Deciding when to draw Social Security can sometimes feel like confounding post-retirement calculus. But it’s one of the most important decisions a person can make.
Age 62 marks the earliest you can file for Social Security. That’s before the full retirement age — between 65 and 67. And that means your benefits will be reduced.
Experts say deciding what age to begin drawing benefits is an individual decision, based on a person’s finances, expected longevity and marital status among other. It’s why they suggest you should always consult with a financial planner before making the choice.
Generally, they caution against drawing at age 62.
“Sixty-two really is only ideal for someone who might have health issues or who is a single individual,” said Christopher Cannon, a wealth management adviser at the financial planning firm RetireRightPGH, headquartered in Upper St. Clair. “It’s a very large difference between what could be collected between 62 and 70.”
Early retirement may influence the decision as well, added Scott Tobe, the founder of Signature Financial Planning on Mount Washington.
“In a situation where someone is really motivated to retire, and that money could potentially be what they need to do that — I’ve seen situations where that is the case, and therefore it makes sense to take it earlier,” he said.
It may not always be the most sound-claiming strategy, but Robert “Casey” Gibbs — a managing director at Hapanowicz & Associates, based Downtown — says people choose it often. He estimates 40 percent of people, most of whom likely are unaware of the various claiming strategies available to them, file for their benefits right at age 62.
That’s of the 90 percent of people who begin drawing at or before their full retirement age, according to data from the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.

“It could be that the higher wage earner waits until full retirement age, 66 or 67, when they’re maximizing the full benefit — sometimes taking it out as late as age 70 to get the full enhanced benefit,” Mr. Gibbs said, adding that the strategy is not too common.
Married couples have access to more claiming strategies like filing for restricted benefits, which allows them to hold off receiving benefits checks while the value of their benefits grow. It’s part of a string of “aggressive claiming strategies,” some of which were eliminated by the Budget Act of 2015. The legislation reformed some loopholes in Social Security and reallocated funds from the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund to the Disability Insurance fund to keep the latter above water.
The restricted benefits strategy was left unscathed by the bill. For a couple to use it, both spouses have to be at full retirement age. One spouse — usually the higher wage earner — can restrict his or her benefits and file for a spousal benefit, which will provide him or her with a check equal to a portion of the spouse’s benefits while their own benefits grow. Then, when he or she reaches a higher age, usually 70, he or she can grab the restricted benefits, which have matured.
Mr. Gibbs said he’s seen families who have gained up to an extra $250,000 than they would have otherwise using this strategy, which is left untouched by the 2015 law. (basically $250,000 represents the difference between what they ended up getting with the strategy vs. what they would have gotten without it)
In other cases, Mr. Cannon said he helps clients explore the option of delaying Social Security and using other assets such as interest from stocks and bonds to support them through retirement.
Changes in strategy aren’t the only things that have changed in recent years. Alarm bells are ringing nationally as the reserves funding Social Security dwindle. It has younger workers concerned, and has led many who are on the cusp of making the decision to file at age 62, fearing that waiting longer might decrease their benefits.
To Mr. Gibbs, it’s a rash, if expected, decision.
“They’ve heard some rumors that it’s going bankrupt, that it’s going belly up,” Mr. Gibbs said of his clients. “It’s the trust fund that depletes in about 2035, the whole system doesn’t collapse. If there isn’t a fix before then, approximately 75 percent of the benefits can be paid out.”
Both he and Mr. Tobe from Signature Financial say they urge younger people who are planning ahead for retirement to not count on Social Security benefits being around when they retire. Instead, they should plan around alternative income such as investments or proceeds from 401k retirement accounts to working a second job in case the program collapses.
“It’s not that we feel that it’s going to go away, but that possibility certainly exists, and so it’s just not something that we want our clients to rely on,” Mr. Tobe said. “If it’s there, great, it’s a nice bonus.”
Brandon Dixon, a former Post-Gazette intern on the business staff, is a rising junior at Harvard College.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.