A legal brief filed by the Westmoreland County district attorney in connection with an investigation into the fatal shooting of a teenage neighbor of state Sen. Robert Regola suggests for the first time that Louis Farrell's death was a crime, rather than an accident or suicide.
Louis, 14, was found dead behind his home July 22 with a gunshot wound of the head. A handgun registered to Sen. Regola was found next to him.
Until now, both District Attorney John Peck and state police investigators have refused to say whether Louis died by accident, suicide or homicide. The county coroner's office has not ruled on a manner of death.
However, in the brief filed last week opposing efforts by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette to unseal a search warrant affidavit executed on Sen. Regola's home, the DA's office wrote:
"The affidavit would communicate to the general public that the District Attorney believes that someone may be guilty of a crime, and yet there will be no context in which to evaluate that opinion."
Elsewhere, Mr. Peck said: "Should the affidavit be released, it would essentially provide a roadmap for perpetrator(s) as well as the press, seriously compromising and potentially destroying both the integrity and the effectiveness of the entire investigation."
The DA's office also wrote: "A death investigation suggests the possibility of crime at its most serious, creating a heightened public interest in successful prosecution."
Mr. Peck also argues for the need to ensure that potential jurors are not influenced and to safeguard fair trial rights for anyone potentially charged with a crime.
Nowhere in the 48-page brief does Mr. Peck mention the possibility of Louis's death being suicide or accident.
Neither Mr. Peck nor Assistant District Attorney Christiann Otto Flanigan, who together submitted the brief, could be reached this morning for comment.
Investigators have not said when exactly they believe Louis died, whether anyone was with him, or how the senator's 9-mm handgun ended up alongside his body.
Authorities have said Louis was pet-sitting for Sen. Regola on July 21 when the senator was accepting an award in Harrisburg with his wife. The senator's oldest son, Robert Regola IV, was at an amusement park all day and returned home that evening.
At 11:30 p.m., Louis and Robert IV had a phone conversation. What happened next is unknown. The next time anyone is known to have seen Louis is around 8:30 a.m. the next morning, when his father, attorney J. Douglas Farrell, found his son dead about 200 feet from his house.
Louis's family has vehemently discounted the possibility that the boy killed himself.
Mr. Peck is on record as saying that Sen. Regola was likely not reckless in how he stored his handgun, meaning it would be doubtful the senator could be prosecuted if a minor obtained the gun.
"Is there some recklessness?" Mr. Peck said at a July news conference. "That element doesn't jump out at you in this particular case."
The Post-Gazette and Tribune-Review have both sued to unseal the search warrant affidavit obtained Aug. 8 and executed the next day. Westmoreland County Common Pleas Judge Rita D. Hathaway both granted the warrant and sealed it for up to 60 days.
Under law, authorities can ask that a warrant be sealed temporarily for "good cause."
While executing the warrant, state police seized a small safe belonging to Robert IV and a computer. It is not known what, if anything else, was taken.
In his brief, Mr. Peck described the affidavit supporting the search as "striking and extraordinary for the type of information and the delicate details it includes." He said it is "extremely different" from a previous search warrant executed within days of discovering Louis's body. That warrant was not sealed.
The sealed affidavit "describes in detail the nature, scope and direction of the investigation. It specifies leads, refers to conversations and events, quotes witness statements verbatim, and provides the names of various individuals involves."
In arguing for the affidavit to remain sealed, Mr. Peck and Ms. Flanigan told the judge that granting a motion to unseal would be "utterly inappropriate and unprecedented."
They also said keeping the document sealed is necessary to preserve the privacy of "everyone involved, including two minors, and promoting the safety and sanctity of this community."
"Those interests," they wrote, "are sufficient to override and outweigh any interest in favor of disclosure at this time."
Mr. Peck also said redacting parts of the affidavit is not an option because essentially the entire document would have to be redacted.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.