The West Mifflin Area school board has rehired former girls high school basketball coach Phil Shar, nearly one year after his contract was opened by former Superintendent Patrick Risha, after Mr. Shar publicly criticized Mr. Risha.
Mr. Shar, who is now a school director, was rehired by a 5-1-1 vote of the board. School director Kathy Bracco voted against the hiring and school director Ned Mervos abstained "due to legal action."
"It feels pretty good to be back," Mr. Shar said after the meeting.
Mr. Shar will coach on a volunteer basis and not be paid by the district. He will remain a school director.
Mrs. Bracco and Mr, Mervos were among five school directors who voted to replace Mr. Shar after 19 years last June with one of his former assistants.
Neither Mr, Shar nor district solicitor Jack Cambest would say if the rehiring was part of the recent settlement of a federal lawsuit Mr, Shar filed against the district in December.
As part of the settlement, Mr, Shar received $30,000, but neither he nor district officials are permitted to discuss the settlement because of a confidentiality clause.
Mr. Shar had been a long-time, highly successful girls coach at West Mifflin High School, had his contract opened by Mr. Risha in late May 2009 after he appeared at school board meetings to criticize the superintendent's plans to build a new middle school on the high school campus and his general handling of the district's finances.
Mr. Shar also made critical remarks about Mr. Risha in local newspapers.
A month after his contract was opened, the school board voted 5-4 to replace Mr. Shar with one of his former assistants.
After he was replaced as coach, Mr, Shar ran a successful write-in campaign for school board, knocking out incumbent Diana Olasz. Shortly after the election, Mr. Risha retired abruptly with two years remaining on his contract.
Mr. Shar filed the suit in December claiming that his right to free speech had been violated when he was fired from his coaching job for speaking in opposition to the superintendent. It asked for monetary damages and a return to his coaching job.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.