CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- West Virginians have decided not to bank on the stock market to cure the state's pension problems, rejecting a measure aimed at repairing its ailing retirement system by selling up to $5.5 billion in bonds.

Yesterday's special election, which sought to amend the state's constitutional ban on taking on debt, is not expected to deter other state and local governments as they examine whether to shore up pension plans by issuing bonds.

But the defeat leaves West Virginia with the more traditional method of curing pension debts: diverting the needed funds from the state's budget. A court-ordered payment plan siphons an ever-increasing amount from the budget annually until 2034.

This year's payment will take about $350 million from general revenue.

Advertise with us

"We were hoping that we would be able to get better control over how much the state was going to have to pay each year," said Judy Hale, president of the American Federation of Teachers-West Virginia, which supported the bond plan. "This just means there will less money for other things as those payments increase."

Complete but unofficial results showed 54 percent of voters had rejected the pension bond measure, while 46 percent supported it. Democratic Gov. Joe Manchin now says he wants to move on to other issues and will leave the pension problem to future governors and legislatures.

Massey Energy CEO and Chairman Don Blankenship spent several hundred thousand dollars in personal funds on radio, television and direct mail ads, as well as automated phone calls, urging voters to defeat the ballot issue.

"Saturday was truly a beautiful day in West Virginia, thanks to the voters," said Blankenship, who had argued that the state would be taking too large a risk by sending such a large sum of money to Wall Street.

West Virginia is not alone in its pension woes: The 127 state and local plans tracked by the National Association of State Retirement Administrators suffer from a combined shortfall of $279 billion. For West Virginia and 12 other states, unfunded pension liabilities exceed the state budget.