The city's Urban Redevelopment Authority is expected to clear the way tomorrow for the sale of the vacant Lazarus-Macy's department store to a Washington County developer for $8.5 million, far below the $36 million that Federated Department Stores and the city spent building it almost a decade ago.
URA board members are expected to vote on a series of complicated transactions that would enable Millcraft Industries Inc. to purchase the four-story store, which closed in January 2004, from Federated with an eye toward converting it into a residential, office and retail complex.
Millcraft, which was involved in the development of the Southpointe complex near Canonsburg, is planning 47 units of housing in the building at Fifth Avenue and Wood Street -- 19 penthouses and 28 condominiums, according to the URA.
It also is looking at 100,000 square feet of office space and 50,000 square feet of retail development. In all, it is planning to invest more than $40 million in the building to reconfigure it for residential, office and retail use in a development being called "Piatt Place" after Millcraft Chairman Jack Piatt.
The sale to Millcraft, coupled with a proposed $170 million retail, office, and residential development proposed by PNC Financial Services Group farther down Fifth Avenue, has the potential to bring new life to the downtrodden Fifth and Forbes corridor.
"I think we're very fortunate to have found a man like Mr. Piatt who is interested in investing Downtown," URA Executive Director Jerome Dettore said.
Read More
He described the proposed sale to Mr. Piatt as a "turning point" in the redevelopment of the corridor, which has been devastated by the closing of the Lazarus-Macy's and Lord & Taylor department stores and a number of smaller businesses.
"There clearly is a move up. With the PNC project and this, you're seeing the upswing" he said. "People are going to see new life there."
The deal also would bring to a close to one of the city's more controversial attempts to create development in the corridor. The total cost of the Lazarus-Macy's department store project, which included construction of an underground parking garage, exceeded $70 million and was heavily subsidized.
It involved an $18 million Pittsburgh Development Fund loan, $9.4 million in tax increment financing, and $5.9 million in municipal services money.
As part of the deal to buy the building, Millcraft has agreed to an arrangement to cover $13 million remaining from the development fund loan.
It would pay the URA $2 million over 10 years at an interest rate of 5 percent. The URA also would have rights to repayment of another $11 million if Millcraft sells the building, generates enough profit or produces revenue through refinancing.
Millcraft also has agreed to pick up shortfalls if tax revenue on the building isn't enough to meet payments on the remaining $3.2 million tax increment financing balance.
Jake Haulk, president of the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy, a critic of the original Lazarus-Macy's deal, said $8.5 million "sounds like a good price" for the building given how much Federated and the city spent building it.
"I guess Federated is the big loser here and the city because they put up so much money building the thing and it's never going to be recaptured," he said.
"I think the lesson is that you don't try to force something into place that the market isn't driving. If the private sector does it on its own, it's one thing. But when the city and URA pour large amounts of taxpayer money into it, it's a big mistake."
Federated spent about $22 million of its own money to erect the building, with the rest coming from public sources. The $8.5 million purchase price ended up being higher than the $2.5 million fetched last year by the Lord & Taylor department store building at Fifth and Smithfield, a project that also involved public subsidies.
The sale of the Lazarus building to Millcraft was spearheaded by the Pittsburgh Task Force, a group of foundations and nonprofits led by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. It has been working with the Regional Industrial Development Corp. of Southwestern Pennsylvania for months to try to recruit a buyer and engineer a sale.
Mr. Piatt and the task force are planning a press conference Monday to announce details of the purchase and the project.
Under the deal with the URA, Millcraft also will have an option to purchase the old Revco building next to Lazarus at 339-341 Fifth Avenue. The URA also is planning to terminate the air space lease to the Lazarus-Macy's property to clear the way for the construction of condos on the upper floors of the building.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.