The city may seek to retain ownership of the Strip District produce terminal in the negotiations over its proposed redevelopment.

Kevin Acklin, chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, said that is one of the options the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority will explore as it enters into talks with Chicago-based McCaffery Interests and Rubino Partners of Pittsburgh over the future of the terminal.

The URA board voted last week to enter into 90 days of exclusive negotiations with both developers to see if they could marry two competing visions into a master development.

McCaffery is proposing to convert the terminal into housing, with some office and retail space, while Rubino is pitching a plan to create a giant marketplace throughout its 1,533-foot length.

Advertise with us

The URA has owned the building since 1981 but has considered selling it as part of a potential redevelopment. In fact, the Buncher Co., which had been managing the building for the URA up until last week, had an option to buy it for $1.8 million.

Mr. Acklin, URA board chairman, said the agency will explore a number of options in its talks with McCaffery and Rubino, including a possible sale, and that nothing has been determined.

But the preference at this point may be to retain ownership. Mr. Acklin said that would keep the Strip landmark in public hands for future generations and would give future mayors and council members the ability to control its destiny.

It also would ensure that the building itself would be preserved, Mr. Acklin said. Buncher lost its development rights and the option to buy the terminal when it proposed demolishing the western third of it, running into trouble with Mr. Peduto.

Even under a lease, the city wants the developers to pay the same real estate taxes on the property as if they owned it, Mr. Acklin said. He believes they are required to do so under leases that run more than 30 years (the URA is proposing a 99-year lease).

Advertise with us

But even if that is not the case, the city would want the developers to do so as part of a contractual covenant, he said. That would ensure that the city, county and city school district would profit from the redevelopment.

“We would like to test the feasibility of [a lease], especially if from an economic standpoint it’s not going to make a difference to the taxing bodies, and that’s a key point,” Mr. Acklin said.

Rubino and McCaffery officials could not be reached for comment.

But state Sen. Jim Ferlo, a URA board member who abstained in last week’s vote and criticized the proposal for co-developers, blasted the idea of the city retaining ownership of the building.

“This makes no sense whatsoever and it’s political pandering to an elite group of Mayor Peduto backers including Mr. Pfaffmann et al,” he stated in an email, referring to architect Rob Pfaffmann, who is part of the Rubino group. “If the majority of the site is intended to be residential, why would this remain a publicly owned facility?”

Advertise with us

Mr. Ferlo said he supports McCaffery’s $30 million plan to turn the terminal into 118 residential units and 14 live-work lofts with some additional office and retail space.

“I believe the Rubino/​Pfaffmann plan is contrary to the interests of the Main Street merchants along Penn and Smallman in the heart of the Strip and completely ignores the large public investment in our Public Market House at 24th and Penn,” he said.

Mr. Acklin said he has never met Mike Rubino, who heads Rubino Partners, or had any discussions with Mr. Pfaffmann. But he believes the two proposals can work in unison. He said McCaffery’s plan had reserved part of the building for some type of market use.

There also may be some potential to add onto the terminal at its western end — the same end Buncher proposed to demolish — to give a marketplace more room.

But he added those are all issues subject to negotiation.

Advertise with us

“My approach to this is not to dictate a solution. We’re an investor in this project. We've invested serious funds [in the terminal]. We don’t intend to miss an opportunity to have transformational development,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.