DETROIT — Cindy Estrada’s journey has taken her from the dusty tomato fields of central California to the bargaining table where the United Automobile Workers union and General Motors will forge the future of about 48,500 U.S. workers.
Her career path to becoming the first woman to lead the UAW’s GM department shares parallels with GM CEO Mary Barra, with whom she is meeting about once a month leading up to this year’s labor negotiations.
They are among the point people — two glass ceiling breakers — in upcoming labor negotiations set against the backdrop of Michigan as a right-to-work state and strong feelings among union members that wages must increase considering big profits of recent years.
With the Detroit Three flush and autoworkers feeling unappreciated, negotiations could be a real donnybrook of old, when labor and management sparred aggressively over wages and working conditions years before the Great Recession and globalization changed the auto industry forever.
But if for no other reason, the negotiations should be different because of the people involved: two women who ascended to top positions in what were once firmly male-dominated executive ranks of labor and management.
Ms. Estrada traces her fervor for workplace issues to conversations of former Cadillac Fleetwood workers she overheard at her father’s bar.
“It was a big part of my life,” she said when asked about Leroy’s U.S. Star Bar. “I heard many stories of how hard work was in those plants. My uncles worked in some of them.”
Ms. Barra, who declined to be interviewed, is the daughter of a tool and die maker who was a UAW member. She’s from Waterford, Mich., raised and educated in the automaking culture of metro Detroit.
Ms. Barra became the first female CEO of GM or any major auto company early last year after coming up through the ranks as an engineer on the management side. A consensus-builder, she made notable changes in the culture of her departments along the way, including a seemingly mundane relaxation of the dress code that resonated strongly and has been cited often as proof that a stodgy GM culture was changing under her direction.
The women did not know each other before their latest promotions. But Ms. Estrada spoke highly of the CEO’s management style and vision.
“She really does want to work on changing the culture,” Ms. Estrada said. “She’s a problem solver and a very smart woman. So far, my experience with her has been nothing but positive.”
Organizing
Ms. Estrada’s grandparents were farmworkers who spent summers picking cherries in northern Michigan. Through a series of jobs her father held, Leroy Estrada and his wife, Margaret, built a life his five children considered comfortable.
“We just had a good middle-class life. We didn’t have an extravagant life,” Cindy Estrada said. “I remember my mom and dad being pretty happy. They helped us do things we wanted to do.”
Two experiences shaped her pride in being a young Latina. Next door to the bar was the United Farm Workers’ grape boycott office that connected her to her grandparents’ experience. She would learn her early organizing lessons at the side of two of Cesar Chavez’s closest disciples.
But Mexican Industries is where her UAW career began.
In the mid-1990s, the UAW launched what would become a futile organizing campaign. In June 1995, workers who were then making an average of $7 an hour rejected the UAW by a 623-265 vote.
“We lost, plain and simple,” said Ms. Estrada, who moved to California to help with the United Farm Workers.
Four years later, the UAW regrouped. This time, the voters approved UAW representation. But in June 2001, the company filed for bankruptcy and laid off the remaining 900 workers.
It was a pattern Ms. Estrada has seen several times in her career. After a hard-fought campaign, the UAW wins certification and negotiates a contract only to see the company either close the plant because their customer moved the work to another supplier or move the work to Mexico, Asia or another low-cost location.
Battling the state
In defeat and victory, the Mexican Industries campaigns left a deep imprint on Ms. Estrada.
“That involved mostly Spanish-speaking workers, a lot of them not documented,” she said. “Sometimes you want to coddle them. But what I learned from that [was] what workers want is for us to help them organize, not take care of them.”
In late 2013 and 2014, Ms. Estrada engaged in difficult negotiations covering 17,000 UAW-represented state workers. The talks came less than a year after the Republican Legislature passed and Gov. Rick Snyder signed Michigan’s right-to-work law.
Bargaining broke down, primarily over terms of state workers’ health care coverage. In January 2014 the state civil service commission forced both sides to accept a two-year contract with 2 percent raises each year, a 0.5 percent lump-sum payment in year one, and a standardized health care plan that raised some workers’ copays and deductibles.
Ms. Estrada acknowledges there was tension during those talks, but she said the UAW tried to emphasize that it was interested in finding more efficient ways to deliver state services without slashing jobs, wages and benefits.
“I’ve never seen Cindy lose her temper, but she’ll get angry about what she perceives as workplace injustice,” said former UAW president Bob King. “She’s open and flexible about finding creative solutions, but if a company is dishonest or abusive, they’ve got a real fight on their hands with her.”
She is now on a bigger stage. Last June, UAW president Dennis Williams assigned her to lead negotiations with GM. Her success ultimately will be measured by the 48,500 UAW members at the nation’s largest automaker.
Her counterpart across the table will be Rex Blackwell, a 31-year veteran of GM labor relations staff. But don’t underestimate the relationship evolving between Ms. Estrada and the GM CEO. They meet at least once every month or six weeks, Ms. Estrada said.
The ongoing negotiations kick into high gear Labor Day weekend. The current contract expires Sept. 15 with opportunities for short extensions.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.