May Department Stores is closing in on a deal to sell the Lord & Taylor Building on Smithfield Street, Downtown, and local developer J.J. Gumberg is the odds-on favorite to gain control of the former bank building.

The Lord & Taylor store Downtown.

Click photo for larger image.

The city's Urban Redevelopment Authority board is expected to vote tomorrow on a termination agreement with May that would clear the way to sell the building.

Advertise with us

With the help of an $11.8 million URA loan, May opened the Lord & Taylor store in the former Mellon Bank headquarters in November 2000. At the time, the store was a key component of Mayor Tom Murphy's efforts to revitalize the Fifth and Forbes retail corridor.

But the store failed to meet sales expectations, and May announced in July 2003 that it intended to sell the building. Under a complicated lease deal with the city, May was required to keep the store open until Nov. 1, 2005, unless it found a buyer for the building before then.

State Rep. Dan Frankel, a URA board member, said yesterday Forest Hills-based Gumberg was one of two prospective buyers talking to May about purchasing the building. The other was New Jersey-based Rugby Realty, which owns half a dozen buildings Downtown.

It no longer appears interested. Herky Pollock, a broker with CB Richard Ellis/Pittsburgh who had been tapped by Rugby Realty to find retail tenants for the site, said yesterday that he was no longer seeking tenants.

May spokeswoman Sharon Bateman declined comment, as did a J.J. Gumberg Co. spokesman. Neither URA Executive Director Jerome Dettore nor board Chairman Tom Cox, Murphy's top aide, could be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

J.J. Gumberg Co., founded in 1927, operates both commercial office space and retail shopping centers. A company Web site noted that its portfolio of more than 30 shopping centers includes the Waterworks along Freeport Road, North Hills Village Mall on McKnight Road and Clearview Mall in Butler County.

When it opened, officials hoped the five-story department store's location between Kaufmann's and Saks Fifth Avenue would help attract customers, but sales never reached anticipated levels.

The Lord & Taylor Downtown store is one of 32 targeted for closing by May because of weak sales. Seventeen of the stores have been shuttered so far. May wants to return the chain to its upscale roots and will focus its efforts on its best-performing locations.

Under its Pittsburgh lease, May could close the store before November 2005 if it found a buyer. The only other way out early is to pay off its $11.8 million URA loan.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.