Republican congressional candidate Mary Beth Buchanan today accused her primary opponent Keith Rothfus of being a Democrat throughout the 1990s, but the evidence she relied on does not confirm that.
At a news conference outside the Allegheny County elections building this morning, Ms. Buchanan distributed a voter history printout showing Mr. Rothfus, an Edgeworth attorney, voted as a Democrat from November 1990 through May 2003. Rothfus "wasn't just trying to hide his lack of experience -- he was hiding the fact that for more than 13 years he was a registered Democrat," Ms. Buchanan said. While it's understandable for voters to change parties, she continued, "what voters shouldn't have to tolerate is a candidate for office who distorts his own record, while lying about his opponent."
But the very printout she used to make that claim may be distorted.
In the 1990s -- said county elections director Mark Wolosik -- the county did not keep registration information on its computer database. It was kept by hand on paper records. The printout she used is from the new voting record system the county adopted in 2003, when Mr. Rothfus was indeed a Democrat -- he says he switched his registration the year before to support pro-life Democrat Bob Casey over Ed Rendell in the primary for governor. Records show he switched back to Republican in the spring of 2004.
So no county computerized records -- including the printout Ms. Buchanan distributed, or the database in the county office building Downtown -- can tell which party Mr. Rothfus was registered in the decade before, only that he cast votes. "The only historical data we stored in the [old] computer system was the voting history, not the party," Mr. Wolosik said. At the very best, her printout was "inconclusive," he said.
The Rothfus campaign says he registered as a Republican in 1990 after settling in Edgeworth after law school, and voted in Virginia from 1994-1996 while working for a college there.
"This sloppy approach to facts and evidence sheds a great deal of light on her failed record in high profile prosecutions when she served as United States Attorney," Mr. Rothfus said in a press release.
The Republicans are battling to face U.S. Rep. Jason Altmire, D-McCandless, in November.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.