Q: Does the hiring of a search firm to look for your replacement indicate that Mellon Financial Corp. is in play?
A: Not at all. In fact, if anything, hiring a new CEO underscores the fact that we are not for sale, because generally a CEO doesn't want to come into a company and find out it is going to be sold. ... We wouldn't hire a new CEO to do that. I could take care of that before I retire.
Q: Would you consider a merger with another financial institution of the same size?
A: Let me say it this way, so I can be as clear as possible. We will consider any transaction that we think makes sense for our shareholders.
Q: Can you evaluate your tenure? What you did right? What you would take back?
A: I think we have made a lot of progress in positioning Mellon as one of the few trust banks. I won't say every decision has been right, but I don't like to second guess those kinds of things, either.
Q: Much has been made of your decision in 2001 to sell the retail branches for $2 billion to Citizens Financial Group. Some criticized the timing. You have argued the sale was in the best long-term interest of shareholders. You still believe that?
A: Well, I do, but let's step back for a minute. Let me go back to the 2000, 2001 period. Mellon had a retail banking franchise that was basically in Pennsylvania, a little in Delaware and New Jersey and relatively low growth areas. I believed if we were going to be a success in retail banking, we had to invest and expand and even be more than a regional bank but be a national player.
Now the other option, which is what we chose, was to look at our asset management and asset serving and related businesses. There, we had globally important positions ... that was a faster growing business. So we couldn't continue to invest in both. We couldn't really follow a strategy of acquiring banks to become a national player and building up the other business. So we had to make a choice. We were not getting out of retail because it was bad. It was because we had to make a choice and I think we made the right long-term choice.
Q: And the timing?
A: It's like buying and selling stocks. Everybody would love to buy low and sell high. Would there have been a better time, particularly in hindsight, with one of the worst equity markets since the Depression and low interest rates, which actually hurt trust banks, you know, sure, but again, when you are making strategic decisions, you are not just trying to time it in a particular cycle. You are really trying to make a long-term decision. So yes, with hindsight, would you choose a different time? Maybe.
But we had a good buyer, let's remember, too, at a very good price, and this was an important part of our decision not only to sell but to sell to Citizens, sell to somebody who is going to keep every branch, basically keep every employee and really become part of the community. I think it has worked out very well.
Q: Do you think it is fair to qualify the sale of the human resources business as a defeat?
A: No, not at all. You know, maybe that is just you media always trying to find headlines and everything like that. I don't think mistakes or defeats are frankly a fair way of looking at things. We are in the risk management business, you know, and if every risk you take works out, by definition, you are not taking enough risk.
Human resources is a good example. I think that would have worked out over time. But it is like buying a stock that is not making as much as you want. It may be a perfectly good stock and if you hold onto it another 10 years, it will be great. But if you see another stock where you think you can do better, you sell the one and then in effect adjust your risk taking.
Q: When people think of Mellon now, what do you want them to think of?
A: When you talk about people, and as you see the marketplace, you are really talking about what I will call mass market consumers. There is no doubt some people say, gee, they don't see Mellon around anymore, because they don't see all the branches. But we are not in the mass market consumer business -- that is what we have gotten out of. What we are focused on now are institutions and then private wealthy people. Those are our two client bases. That is why we don't do television advertisements or send up a balloon for mass market. That would be a waste of our money.
Q: What do you make of the downturn in the stock market and the effect that had on your strategy?
A: Would you want to run a company in a bull market or a bear market? You have to be careful what time frame you take. Yes, if you look at it from '95 to '05, you have got a bull market, you have got a bear market, you've got a totally different interest-rate environment and, sure, the comparisons in that environment are very difficult, but now I think we have to look at what happens over the next year, two years, five years. I am very confident about that and see the cycle already changing, by the way."
Q: Do you see Mellon remaining in Pittsburgh for some time to come?
A: Yes, it is our heritage, it is our headquarters.
Q: You are not considering a sale?
A: Right. The company is not for sale. Exclamation point. But we do want to make acquisitions, and it could include larger ones if we find the right one. But no pressure to do it.
Q: When will you step down as CEO?
A: My contract runs to January of 2008. But it is really going to depend on my successor, how the transition is going, what the board thinks. We have to have some flexibility. I think the most accurate statement at this point is that I plan to retire in approximately two years.
Q: Have you thought about what you'll do after you retire?
A: I would like to continue to be involved in the Pittsburgh community, serve on some boards and spend lot more time with my family, including my grandchildren, and travel.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.