A deal to sell the Downtown Lazarus-Macy's store to developers from New York City is off, putting the empty 250,000-square-foot building back on the block just as the liquidation sale at the nearby Lord & Taylor department store begins.

"The property is no longer under contract," said Jean Coggan, a spokeswoman for owner Federated Department Stores Inc. "We are currently in discussions with other interested parties."

J.J. Operating Corp., a family-owned developer that has worked on vacant department stores in New York and New Jersey, announced in June it had agreed to buy the Fifth Avenue site for an undisclosed price. It expected to close on the property by the end of the year.

But as months passed, speculation increased in real estate circles that the deal might not close. There was also some concern that J.J. Operating's experience in lower-end retail projects wouldn't add a lot to the shopping district along Fifth and Forbes avenues.

Advertise with us

Last month, the city's Urban Redevelopment Authority told representatives for J.J. Operating that it wanted a "quality retailer" at the site.

The URA believed it had control over the use because of its ownership of air rights to the property, rights that were leased to Federated to build the Lazarus-Macy's store. URA Executive Director Jerome Dettore said at the time J.J. Operating would have to negotiate an amended lease as part of its purchase.

Samuel Jamal, president of J.J. Operating, balked at that interpretation, however, saying through a spokesman he did not believe the URA had the right of approval.

Neither Jamal nor Dettore could be reached for comment yesterday.

URA board Chairman Tom Cox, top aide to Mayor Tom Murphy, said he had been told yesterday that J.J. Operating had withdrawn.

Advertise with us

"That's all I know," he said.

City Councilman Sala Udin, a URA board member who said he was not aware that the sale had fallen through, did not view its collapse as a serious setback.

"It's a wonderful building. It will not be hard to market it," he said. "We'll keep dealing until a deal is done."

The sale's collapse deals another blow to Murphy's efforts to revitalize the Downtown retail corridor just when it looked as if some momentum was developing with the pending sale of the Lord & Taylor building a block away to local developer J.J. Gumberg Co.

Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership founder Herb Burger, who is heading an ad hoc committee that is trying to breathe new life into the Fifth and Forbes retail district, said there are "several quality people" looking at the Lazarus building for a possible purchase.

Advertise with us

He said he does not view the loss of the sale to J.J. Operating as fatal to redevelopment efforts.

"What this does do is opens up a premiere property for a class development, potential residential and retail, that will be a benefit to further development of that sector," he said. "I see [the collapse] as an opportunity to invite other investors, of which there are several who could bring major improvements to the area."

Though representatives of the Jemal family that runs the development company moved quickly to distribute leasing brochures for the Lazarus-Macy's store at a local real estate industry gathering in June, they did not detail how they would adapt the structure.

"Based upon my discussions with several parties involved in the transaction, there appeared to be a lack of a concrete plan for the re-tenanting of the building," CB Richard Ellis/Pittsburgh broker Herky Pollock said.

"They tied it up and tried to find a retailer or two to kick-start the project without a strong local knowledge of Pittsburgh."

Advertise with us

Pollock worked this summer to help a New Jersey company explore retailers' interest in moving into the Lord & Taylor building. J.J. Gumberg ended up negotiating a deal for the historic bank building and hopes to find one large retail tenant to lease it.

As part of its deal, Gumberg has pledged not to use the structure for slot machine gambling without the approval of the URA board.

The 6-year-old Lazarus-Macy's store would be easier to lay out for multiple shops, though it would take at least one larger tenant to anchor the site, said Pollock. An office supply store, bookstore or perhaps a discount fashion chain such as TJ Maxx or Ross Dress for Less that needs around 30,000 square feet would work.

A number of retailers continue to be interested in the central business district, Pollock said. Despite the failure of the two department stores lured by the city since 1998, potential tenants like the mix of offices, restaurants, cultural attractions and strong retailers such as Kaufmann's department store.