As state lawmakers spent the spring grappling with ways to raise money and close a projected budget shortfall of more than $1 billion, there was a potential revenue source sitting under their noses the whole time — the pot of uncollected, overdue taxes, much of it owed by Pennsylvania businesses.

That’s one reason the state’s Revenue Department has been ramping up efforts to recover past-due debts, armed with new laws that allow it to conduct expanded audits, as well as more aggressive — and efficient — tax collection.

Other states, counties and cities are trying to do the same, particularly post-Recession with tax collections stagnant.

Last year, Philadelphia stepped up its sequestration efforts, allowing the city to seize rental income bound for property owners who are delinquent on their tax debts. Vermont hired new compliance auditors. Counties are garnishing wages and seizing homes. Other states are simply filing liens and turning debts over to collection agencies more quickly.

Advertise with us

Crackdowns such as these aren't necessarily popular, particularly with those being targeted — but they are generally more popular than the alternative.

“It’s always an easier sell to say that we need more aggressive enforcement than to say, ‘Let’s raise taxes,’ ” said Chester County tax law attorney Kelly Phillips Erb.

One of the new Pennsylvania collection programs, authorized by 2010 legislation, is known as the Enhanced Revenue Collection Account. This fiscal year, the $15 million spent on the program and its hundreds of employees helped recover $162 million in tax debts and helped keep $69.3 million in “refunds avoided.”

PG graphic: ERCA

(Click image for larger version)

Advertise with us

More than half of the state’s recoveries ($83.9 million) come from businesses that haven’t turned over sales and use taxes, with an additional $20 million recovered in corporate net income taxes, capital stock taxes and foreign franchise taxes.

The ERCA program gives the Revenue Department “a way to invest in the positions we know will bring money,” said Elizabeth Brassell, press secretary for the department.

And there’s a lot of money out there — though it’s impossible to say how much.

Each month, the state updates its online lien list, a collection of businesses and individuals believed to owe taxes. (Liens are a claim against a property that must be satisfied before that property or business changes hands.)

As of this month, the list contains 137,600 liens, representing nearly $1.1 billion in unpaid taxes.The state files liens against delinquent businesses and individuals only when the Department of Revenue has “exhausted a number of other collections efforts, including notices, assessments and even phone calls and visits.”

Advertise with us

About $235 million originates in Allegheny County.

Those totals, however, aren't reflective of the actual debt owed by those taxpayers; they are merely estimates. Some liens have been paid down since originally filed by the state. Unpaid debts may also be higher than the recorded lien because, if a debt remains unpaid, taxes and penalties continue to accrue.

Other lien amounts are revised up or down once a business or individual agrees to a payment plan.

The lien list, Ms. Brassell said, is a “snapshot in time,” not reflective of the full amount owed to the state.

The state experimented with a “tax scofflaw” list starting in 2006, when it began publishing a list of businesses that had failed to pay employer withholding taxes and and sales taxes. (The new online lien list includes all delinquent state taxpayers).

Advertise with us

Though the state began culling data in July 2009, it waited a year to publish the scofflaw list. It did so to allow delinquent taxpayers to settle debts via a “tax amnesty” window, during which back taxes could be paid at reduced penalty and interest rates.

While the campaign was popular, the TV and radio spots that advertised the amnesty program were themselves controversial, saying Pennsylvania revenue agents “are [in] your telephone; we are your mail ... we are going to make your life very complicated ... Find us before we find you.”

After the amnesty window expired in June 2010, the state Department of Revenue released its online scofflaw list, hoping to “shame” delinquent taxpayers into settling up.

State liens exist prior to 2009, Ms. Brassell said, but there’s no central state accounting method that keeps track of those older debts. Those aren't ignored, she said, but the department’s tax collectors pursue debtors more vigorously “when we have a scent on the trail.”

Scents are developed more quickly these days. The state is stepping up “skip tracing” efforts, tracking down debtors who have no forwarding address or phone number. The state, through its ERCA program, also hired new phone agents for its delinquent tax call center. Liens are filed more quickly, too, now that the Revenue Department has moved away from its paper-based filing system.

Advertise with us

In 2012, the department was given legislative authority to attach a lien to a bank account. That means if a business’s taxes are past due, the department can get in touch with a bank and freeze an account until a tax debt is settled or at least until a payment plan is hashed out.

Also in 2012, the department was permitted to partner with a third-party contractor (the department hired Revenue Solutions Inc. of Pembroke, Mass.) that scours tax returns for questionable or fraudulent refunds. As of Sept. 15, the “benefits-based procurement” program had recovered nearly $11.8 million, yielding $7.74 million for the state with Revenue Solutions keeping $3.6 million for its own cut.

The state collected the money after first sending out tens of thousand of letters, telling taxpayers their refunds had been reduced or wiped out after further review. Others were asked to furnish additional documentation about deductions and work expenses.

While Revenue Solutions Inc. isn't a third-party collector — it just combs through the returns, while the state is still the party sending out letters and collecting money — the effect can be similar, Ms. Erb, the tax law attorney, said.

Because those companies work on commission — a cut of the money recovered — they have greater motivation to catch errors than resolve questions, she said. A taxpayer receiving a letter questioning a $50 deduction, even a legitimate one, is likely to pay the extra tax rather than put up a fight.

Advertise with us

While taxpayers aren't thrilled, the Revenue Department would rather catch the money before it goes out the door than have to track it down later.

We’re “catching the errors earlier, before it gets to the lien process,” Ms. Brassell said. “We’re not waiting until it gets into the collections stream.”