To try to assist consumers in search of a quality nursing home — or at least seeking one close to home that’s not among the worst of them — the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services for years has provided star ratings through its Nursing Home Compare website.
Nursing homes receive anywhere from 1 to 5 stars in different categories and are also given an overall rating on that scale.
The measurements and results can be a little hard for the average person to use and analyze, and that’s where advocacy groups like the Long Term Care Community Coalition step in. The national coalition does things like organize the government’s star ratings by state and ranking, such as creating a report showing which 116 Pennsylvania nursing homes received just one star overall, while also displaying their ratings in the various sub-categories.
The group reported this month that the latest government ratings were significant for assessing staffing levels for the first time by using verifiable, payroll-based records from each nursing home’s database. The Nursing Home Compare website information has received some criticism previously for relying too much on what nursing homes report, without means of verifying their data.
So now, by using the community coalition’s analysis, one can know with some confidence that among the 116 1-star rated facilities in Pennsylvania (about one of every six nursing homes), there are just four in southwestern Pennsylvania where staffing levels are so low that they also merited just 1 star in that category. Those four are Baldwin Health Center, Mountainview Specialty Care Center in Greensburg, The Grove at Latrobe and Transitions Healthcare in Washington, Pa.
It’s wise for individuals and families to be armed with such information when making decisions about nursing home placements, but officials from both the industry and consumer organizations stress that such ratings — whether good or bad — shouldn’t be the sole factor considered. It is recommended that people also visit facilities themselves, take tours, try to talk to residents and/or employees, and use word-of-mouth from anyone who has had prior experience with the home.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.