HARRISBURG -- The first Republican defendant in the Bonusgate corruption probe has been bound over for trial.

Harrisburg District Justice William Wenner today ordered former caucus open-records officer John Zimmerman to stand trial on charges he obstructed justice by helping conceal evidence being sought by subpoena.

Defense attorney Tom Bergstrom had argued that Mr. Zimmerman didn't know what was in boxes that were moved from a storage area in the Capitol to campaign offices across the street. Further, he didn't know investigators were seeking the contents, Mr. Bergstrom said.

"If you don't know what's in the boxes, then you haven't done anything wrong," he told Judge Wenner.

Advertise with us

Deputy Attorney General Christopher Carusone, meanwhile, argued that Mr. Zimmerman "actively misled the prosecution."

Whether his actions were a crime is for a jury to decide, Judge Wenner said.

Mr. Zimmerman is charged with two counts of hindering prosecution and obstruction.

The judge is expected to rule Thursday on whether prosecutors have enough evidence to bring to trial nine others associated with the caucus. Among them are state Rep. John Perzel of Philadelphia and former Rep. Brett O. Feese of Lycoming.

They are fighting charges related to allegations they used state funds improperly and then tried to conceal their alleged crimes by hiding evidence.

Advertise with us

Testifying under a grant of immunity, Perzel secretary Lori Lochetto said that in 2008 she extracted political materials from boxes stored in the Capitol. The materials included stationery from Mr. Perzel's 2004 re-election campaign.

Her testimony came during the fourth day of an unusually long preliminary hearing.

At the core of the case are allegations they spent about $20 million in public money between 2003 and 2007 on contracts with computer companies that created programs to track voter behavior, analyze political demographics and guide campaigns.

Witness Sheila Flickinger, who worked for both the legislature and the House Republican Campaign Committee, testified that the committee also issued small checks to the computer companies. She said those payments were a "cover" and that they weren't nearly enough compensation for the amount of campaign work those companies provided.

Evidence gathered by the Office of Attorney General shows the campaign committees payments to various computer vendors totaled about $75,000 between 2003 and 2007.

Advertise with us

The charges in this case grew out of the Bonusgate investigation, in which three people associated with the House Democrats already were found guilty. Two others have been acquitted.

The preliminary hearing began a month ago but was continued after three days of testimony because of attorneys' scheduling conflicts. Testifying last month were aides who said they spent as much as half their state-paid time doing campaign work.

The hearing is expected to continue this morning with testimony from two key witnesses: John Hanley and J. Anthony Painter.

Mr. Hanley was director of district operations and Mr. Painter was director of the Republican Information Technology Department. In a presentment last year, grand jurors said those departments routinely provided state workers for Republican political campaigns.