Penn-Trafford might be the unicorn of WPIAL softball programs.
Since 1975, when the PIAA held its first state championships, there have been 24 schools that have won titles in various classifications. Of those 24, 23 also won a WPIAL crown at some point in their history.
Only the Warriors have won a state championship — they’ve done it twice, in 2019 and 2025 — without ever winning a WPIAL title.
“Being a unicorn, I’ll take it,” Penn-Trafford coach Denny Little said. “What’s better than two state titles? Three state titles. That’s how we’ve got to think. I care about the WPIAL, but I don’t stress it.”
Though winning a WPIAL title would be nice, Penn-Trafford isn’t emphasizing it as it grinds through the season hoping to have an opportunity to get back to PennWest California and the finals for the second year in a row.
“We started to build it three years before we won the state title last year and, this year we’ve got the Grand Canyon after we lost seven starters,” Little said. “But we just stick to the process.”
Penn-Trafford lost to Shaler in a 2-1 pitcher’s duel in 11 innings a year ago, as Warriors pitcher Allyson Paulone did not allow an earned run in the loss to the Titans and pitching counterpart Bria Bosiljevac. Though the Warriors won a rematch March 25 with the Titans, 6-1, Bosiljevac did not pitch.
Paulone is the one constant for Penn-Trafford this season, as the junior has added a few miles per hour to her fastball thanks to her offseason training. But even with that, it might be a little while before she is the pitcher she was a year ago.
“We know that she’s a really talented singer. She sang the National Anthem for the Pirates and Pitt, so she hit me with the fact that she really wanted to do the [school] play,” Little said. “I’m the type of person who knows that people have a lot of different talents. She has three or four and I told her I’m all for it.”
With final dress rehearsals this week and performances coming up, she has been burning the candle at both ends. But once the curtain falls, it will rise on the diamond.
At that point, Little believes Paulone will get back to being the pitcher she was a year ago, the one who nearly threw a perfect game in the WPIAL Class 5A semifinals against North Hills.
“Physically she’s there, but mentally right now, she [has been] diverted. That’s OK because she’s still pitching well,” Little said. “I just have a feeling after next Sunday she’s going to be able to focus. It’s important to her and I’m not about to hold her back from that.”
It also might be one of the reasons Penn-Trafford took an early 11-5 beating from Armstrong before coming back to win its past five. But Paulone having the occasional bad start is nothing new. She was shelled in a 14-11 win against Chartiers Valley in the WPIAL quarterfinals in 2025 right before she tossed the one-hitter against North Hills.
In the meantime, other players have had to grow into new roles.
“We see the girls we think are going to donate to the season and you can see who really wants it in their eye. And we’re always wrong. There’s always someone who steps up,” Little said. “This week it’s been Gabi Rubbe, who has kind of been watching this for three years and now she thinks it’s her turn. She’s talented, but she’s really surprised me this week with the offense she’s produced.”
Changing of the guard
Seneca Valley had one of the most feared pitchers in WPIAL history when Lexie Hames dominated the circle and led the Raiders to two WPIAL Class 6A titles and three championship appearances.
But Hames, the two-time Pennsylvania Gatorade Player of the Year, now is at Clemson. And her mother and head coach, Marlesse, opted to leave with her.
Now, it’s up to Marlesse’s assistant the past few years, Joe DeCristoforo, to guide the program in the post-Hames era.
“We’re kind of still doing the same sorts of things,” DeCristoforo said. “It’s just a little bit different.”
This year, instead of having that one dominant pitcher, Seneca Valley will have a pair of hurlers as senior Abby Kalkowski and junior Rachael Dunmire will split duties early in the season.
“Abby was a backup to Lexie the past couple years and she also plays other positions when she’s not pitching,” DeCristoforo said. “I think both of our pitchers have embraced this. They might not have as many strikeouts, but because both of our pitchers also play other positions and know they have a defense behind them.”
Seneca Valley also has increased its run production this year. The Raiders are averaging 8.6 runs per game as compared to 6.9 a year ago, which is necessary considering that they were only giving up 1.4 in 2025 as compared to 3.1 through six games in 2026.
“They’re making more adjustments at the plate, not just game-to-game, but pitch-to-pitch,” DeCristoforo said. “It’s nice being able to come out and score a few runs in the first inning and it’s all about that ebb and flow of the game.”
Quick hits
• Elizabeth Forward has opened the season 7-1 and has not lost to a team from the WPIAL. The Warriors have won seven in a row after a loss to Spring-Ford at a spring training tournament in Florida.
• Indiana is in first place in Class 4A Section 1 and has taken over the top spot in dominating fashion. The Little Indians have outscored their section foes, 45-1, in four games.
• Heading into Wednesday, the only team in the WPIAL not to have played a game is Ellis School. The Tigers were slated to travel to Serra Catholic Wednesday for their Class 1A Section 3 opener.
• In eight wins this season, Chartiers-Houston has outscored its opponents, 124-4. The Bucs’ 15.5 runs per game is by far the best in the WPIAL.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.