May Department Stores will close its Lord & Taylor store Downtown Nov. 22, clearing the way for local developer J.J. Gumberg Co. to acquire the building and take a stab at helping revitalize the city's ragtag retail corridor.
Previous article:
Buyer lined up for Lord & Taylor Downtown
The closing will come slightly more than four years to the day May opened the upscale store amid high hopes that it and a new Lazarus department store a block away would bring new life to the shopping district along Fifth and Forbes avenues.
But that never happened, and now both buildings are being sold to developers hoping to concoct new formulas to attract shoppers.
The city's Urban Redevelopment Authority board opened the door for the Lord & Taylor's closing yesterday by unanimously approving a termination agreement with May.
May had announced in July 2003 that it intended to sell the grand, stone structure. But under a deal with the URA, it was required to keep the store open until Nov. 1, 2005, unless it found a buyer for the building.
The retailer's deal with Gumberg puts the historic bank building in the hands of a hometown developer that will be investing its own private funds in the project. The sale price was not disclosed.
Although Forest Hills-based Gumberg operates more than 30 shopping centers, including the Waterworks Mall on Freeport Road, in seven states, it has never done any downtown retail development.
Chairman Stanley Gumberg allowed as how the Lord & Taylor building, once home to Mellon Bank, posed a unique challenge. "I'll bet you couldn't find another building with this configuration if you stood on your head," he said.
When May announced it would try to sell the Downtown department store site, Gumberg officials made inquiries almost immediately. Even after Rugby Realty, a New Jersey firm that owns several Downtown properties, had the building under contract, Gumberg stayed in contact with May.
Gumberg, which does not have a signed tenant, said its preference would be to find a single department store or general merchandise retailer that would need three to five floors. It's hoping to lease some 150,000 square feet altogether. Chains that would fill the bill could range from a Target discount store to a more upscale Nordstrom department store.
Preparing the building for a single user would be relatively easy since the Lord & Taylor renovations were done just four years ago.
Gumberg would consider reconfiguring the site for multiple retailers, probably keeping a common area open around the escalators and having stores face out on that. That would require more construction and more investment by the developer.
Either way, the goal is to have merchandise for sale on the site next year, preferably before the holiday shopping season.
"We do have some certain plans," said Fred Reitano, vice president and director of development for the company, but he declined to elaborate beyond offering assurances that the tenants would be proven retailers who fit with the caliber of the building.
The failures of Lord & Taylor and Lazarus-Macy's do not appear to have discouraged Gumberg officials. While they declined to comment on what the other businesses might have done wrong, they believe the Lord & Taylor closing was triggered by internal May issues.
The right retailer could make the site a destination that would draw shoppers from outlying neighborhoods and overcome the general aversion to finding parking Downtown, he said.
Although Gumberg officials had a few discussions with the city about its plans for revitalizing the Fifth and Forbes corridors, Reitano said that was not a factor in the decision to try to acquire the building.
Among the other Gumberg holdings are North Hills Village Mall on McKnight Road and the Clearview Mall in Butler. Stanley Gumberg, son of founder J.J. Gumberg, serves as company chairman and his three sons work in management.
Under the termination agreement, May and Gumberg have pledged not to use the building for slot machine gambling without the approval of the URA board. Tom Cox, URA board chairman and top aide to Mayor Tom Murphy, said the agency sought the pledge to put "to bed" speculation that the building would be used for that purpose.
"Nobody had proposed gambling, neither the May Co. nor Gumberg, but we just wanted to make sure everybody understood this is for retailing Downtown," he said.
The Lord & Taylor opening in 2000 was a key part of Murphy's strategy to resuscitate the sagging Downtown retail corridor. As part of a complicated transaction that involved two parking garages, the URA ended up sinking $11.8 million in incentives into the Lord & Taylor deal.
May decided to close the store when it never reached anticipated sales projections.
URA officials maintained yesterday, however, that the failure had more to do with Lord & Taylor than the retail climate Downtown or Murphy's strategy. With the Nov. 22 closing of the Lord & Taylor store, about 50 employees will lose their jobs, down from 78 about a year ago. Sharon Bateman, a May spokeswoman, said employees will be offered severance pay based on years of experience as well as "enhanced retirement" for those who qualify.
May plans to begin a liquidation sale Oct. 27.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.