Make that 1,599.
Family physician Malcolm Harris says his name was wrongly included in a UPMC newspaper ad published Sunday that listed 1,600 doctors who will not be in Highmark’s network when the Pittsburgh insurer’s contract with UPMC expires Jan. 1.
“It is an error, and I am not a UPMC-owned physician,” said Dr. Harris, who has practiced medicine locally for 24 years.
According to UPMC, Dr. Harris was included on the list because “he sees patients at UPMC St. Margaret’s Family Health Clinic,” said spokesman Paul Wood, “therefore, those services will be out of network.”
Not exactly, Dr. Harris said Monday.
One day a week, he explained, he oversees residents at St. Margaret’s, consulting with them on patient care. The patient billing goes through the staff physician — him, in this case — “but I don’t get that income,” he said. He does receive a standard teaching fee.
Dr. Harris acknowledged he may be an anomaly; none of the 15 or so other independent physicians he knows appeared on the list. He had even guessed that he made the list because of his teaching at the health center. At the same time, he said, “It means they are relatively indiscriminate in how they check those things.”
Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said Monday that the insurer had “heard from several physicians who UPMC listed,” but he declined to go into specifics. “No one benefits from arguing with UPMC about doctors. We know the methodologies agreed to with UPMC [deciding which physicians will be in or out of Highmark’s network] and how our transition plan will consider them in-network.”
Dr. Harris, meanwhile, feels like part of the ground-level collateral damage in the war between the region’s largest provider and its largest insurer. Highmark subscribers represent 25 percent to 30 percent of his commercial insurance patients.
“I’m pretty angry,” he said. “I’m sure people are going to start calling up and asking as they start realizing” he was listed as being out of Highmark’s network next year.
As a solo practitioner, with a small office staff, he said, “It’s going to be a big pain in the neck to explain this to everyone. There’s going to be a lot of reassuring.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.