This you don't hear very often on a Sunday afternoon: "Son, grab the oscilloscope and the soldering iron and let's tune up the fuel injection control computer in the old Lexus."
We're approaching a time where things can't be fixed anymore.
Gone are the days of percussive maintenance. (I can't tell you how many times when I was a kid, I'd get up and smack the side of the TV set to fix the picture or sound. You can't do that to a modern TV. A good whack won't fix a microprocessor.)
I had a friend in my youth who had an old Chevy van, and in the back there always was a broom. I thought it was because he was a clean freak. Then one day the van stalled. He retrieved the broom, popped open the hood, removed the air cleaner and jammed the broom handle into the carburetor.
Then he got back in, threw the broom in the back and the van started right up.
"Butterfly valve sticks," he said by way of explanation.
There aren't many opportunities for broom-handle repairs in a modern car.
The idea of the coming age of nonrepairability is certainly not mine alone.
Many people have written about it, including John C. Dvorak in a column for pcmag.com. Mr. Dvorak, who can rant with the best of them, was brought to the subject by Apple's recent release of the MacBook Pro with Retina Display, its pricey new laptop.
Mr. Dvorak points out that the MacBook Pro's batteries are glued in and cannot be exchanged; the solid-state drive is nonstandard and many components are permanently soldered in, including the RAM.
Apple also uses its proprietary screws that few people can unscrew without an expensive and hard-to-get screwdriver.
Apple started to use the so-called pentalobe screws in the iPhone 4, and some websites claim it is specifically to keep users from repairing their devices. I reject this conspiracy theory. Would Apple do something to take more control away from the user?
Since you can't easily replace the MacBook Pro battery yourself, Apple, of course, offers to do it for you. For $199, it will install a new battery and dispose of the old one. You read that right -- $200 for replacing the battery.
Even in the world of non-Apple PCs, which have historically been more open to tinkering, things are getting more buttoned up.
Early looks at the new Microsoft Surface tablet due out this fall indicate that you can access the inside of the machine. Still, it wouldn't be surprising if the memory were soldered in the same way it is in the iPad and the latest MacBook Pros. Manufacturers do that to avoid errors from RAM chips working their way out of the socket. But it looks as though you can replace the Surface battery yourself.
The website ifixit.com, which encourages and instructs in the self-repair of electronic devices, said the new Google Nexus 7 tablet also is fairly repairable.
While many hotbeds of do-it-yourselfing remain (including Make Magazine at makezine.com), I think the trend toward disposability is a juggernaut. Instead of changing the blade in your razor, throw it away when it gets dull. Instead of buying a car and maintaining it, lease it, let the dealer maintain it, then discard it for a new one. Appliances are less expensive to replace than to repair because you can't do it yourself.
While this trend might be good for business and the economy, it is not good for society.
While I might not go as far as Mr. Dvorak in talking about the "nanny state" and "dependent slaves," I do think we are losing the habit of doing things for ourselves.
How many people do not know the basics of cooking? Meal preparation for many, if done at all, is sliding a tray into a microwave, which, by the way, they cannot repair.
TechMan doesn't claim to be a genius at do-it-yourself projects. Far from it. But at least he can make a decent omelette.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.