Shop 412 in SouthSide Works offered a special T-shirt celebrating Evgeni Malkin as the Penguins headed into the NHL playoffs, but the line of customers out the door wasn't a problem, according to Christian Kinkela, who owns the men's clothing store with his brother, Aaron. One brother checked people out on an iPad and the other used a iPhone.

"It's very convenient," said Christian Kinkela, who loves the fact that the credit card payment system the store switched to about six months ago is paperless -- customers get receipts by text or email -- and very mobile.

Shop 412 (http://shopfouronetwo.com/) is using technology from Square, a San Francisco company that claims to process more than $4 billion in payments annually and is making inroads into the small business market where the cost of accepting credit cards has long been a headache.

The system seems to be growing faster than many of the other mobile payment systems that retailers have been experimenting with, but don't declare a winner yet in the competition to change how consumers pay for goods, said Rick Oglesby, senior analyst with Aite Group, a Boston research firm focused on issues that affect the financial services industry.

Advertise with us

It seems that everybody's testing something -- Macy's and American Eagle Outfitters have tried Google Wallet; Home Depot in March added its Pittsburgh stores to a program accepting in-store payments through PayPal accounts; and Visa, MasterCard, Verizon and AT&T are all involved in projects. But nobody has yet to revolutionize the way Americans pay for goods and services.

"Is the mobile device in itself enough to get people to change?" asked Mr. Oglesby, whose November report declared 2011 a watershed year for mobile digital wallets. "Or do we have to create a lot of services around that to get people to change?"

Almost half of U.S. consumers now carry smartphones, but a survey earlier this year by Radius Global Market Research in New York found the majority skeptical about using them to pay. Those surveyed were concerned about security issues, including the majority of those younger than 35 and those who consider themselves digitally savvy. And they are aware of how fragmented the industry is, with different systems requiring different equipment or apps, the survey found.

That fragmentation is driven by the fact that so many parties are involved in the payment system, from technology firms to banks and credit card companies to retailers and finally to consumers.

When PayPal was starting years ago as an online payment option, it gained traction quickly because it solved the problem of helping shoppers acquire things on the Internet easily, Mr. Oglesby said. But nobody is having problems buying goods in most bricks-and-mortar stores at the moment -- unless they just can't afford something -- and people are used to carrying cash and credit cards.

Advertise with us

"Most consumers don't look at pay and say it's broken," he said.

Square, which claims to have 1,500 users in the Pittsburgh area, has been able to gain acceptance by keeping one foot in traditional technology while it nudges customers to try a newer one.

Its Square Register system, the one used at Shop 412, allows stores to read a customer's plastic credit card with a small device that attaches to an iPad or iPhone. No smartphone required -- at least for the shopper. Home Depot's new PayPal system also can be used without a smartphone.

Square's other main product, called Pay with Square, does require customers to use their smartphones and an app. As long as they have the phone on them, they can give their name to the cashier and the system, using location software, will confirm that they're the right customer and charge their account.

That part has had its glitches, said T.J. Fairchild, owner of Commonplace Coffee (www.commonplacecoffee.com/), which uses both Square products. A couple of times in the last year, the system didn't pull up customers as they stood ready to pay in one of the Indiana, Pa.-based company's coffee shops.

Advertise with us

"I think they've worked that out," said Mr. Fairchild, who hasn't minded serving as a bit of a tester for the technology because he figures he's saving so much money on credit card processing.

That's Square's other smart move. Small business owners like Mr. Fairchild and Mr. Kinkela see the company's deal in which every transaction incurs a 2.75 percent fee as an improvement over traditional services from banks in which they might pay a hefty equipment fee as well as different percentages for different credit cards.

Sometimes they didn't even know how much the fee on any particular card would be until the bill came at the end of the month.

This way, "At least I knew when I swiped the card how much it was," said Mr. Fairchild, who estimates his business saved hundreds of dollars just in the first month when he tried out Square with his warehouse customers. He's now such a fan that he encourages businesses who work with Commonplace Coffee to try the system.

Another industry player, PayPal, in recent weeks announced a competing mobile payment smartphone app called PayPal Here. The company, also based in San Francisco, isn't charging a setup fee and is offering businesses a 2.7 percent flat rate on card swipes and PayPal payments.

Advertise with us

The behind-the-scenes credit card issues are important to retailers, but consumers are more concerned with convenience, something Purchase, N.Y.-based MasterCard focused on in a recent survey that found mass transit riders have missed their bus or train as they waited to add money to fare cards.

Altoona, Blair County-based convenience store chain Sheetz, with lots of in-a-hurry customers, was an early adopter in using a MasterCard PayPass contactless credit card payment system.

At the moment, the payoff in making mobile payments more common still seems to be stronger for businesses than consumers, Mr. Oglesby said.

If Mountain View, Calif., search engine giant Google, for example, can get a successful mobile wallet into enough consumers' phones, it would be able to collect data to draw a more direct connection from its search results to in-store sales and that could help its advertising revenue, Mr. Oglesby said.

American Eagle Outfitters now offers the smartphone-enabled Google Wallet in more than 350 stores in major markets, but a company spokeswoman said the South Side teen clothing retailer is considering other payment systems as well.

Advertise with us

"We strive to be an early adopter of new technologies that will enhance our brand experience and promote multichannel shopping," Jani Strand said. "This is especially important with AEO's customer demo, which is extremely tech savvy and wants to engage with brands that understand how they use technology."

Macy's last fall began offering Google Wallet in five major markets, including New York, Chicago and Washington, D.C. "We are in the early stages of customer adoption with mobile payment and believe that usage will continue to grow as the technology evolves and becomes more widespread," said a spokeswoman for the Cincinnati, Ohio, company.

Mr. Oglesby predicts change in the way consumers pay for purchases will come, but it may take awhile as businesses tinker with the various pieces -- from the design of phones to the configuration of retail software that integrates with inventory tracking and online sales systems.

"Frankly, right now I think there's a lot of frustration," Mr. Oglesby said.