Pittsburgh may be getting the worst of all worlds with the downgrading of US Airways' local operations from a hub to a "focus city," according to some airline observers and local officials.
Others disagree
The move, part of the airline's new survival plan unveiled without any specifics earlier this week, could stick the region with fewer overall flights, comparatively high fares and sharply reduced employment, the bad-news side fears.
Former Allegheny County Chief Executive Jim Roddey believes the employment could fall as low as 2,500, from about 8,000 now and nearly 13,000 three years ago.
But the new county chief executive, Dan Onorato, believes a smaller US Airways will clear the way for other airlines, particularly low-fare carriers such as Air Tran Airways and Southwest Airlines, to increase operations here with US Airways no longer so formidable a foe at Pittsburgh International.
"Other airlines will be able to compete" with US Airways no longer controlling some 87 percent of traffic at the airport, Onorato said. The airline "won't have the monopoly control they had in prior years."
Pittsburgh Regional Alliance President Ronnie Bryant, part of an Allegheny Conference on Community Development effort to ensure adequate air service at the airport and even expand it, yesterday said preliminary talks with other carriers have been "very positive."
"This market has the potential to be very attractive to mainline and low-cost carriers. In our early discussions, we have been very well-received," Bryant said.
Still, airline observers believe local officials will confront a hard sell if they hope to lure a significant number of new carriers and service to Pittsburgh. The region is only the 30th-largest airline market in the country and could go lower.
Not counting the out-of-town travelers who use the airport solely as a connection point, Pittsburgh's total of 6.9 million local passengers trails 40 other U.S. cities, lessening its attraction. "You are not that big of a market," said Colorado-based aviation consultant Mike Boyd.
Pittsburgh is "not the giant vapor hole that other airlines will be rushing into," he said. "It may be the small apple or no apple. It may be US Airways or nothing."
Part of the problem is that while US Airways is shrinking, it's still going to be the biggest airline by far at Pittsburgh International -- big enough to keep some other carriers from coming in and setting up shop, Boyd and others said yesterday.
The airline hasn't said how many daily flights it may pull -- in fact, it reiterated plans to maintain existing service levels through September -- but observers speculate the number could fall from 379 to as low as 150 or 200.
Even at that lower level, the number of daily flights by US Airways would more than double or nearly triple, depending on the final count, the total number of flights offered by all other airlines at the airport combined. Moreover, the flights U.S. Airways does abandon most likely would be those where it already confronts competition, freeing it to keep the most lucrative routes to itself.
It's hard to envision many other carriers rushing into such an environment just to take up the slack for the lowest-fare, more marginal routes, said airline analyst Darryl Jenkins, who heads George Washington University's Aviation Institute.
The local economy is not strong enough or big enough to attract a lot of new attention, he said. To be sure, history shows that cities can bounce back from the partial withdrawal of a large, dominant air carrier, but only if the local traffic is large enough to support the replacements.
Two examples of that are Nashville and Raleigh, N.C., both of which lost their status as American Airlines hub in 1995. When American left, traffic took a big hit in both places, with the Raleigh-Durham International Airport losing 3 million passengers in one year and the Nashville International Airport losing 2 million.
Raleigh rebounded with the arrival of Southwest Airlines in 2000 and demand for travel from the region's cluster of high-technology companies and medical outfits. "Even though it was a bad thing that happened, good things resulted," said Mindy Hamlin, the airport's spokeswoman.
The story was the same in Nashville, where traffic dipped as low as 7 million once American left but came back up to 9.2 million before 9/11. Last year, it was 8.2 million.
"It worked out very, very well," said airport chief operating officer Hugh Smith, who noted that people now drive as much as 250 miles to use the Nashville airport, due in large part to Southwest. If Pittsburgh can attract a new low-cost carrier, "you will be able to pull people in from a great distance," Smith added.
County Airport Authority Executive Director Kent George said the agency and local officials have been trying to move the airport away from its reliance on connecting traffic to one built around its local market for more than a year, and that it "will continue to talk with every other carrier out there, along with carriers serving Pittsburgh."
But the outcome in Pittsburgh could be much like it has been so far in St. Louis, where American, which accounted for three-fourths of all flights at Lambert International Airport, in November slashed its daily flights from 417 to 200 and stopped its direct flights to London and Paris.
Since then, city and aviation officials have been trying to recruit other airlines to fill the void, but so far, they've only landed one -- Frontier Airlines, which started Nov. 1. And only 47 of the 217 lost flights have been filled by Frontier, Delta Airlines, Northwest and American.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.