U.S. Steel nearly tripled its profits in 2018, reporting net income of $1.1 billion amid a remarkable turnaround in the American steel industry.

Meanwhile, NiSource, the corporate owner of Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania, lost $66 million during that same time period, which included nearly $1 billion in costs related to gas explosions that killed one person in Massachusetts last September.

Guess which company’s stock lost half its value, while the other’s stayed almost flat and ranked in the better half of Pittsburgh-area companies during a turbulent year on Wall Street?

You would have lost about half your money if you had gone with U.S. Steel — not much of a reward, it would seem, for correctly guessing that the Trump administration would slap tariffs on imports of steel and boost prices for the Pittsburgh steelmaker.

Advertise with us

U.S. Steel shares opened the year at $35.57 on Jan. 1, 2018, and closed at $18.24 on Dec. 31, 2018. NiSource opened the year at $25.64 and closed at $25.35.

As it turned out, 2018 was an instructive year for investors to re-educate themselves on the garden variety of factors that can swing stock prices — prices that increasingly serve as a gauge for the performance of retirement savings, index funds and personal investments.

A basic fundamental of the market can explain why stock prices can be so largely divorced from the reality of the reported financials: While investors are often encouraged by reports of rising sales and profits, they tend to be focused on a bigger question for companies — what does the future hold?

“Many, many, many people do not appreciate the fact that the stock market is a forecasting mechanism,” said Linda Duessel, a senior equities strategist for Federated Investors, the Downtown-based investment firm.

“The price of a stock at any moment of time is a reflection of the market’s view of what the next six to eight months hold.”

Advertise with us

That rule clearly manifests in the fact U.S. Steel’s stock suffered last year alongside the broader steel industry. The New York Stock Exchange American Steel Index, a measurement of publicly traded steel companies, dropped 23% in 2018. 

Worries about the potential for a recession, which would slow demand for steel, shook investors at the end of 2018. A fourth-quarter selloff pushed down the Dow Jones Industrial Average by nearly 6% for the full year 2018, the worst performance since 2008.

The stock market has gained back some of those losses in the first quarter of 2019. Investors understood that the tariffs imposed in March 2018 had helped American steel companies, but they were unsure just how long the trade barriers could support the good times.

“The benefit of tariffs were already priced into these stocks in early March [2018],” said Carter Henderson, a portfolio specialist at Fort Pitt Capital Group. “It’s not what have you done for me lately; it’s what can you do for me in the future?”

Meanwhile, NiSource stock fared well because business is stable for Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania and the company’s other natural gas utilities.

Advertise with us

While the Massachusetts explosion was a disaster that harmed the company’s financials last year, it did not reduce demand for natural gas to fuel homes and businesses. Utilities are generally considered a safe bet for investors for that reason. Plus, utilities are regulated — and propped up by — state utility commissions, adding an extra layer of stability.

Last year, Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania, based in Canonsburg and serving 430,000 customers in 26 counties, received state approval to raise its rates beginning in December. That is expected to boost the utility’s annual revenue by $26 million. NiSource’s stock price has surged 14% in 2019.

This spring, U.S. Steel’s shares have gone in the other direction as the skepticism seen last year has only grown.

In April, Credit Suisse analyst Curt Woodworth issued a research note that slashed expectations for U.S. Steel’s stock performance on worries about the company’s profit margins as new domestic steel capacity comes on line in 2021 and 2022.

That note followed up on research by Bank of America Merrill Lynch analyst Timna Tanners in March that warned of “steelmageddon” should prices fall precipitously.

Advertise with us

Mr. Woodworth’s assessment helped push down U.S. Steel’s stock price by 10% last month.

Federated and other investment companies that manage large pools of money look for expertise to the legions of financial analysts who spend their days following a small group of companies within an industry, Ms. Duessel said.

Those analysts estimate what to expect from a company’s earnings, stock price and industry trends that could affect a company’s performance — and those projections are closely watched come earnings time.

For investors looking for a simple strategy, Ms. Duessel suggested buying stocks across diverse industries — a healthy mix of safe stocks and high-risk, high-reward stocks — and holding onto them for a long period of time.

From her 35 years of experience watching the market, she said, it’s clear that it’s a fool’s errand to try to time purchases of stock based on what you think prices will do.

Advertise with us

And Ms. Duessel works hard at being informed on what the market is doing.

She watches CNBC programs in the morning, reads business reporting, scrolls through Twitter.

“You can become a real student of the market,” she said. “This is a great time to be alive right now, for the information you can get out there.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore