At 7:02 p.m. on Tuesday evening in the faculty lounge of Osborne Elementary School, the monthly meeting of the Haysville Borough Council was called to order. With six members in attendance plus Mayor Mike Kerr, nearly 10% of the borough’s population had assembled to perform its public business.

With 81 residents, Haysville is the smallest municipality by population in Allegheny County — though Council President Amy Paff informed me a new family had recently moved in, so they think they’re up to 86. Haysville is often held out, sometimes by this very writer, as a perfect emblem of the county’s absurd degree of governmental fragmentation.

But rather than consider tiny Haysville in the abstract, I wanted to see the place and its leaders in action. This is what I found.

The borough

Haysville is situated on the right bank of the Ohio River between Glenfield (pop. 212) to the southeast and Glen Osborne (pop. 590) to the northwest. It’s part of the Quaker Valley School District, which means it exists in orbit around Sewickley.

Advertise with us

The borough will celebrate its 125th anniversary next year. According to its website, it began as a tract of land owned by Mexican War veteran John Hay, who built an inn in the hills above the river. That getaway, like so many others of the era, marketed its access to certain “curative waters.”

These waters, as we will see, are now the source of Haysville’s most pressing problems.

Almost all of the borough’s residents live on one of two streets: South Avenue, which runs adjacent to Norfolk Southern railroad tracks and provides access to about 15 riverfront homes, and River Road, which runs up the ravine where Hay’s inn used to be.

This is where the borough’s office is located. In addition to being Haysville’s official address, 24 River Road is also the home of long-time Council Secretary Mary Beth Conlin. Council meetings used to take place around the kitchen table here and at other officials’ residences before they moved to Osborne Elementary.

But there’s still a relic from that era: Conlin posts council’s monthly agenda, per the state’s Sunshine Act for government transparency, on her front door.

Advertise with us

The most pressing item on those agendas is almost always related to The Intersection. Yes, there is just one intersection in Haysville. But it’s a doozy.

The intersection

Imagine you’re driving outbound on Pa. Route 65/Ohio River Boulevard, the river on your left. The Intersection begins with a slip ramp on the right that gives access to Beaver Road on an embankment above the highway but also River Road up the tight valley.

On the other side of Route 65 is where things get hairy.

First, River Road immediately crosses three railroad tracks, with barely enough space for one car to rest without getting blasted by an oncoming locomotive. Then, immediately after that, are Haysville’s South Avenue to the left and Glen Osborne’s Railroad Avenue to the right. This is the only access to either of these roads, and the homes and businesses on them.

Safety at The Intersection has been a concern for decades. But there’s another problem: Those “curative waters” flow underneath the entire operation.

Advertise with us

In fact, four separate structures span the little creek. PennDOT handles Route 65 and its ramp, while Norfolk Southern handles the railroad portion.

But little South Avenue, owned and maintained by Haysville, actually has two structures holding it up: steel beams adjacent to the tracks and a corrugated steel pipe just beyond.

The pipe is doing alright and provides just enough stability that vehicles can pass on the far side of the intersection.

The beams, however, are badly deteriorated, leaving one of South Avenue’s two narrow lanes unusable. Fixing that — and preserving half of Haysville’s lifeline to the world — will be very expensive.

Looking down South Ave, one of the two streets entirely in Haysville, Allegheny County’s smallest municipality by population. (Brandon McGinley/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The money

Councilwoman Sara Horsey didn’t realize she was moving to Haysville when in 2020 she bought a home on Sycamore Street, one of a few nearby roads with addresses that nudge across the municipal line. But it was very lucky for the borough that she did.

Advertise with us

Horsey is professional engineer. In fact, she engineers bridges.

She arrived a moment late for Tuesday’s meeting, but she arrived prepared. In addition to bringing her experience and PennDOT contacts to the faculty lounge table, she brought packets of charts and graphs on the borough’s finances.

The engineering review for the South Avenue bridge will cost at least $250,000, and that’s just the cost to generate an estimate for the construction. But the project is within the zone of influence granted to railroads, so Norfolk Southern will also have to review the report — for a fee, council members heard, of $35,000.

Annual property tax revenue for the Borough of Haysville is about $37,000.

Much of the meeting was dedicated to discussing applications for grants to save South Avenue. The most promising is from the Local Share Account, which provides access to up to $1 million from the state’s gambling revenues. This would be a planning grant, covering the engineering (and the railroad fees) but not the construction.

Advertise with us

PennDOT offers grants from its Multimodal Transportation Fund for construction, Horsey said, but they require a 30% local match, which is far beyond what Haysville can afford. She is searching for other zero-match programs the borough could access, especially if Local Share doesn’t come through.

When it comes time to rebuild the bridge, Horsey said the cost could run anywhere from $500,000 to $5 million.

The trash

The other main agenda item at the meeting involved much smaller figures. But the council members addressed it with at least as much care as the million-dollar bridge.

Waste Management is raising its rates for residential trash pickup, from about $16 to $26 per address per month. Haysville leaders take pride in absorbing this cost for the borough’s 40 households — it’s one of the few municipalities that still do so — but under the circumstances it can’t take on another $4,800 per year. In fact, with an $8,000 deficit, it can no longer pay for trash at all.

For at least 15 minutes, council members weighed their options: Ask Waste Management to bill residents monthly (for a fee) or front the cost and have Jordan Tax Service collect the fees annually (for another fee).

Advertise with us

The question was deliberated as neighbors looking out for neighbors, and they concluded it would be easier for those on budgets to be charged monthly.

Another necessity that tormented council members was raising taxes.

At 6.43 mills, the borough’s rate compares unfavorably with larger neighbors, but actually quite well with other small communities, whose rates are often in double-digits. They briefly considered whether the Waste Management deal would allow them to skip the hike, but concluded that with the South Avenue project coming, they just can’t afford to stand pat.

So they increased the millage by 0.22, about 3%, which will raise $1,300 or so.

The future

As I witnessed this little drama unfold, a thought came to mind that I didn’t expect.

Advertise with us

I wished there were more Haysvilles.

This was the closest to the idealized democracy of Athens there can be in the modern age: everyday citizens forced by circumstance and motivated by neighbor-care to steward their little community, their shared inheritance.

If there were more such councils and committees tasked with such small-but-important matters, how many more regular people would step up to the challenge — would find within themselves capacities they didn’t know they had, would commit themselves to their neighbors instead of passing them by with eyes blinded by screens and minds preoccupied with their private concerns?

Yet there can’t be more Haysvilles, there mustn’t be. Even this Haysville, as an independent government with all the same powers and duties as those with 100 times more taxpayers, shouldn’t be.

If that corrugated steel pipe gives way, or if their engineer-councilwoman gets transferred out of state, or if none of the grants (that typically require heavy lobbying) come through, or if Norfolk Southern or Waste Management decides to squeeze them further — that’s it. Game over.

Advertise with us

After they adjourned, I asked Haysville’s leaders if their little thing was sustainable. Councilwoman Horsey was circumspect, admitting the borough lacks economies of scale that their neighbors have.

But Council President Paff was defiant: Haysville can’t be “gobbled up” by a neighbor or folded into a Greater Sewickley because no one would look out for their interests, for their neighbors, like they could.

Neither I nor anyone who had witnessed the meeting could do anything but agree, and I didn’t dare press the issue further.

We parted in the lobby of the Osborne Elementary School, and the members of the Haysville Borough Council pulled out of the lot in a small caravan, some going to South Avenue and others to River Road.

But I pulled through The Intersection and headed toward my own home, happier for having seen this place’s civic life in action and sadder that necessity was closing in on it.