doesn't mean HIPAA rules are waived across the board.
HIPAA generally forbid "covered entities" -- doctors, hospitals, health insurers and others -- from disclosing "individually identifiable health information" without a patient's written permission.
Aetna's spokeswoman said it was Ms. Silverstein who "discussed the surgery and her condition specifically. We do not discuss her health condition on Twitter."
"What they should have said is, best of luck to you. Period," said Ms. Leiter, the privacy expert with the Center for Democracy & Technology. Aetna, she said, is "walking a fine line ... where [do] you draw the line between customer service and a privacy violation?"
On the other hand, the Internet -- and social media in particular -- broadly allows patients to take health care into their own hands, including research, talking with doctors, engaging with insurers, comparison shopping cost and quality at different hospitals. "We want to encourage that," she said.
But entities covered by HIPAA have to be careful how they reciprocate, especially in the social media realm.
"We're a stepped-up enforcement environment," Ms. Leiter said. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services' Office for Civil Rights "takes HIPAA violations very seriously, now more than ever."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.