Twenty-six Pennsylvania Turnpike hourly employees have filed federal lawsuits, saying that union dues are being illegally withheld from their paychecks.

The Springfield, Va.-based National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation is providing free legal aid to the workers, maintaining that "seizure" of the union dues against the employees' wishes is illegal under the Constitution.

Seven employees have filed suit in the U.S. District Court's Western District in Pittsburgh against Teamsters Local 250, which represents toll collectors, equipment operators and other rank-and-file workers.

At various times since September 2005, those employees sent letters to the Teamsters Local 250 resigning their union memberships, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

Under a 1988 Supreme Court decision, public union workers have the right to resign from their union and only pay dues related strictly to collective bargaining -- not those going toward union politics, organizing and union-only activities, said Justin Hakes, legal information director for the National Right to Work Legal Defense Fund.

If the workers feel as if they have been overcharged for their dues, they can request an audit of union expenses -- and not pay dues pending the release of that audit.

When the Turnpike plaintiffs who had resigned their memberships objected to paying 92.01 percent of full union dues and requested an audit, the lawsuit alleges that they were illegally charged fees after that request.

The Teamsters Local 250 declined to comment on the lawsuit.

Nineteen employees also have filed suit in the U.S. District Court's Middle District in Harrisburg against Teamsters Local 77, which represents the same classifications of union workers east of Harrisburg and on the Northeast Extension.

Advertise with us

In that case, workers allege that they are being denied their constitutional right to resign from their union because a "maintenance of membership" clause restricts the window for resigning to one 15-day period prior to the end of their three-year contract.

Mr. Hakes said that such clauses are common, and that the Harrisburg lawsuit is noteworthy because it has "the potential to wipe out so-called maintenance of membership clauses under collective bargaining contracts in the public sector in Pennsylvania."

There are about 1,850 Teamsters working for the Pennsylvania Turnpike when both locals are combined, said Carl DeFabo, a spokesman for the turnpike.

Pennsylvania Turnpike Chief Executive Officer Joe Brimmeier, the Turnpike Commission and several administrators are named as co-defendants, in addition to the Teamsters.

The plaintiffs from Western Pennsylvania are William Mangino, Diane Gallo, Paula Henderson, Kirk Miller, Lisa Mulik, Timothy Mulik and Darlene Tuccinard. Most are toll collectors, said Mr. DeFabo, and their locations are scattered throughout the Western section of the turnpike.

The plaintiffs are seeking an injunction to stop the dues checkoff and compensatory damages, attorneys fees and legal costs.