Institutions that control index funds own as much as 65% of the shares of some of the largest companies based in the Pittsburgh region.

For example, Morningstar Inc. data shows 44.5% of the shares in PNC Financial Services Group are owned by either index funds, mutual funds or exchange-traded funds.
That’s about 200 million shares valued at about $26 billion in the bank that employs 13,500 employees in the Pittsburgh region.
It’s an indication of how the influence and power of index funds has steadily grown to the point that they could shape company’s boards and corporate strategies. Index funds also can affect how involved shareholders get in tracking individual company performance.
While actively managed mutual funds have traditionally dominated the investment landscape, passive mutual funds — which include index funds and exchange traded funds — are steadily gaining ground. In 2018, investors placed $207 billion into passive U.S. equity funds and pulled $174 billion out of actively managed stock mutual funds, according to MorningStar Inc., a global financial services firm headquartered in Chicago.
“The new money going into mutual funds is going into index mutual funds,” said Shelly Antoniewicz, a senior analyst at the Washington, D.C.-based Investment Company Institute.
Read More
Index funds have not only revolutionized investing for individuals, they have become a force to be reckoned with in the investment world.
The low-cost investment programs are a type of mutual fund whose holdings match or track a particular market index, such as the Standard & Poors 500, or market sectors, such as energy, banking or technology. The idea is to protect investors from volatility and to practically guarantee a return that will mirror the overall return of the markets.
Index funds are designed to provide individuals with a passive, inexpensive way to invest in the stock market. And over the past decade, the investing public has gradually fallen in love with them.
When the Dow Jones Industrial Average is surging, as it did in 2013 and 2017, that looks pretty good to investors. Of course, index funds can go down, too, following the market twists and turns. At the end of 2018, the Dow was down 5.6%.

“Investors are drawn to index funds because they know with certainty they will get the market as their return,” said Paul Brahim, chairman and CEO of BPU Investment Management, Downtown. “The second reason is cost. Traditional index funds and ETFs cost a fraction of what actively managed funds cost.”
According to the Investment Company Institute, the average management fee for an index fund is around 0.09% versus around 0.82% for an actively managed mutual fund.
Over a 30-year period, someone who invests $1,000 each year would end up paying about $1,800 in fees for an index fund versus about $15,000 total fees for a mutual fund.
Based on the fee structure alone, investors have a better chance of achieving higher returns. While active managers get paid more to do stock research and attempt to pick more winners than losers, few actively managed mutual funds are able to consistently outperform the market.
Only 38% of actively managed stock mutual funds in 2018 outperformed their average passive fund peer, according to Morningstar.
But the popularity of index funds may have some drawbacks for the broader market.
A growing number of financial industry professionals are becoming concerned that such funds have grown to a point where a handful of them are controlling a large percentage of publicly traded companies.
“If index funds get large enough, the concern is is anyone buying stocks based on fundamentals?” said Jim Sinegal, a senior investment analyst at Fragasso Financial Advisors, Downtown.
“It used to be that individual investors could have a big say in how companies are run and they cared about who was elected to the boards and issues related to corporate governance. For the past 10 to 15 years, index funds have worked out well.
“But the other side of the argument is can that last forever?”
Several Pittsburgh-based companies — such as PNC Bank, PPG Industries and Kraft Heinz — are listed on the S&P 500, which is one of the most popular index funds. That draws a lot of investment dollars to those companies.
But practically all publicly listed companies based in Pittsburgh and elsewhere are included in some index.
“Pittsburgh companies cover the spectrum of market capitalization from large cap to micro cap,” Mr. Brahim said.
“You can own all those companies in a market weighted way by owning a total market index fund that tracks either the Russell 3000 or the Wilshire 5000. And, of course, you can get the top 10 Pittsburgh companies in the S&P 500.
“I think that’s a great testament to Pittsburgh innovation, work ethic and even its thought diversification,” he said.
Fund ownership accounts for more than 57% ownership of Wabtec Corp. Investment funds also own more than 65% of Kennametal and 55% of CNX Resources Corp.
Morningstar does not specify what portion of the fund ownership in Pittsburgh-based companies is active or passive. But from 2012 to 2018, over 39% of all new money invested in the stock market has been buying passive investments.
The changing landscape of share ownership could give index fund managers more power than ever over companies through their corporate governance actions. By voting their proxies, fund managers could determine who serves on the boards of directors, how much top managers are paid, and even strongly influence corporate strategies.
So far, Green Tree-based L.B. Foster representatives say the company’s relationship with the investment community has not changed.
“We are seeing more ETFs and they are becoming more of the portfolio of investors of L.B. Foster, but it’s still the same message,” said Jim Maloney, chief financial officer and treasurer. “The message to the value investors hasn’t gone away.”
He said the company still has to tell its story to make sure all of the investment community understands the company, how each of its segments are doing and its future market outlook.
“Our investor relations is focused on the value investor who is using research to make investment decisions,” Mr. Maloney said.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.