Juan Henderson says he makes about $700 a week driving for Uber and claims he’s not only meeting his goal of earning extra money to help pay for his children’s education, but he’s developed a new affinity for driving.

“The weirdest trip I ever took was during a Pirates game — I miss the Pirates games. During the seventh inning, I get a call from three guys in business suits who want to go to Canonsburg,” he said. “That was a $98 fare. It was great.”

Mr. Henderson is sort of the ideal candidate for a ride-share company seeking to demonstrate its value in stimulating the economy: Someone seeking extra money who drives on his own time as a supplement to a full-time income.

He is part of the so-called “1099 economy,” a segment of the workforce driven largely by Silicon Valley startups such as Uber that rely heavily on independent contractors. A 1099 is the tax form an independent contractor files with the Internal Revenue Service.

Advertise with us

But as the practice of using non-employee workers has grown, it has come under increased scrutiny.

Most recently, appeals courts in Kansas and Oregon ruled that Moon-based FedEx Ground drivers were misclassified as independent contractors instead of as employees and can pursue claims for alleged unpaid wages and benefits. Similar cases have been filed in approximately 40 states. FedEx has said it will appeal the decisions.

Uber itself is the subject of two class-action lawsuits by drivers in Massachusetts and California who claim they are misclassfied as independent contractors.

Independent contractors or freelancers are staples of many industries, including driving and taxi companies. Creative sectors such as journalism and Web design use them, too, as well as any number of technology-based companies.

In the past few years, Silicon Valley has produced Lyft and Uber, as well as companies such as TaskRabbit, which enlists workers to do small household tasks for clients, and Homejoy, which offers home-cleaning services using independent contractors.

Advertise with us

While plenty of workers embrace the flexibility of driving for a ride-share company or see working as a freelancer as an attractive option, for others, it may be the only choice available to earn money during one of the toughest economic climates in a generation.

“This is a way to move costs off the employer and onto the employee,” said Ross Eisenbrey, of the Washington D.C.-based Economic Policy Institute. He added that it’s “not a coincidence that this is happening in the longest, slowest recovery in history.”

A recent survey by the Freelancers Union found that independent contractors, temporary workers and those working a second job make up about 34 percent of the U.S. workforce. It is hard to put together a comparison of how quickly this segment of the workforce has grown because it is not regularly tracked, but a 2005 Bureau of Labor Statistics survey estimated there were 10.3 million independent contractors accounting for 7.4 percent of the total workforce.

Mr. Eisenbrey noted many of the protections available to workers who are classified as employees are not available to independent contractors and freelancers.

Such workers are not eligible for overtime; can’t form unions; and aren't eligible for workers’ compensation if they are injured. “All these safety net programs do not help independent contractors, but are big financial incentives for employers to set up a workforce that they are not responsible for,” he said.

Advertise with us

The IRS and the Department of Labor have tried to tighten up the rules about who can be classified an independent contractor and who is an employee, entitled to benefits. The latest definition from the DOL states that having a worker sign an agreement stating he or she is an independent contractor isn't sufficient, because the “reality of the working relationship — and not the label given to the relationship in an agreement — is determinative.”

According to IRS rules, if a company has the right to control how the worker does his or her job, such as setting a schedule, and if the company controls business aspects of the worker’s job, such as providing tools and uniforms, then the worker should be considered an employee.

That was part of the case against FedEx: that it deducted so-called “company business costs” such as FedEx-branded uniforms from contractors’ paychecks. The company reconfigured its entire system to make sure it had no one-truck operators anymore, as a way to make sure employees worked for other people.

But some companies that use independent contractors as part of their business models aren't sure what the latest rules are.

Mike Dorfner, owner of audio visual production company MediaQuest in Crafton, started reconsidering his use of independent contractors when a competitor was fined for misclassifying an employee.

Advertise with us

“Nobody tells you this stuff is changing, but ignorance of the law is not an excuse,” Mr. Dorfner said.

His workers vary from highly-skilled technicians to entry-level, and most have other jobs, Mr. Dorfner said. Earlier this year, he told employees if they wanted to continue to work for him, they would become part-time employees. He has about 13 people on staff full-time, and does about $2 million in business annually.

“It’s been up to us to figure all this, out, because even some professionals we asked weren't sure what the latest rules are,” he said.

Ultimately, Mr. Dorfner said he wanted to treat workers fairly. But doing away with independent contractors has altered the way he’s been able to do business, because some rules vary from state-to-state.

“What if I need casual labor for a day for a set up in Boston?” he mused. “If I take that job, I have to comply with all the state laws there. I don’t really have the resources for that.” 

Advertise with us

The larger economic consequences of a 1099 workforce may not yet be known, but Mr. Eisenbrey said it does not bode well long term for workers. 

“We have so many people who want to work full-time and can only find part-time work,” he said. “And we have so many people who have just disappeared from the labor market. It’s a sign that things aren't healthy and strong yet. But if you haven’t worked in months, any job, even without protections, becomes a good option.”

Kim Lyons: klyons@Post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241