It dealt with the heady world of intellectual property, so it's only appropriate the case would inspire not one, but two Supreme Court rulings -- and countless questions for local tech company advisers.

The Supreme Court decided unanimously Monday to deny South Side-based WeatherWise USA a patent for the mathematical model it developed to determine the cost of weather risks. But an accompanying 5-4 decision split along the Roberts Court's ideological lines determined other business methods to be eligible for patents under some conditions.

The fractured ruling essentially rejects the "machine or transformation test," which judges an invention's patent eligibility by whether it's associated with a machine or product transformation.

It's a ruling that looks to update patent law from a time of smokestacks and factory lines to a new era of computer servers and software engineering -- and new questions about patent qualifications were heard in tech communities across the country.

Advertise with us

"It will affect the claims of patents that are already filed," said Richard James of Spilman Thomas & Battle, Downtown. He is chair of the firm's intellectual property group and said his "nervous and excited" colleagues had begun work on revising patent applications the day after the court's ruling.

Mr. James said the Supreme Court ruling kept the new patent rules general, taking a case-by-case, "we'll figure it out when we see it," approach.

But that hasn't stopped some intellectual-property lawyers from re-evaluating what patents they may file in the future.

In years past, Jim Singer would counsel startup entrepreneurs to frame a software patent as tied to a specific computer so the software would qualify under the "machine or transformation test."

Mr. Singer, a partner at Pepper Hamilton and the blogger behind www.IPspotlight.com, said the tech community should be encouraged by the decision to stop limiting patents to more tangible inventions.

Advertise with us

One sector of the Pittsburgh tech scene, the life sciences industry, shouldn't see too much of a change in activity, said Debra Parrish, an attorney who serves as the regulatory and reimbursement adviser at the Pittsburgh Life Sciences Greenhouse.

"Life sciences lends itself more to product patents" that fall under the traditional "machine or transformation test," she said.

But even if the Supreme Court has expanded the guidelines behind that test, Mr. Singer said the vagaries of the decision have put him into trial-and-error mode to see what patent applications are eligible under the new law.

"We're still going to try to tie the patent to some kind of machine," he said. "At least under the ruling we know that that's patentable."

He counsels startup entrepreneurs who receive funding as part of the Innovation Works AlphaLab program, and said clients called to check on the implications immediately after the ruling was announced on the last day of the court's term.

"The court clearly thought long and hard about this," he said. "Now, unfortunately, the Supreme Court didn't say what new test you can use."