An Arnold man was found not guilty Tuesday of involuntary manslaughter in the 2008 death of his 4-month-old son.

Jason Gmuer, 35, formerly of Castle Shannon, was charged with shaking his son, Nathan, early in the morning hours of Dec. 18, 2008, as he watched him and his twin brother, while their mother was at work.

Mr. Gmuer wasn’t charged in the case until some two years later, and medical examiner Karl Williams of Allegheny County ruled the boy's cause of death as undetermined.

However, during a non-jury trial before Common Pleas Judge Donald E. Machen that stretched for more than two years, assistant district attorney Lisa Pellegrini said Nathan’s death was clearly homicide and called four physicians who said the baby died from shaking — noting severe retinal hemorrhaging and bleeding in his brain.

Advertise with us

“It doesn't take much to harm a child that tiny,” Ms. Pellegrini told Judge Machen during argument.

However, defense attorney William Difenderfer called his own expert who testified that the boy had a blood clot in his lungs, and died of natural causes — a clotting disorder.

The expert also said Mr. Gmuer has a coagulation disorder, as well.

But in a brief to the court, Ms. Pellegrini said that physicians who testified in the case said there was only a 25 percent change Nathan had it, and that even if he did, it would not have resulted in brain or retinal hemmorhaging.

“[T]his coagulation disorder, as it pertains to the victim, is nothing more than mere speculation and cannot form a sound basis in reasonable doubt,” she wrote. “Before this night, the victim was growing and developing as a normal child; he was smiling, laughing and responding to those around him. He had no history of disease or illness.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Gmuer, she continued, was the last person to hold Nathan before he entered a comatose state.

But, Mr. Difenderfer argued, “There is no evidence in this case that my client handled this child in any inappropriate way.”

After the verdict, Mr. Gmuer praised the verdict.

“The judge spoke the truth today,” he said.

Mr. Gmuer, who has not been permitted contact with his other son because of the charges, will now work to become reacquainted with him, Mr. Difenderfer said.