The Civic Arena won't know its fate for another week.

For the second straight week, city council delayed a preliminary vote on whether to designate the 49-year-old landmark a city historic structure and save it from demolition.

Council voted 8-0 in favor of a one-week postponement after several members were rebuffed in bids to delay the decision even longer, perhaps into July.

Those in favor of a delay, such as council members Doug Shields and Bruce Kraus, said they wanted more time to consider the economic ramifications of the redevelopment proposed by the Penguins for the arena site.

Advertise with us

They pointed out that council technically did not have to vote on the proposed designation until August.

"I do not want to be the person that tore down the Civic Arena in haste," Mr. Kraus said.

Local preservationists, led by architect Rob Pfaffmann and his group, Reuse the Igloo, are pushing for the designation to prevent the city-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority from following through with plans to raze the arena to clear the way for the Penguins' proposed redevelopment.

Mr. Shields said he wanted to see more specifics from the team about the proposed 28-acre redevelopment. Plans call for 1,400 units of housing, 600,000 square feet of office space and 200,000 square feet of commercial space.

He said he also had questions about the 2007 deal that gave the team development rights over the land.

Advertise with us

At the same time, Mr. Shields warned that designating the arena a city historic structure would be no guarantee against demolition.

He noted the SEA, its owner, could seek hardship status before the city Historic Review Commission to have the building razed.

The Historic Review Commission has already voted against a historic designation for the arena.

"It isn't a vaccination against demolition," Mr. Shields said.

Some other members were against any further delay.

Advertise with us

Councilmen R. Daniel Lavelle and Ricky Burgess said they were ready to vote against the historic designation.

Mr. Lavelle, who represents the Hill District, said that until the arena comes down and a developer is hired to redo the site, it would be hard to get any more specific about the Penguins' proposed redevelopment.

Both he and Mr. Burgess, who represents the East Liberty area, said most of their constituents were against keeping the arena.

"I love the Civic Arena, absolutely love it. I think it's a tremendous piece of architecture. But at the same time, its time has passed," Mr. Burgess said.

Meanwhile, the state Historical and Museum Commission voted Wednesday to table a request by state Sen. Jim Ferlo, D-Highland Park, that the panel hold a public hearing on how to restore the area should the arena be demolished.

Advertise with us

Several of the commissioners, including Rep. Rob Matzie, D-Ambridge, said a hearing would be something to consider after council makes its decision on the arena's future.

Mr. Ferlo said afterwards that he might resubmit his request, depending on council's actions.

He said the commission members were "ignoring their ministerial duty to hear and be an advocate for" those in the public who have concerns about preservation.

"The Penguins have the power, they have the money," Mr. Ferlo said. "They've shown their influence."