Let’s get a few things straight regarding the 2023 Emmy Awards.

First and foremost, this Anthony Anderson-hosted ceremony will be taking place Jan. 15 at 8 p.m. instead of its original Sept. 18 air date after being delayed by the recently settled SAG-AFTRA and Writers Guild of America strikes. That part should be easy enough to swallow.

It is, however, objectively strange to have reached 2024 and still be celebrating shows like AMC’s “Better Call Saul,” Disney+’s “Andor” and HBO’s “The White Lotus” that finished their most recent seasons in 2022.

Only shows that debuted between June 1, 2022, and May 31, 2023, were eligible for 2023 Emmy nominations, which is why FX’s “The Bear” and Hulu’s “Only Murders in the Building” are being recognized for their respective first and second seasons despite wrapping up subsequent outings earlier this year.

Advertise with us

If you’re wondering how any of this makes sense, don’t worry, it doesn’t. Now that we’re all on the same page, it’s finally time to determine who will and should go home with Emmys on Monday:

Outstanding drama series

Who will win: “Succession”

Who should win: “Succession”

This may be the evening’s biggest no-brainer. The final season of HBO’s vaunted corporate media satire claimed its rightful place atop my Best TV Shows of 2023 rankings thanks to its unmatched technical and creative mastery. Not every legendary show manages to land the plane, but “Succession” went out in a blaze of biting one-liners, withering social commentary and whatever Roman was doing to Peter’s special cheese.

Advertise with us

Pour one out for “Better Call Saul,” which easily would’ve taken this category the last two years if it wasn’t for Jesse Armstrong and company banging out back-to-back seasons of unrivaled television.

Outstanding lead actor in a drama series

Who will win: Kieran Culkin, “Succession”

Who should win: Kieran Culkin, ‘Succession”

There’s a world where the Emmys saved Jeremy Strong’s coronation for embodying an all-time great TV character in Kendall Roy for his show’s last ride. That happened in 2020, though, which means this year’s prize is probably his “Succession” co-star’s to lose. Culkin was extra hysterical and heartbreaking during the show’s final season as his Roman Roy sank to previously undiscovered levels of despair and depravity. He will hopefully (and likely) be rewarded for his efforts.

Advertise with us

Outstanding lead actress in a drama series

Who will win: Sarah Snook, “Succession”

Who should win: Sarah Snook, “Succession”

Look, this is just one of those Emmy cycles where one show stood head and shoulders above every other dramatic offering. So don’t be surprised that the favorite in both my head and heart remains a “Succession” alumnus. Shiv Roy was put through the ringer physically, romantically and morally last spring, and Snook rose to the challenge every time. Don’t overthink this one.

Outstanding supporting actor in a drama series

Advertise with us

Who will win: Matthew Macfadyen, “Succession”

Who should win: Matthew Macfadyen, “Succession”

We can start by acknowledging how insane it is that this category is dominated solely by “The White Lotus” and “Succession” actors. At least Macfadyen was deservingly nominated once again for a searingly sad and self-serving performance. Everyone’s favorite Tomlette broke quite a few Gregs this go-around and now has a great shot of earning a second consecutive Emmy.

Outstanding supporting actress in a drama series

Who will win: Someone who isn’t Rhea Seehorn

Advertise with us

Who should win: Rhea Seehorn

This didn’t work in 2022, so my only recourse is to shout it even louder in 2024: GIVE RHEA SEEHORN HER EMMY ALREADY, YOU COWARDS!!!!!!

Outstanding comedy series

Who will win: “The Bear”

Who should win: “Barry” or “Jury Duty”

Advertise with us

Emmy voting ended on Aug. 28, so there’s a chance that the third season of “Ted Lasso” was fresh enough in everyone’s minds to earn it a third consecutive outstanding comedy series win. It’s also possible that even the most ardent “Ted Lasso” defenders would agree that its presumed swan song was a bit lackluster and that goodwill from the sensational second season of “The Bear” could earn that show some love for a solid debut season.

Even though describing the extremely twisted “Barry” as a comedy is farcical, I’d still love to see Bill Hader’s opus recognized here for powerfully sticking the landing on its four-season journey. It would also be fun if “Jury Duty” ended up getting this award for managing to capture lightning in a bottle with its hilarious and kind-hearted spin on the hidden-camera and mockumentary formats.

Outstanding lead actor in a comedy series

Who will win: Jeremy Allen White, “The Bear”

Who should win: Martin Short, “Only Murders in the Building”

Advertise with us

Carmy’s seven-minute monologue about his struggles with addiction from season one of “The Bear” will have more than earned White this Emmy. I’d rather this award, though, go to a more traditionally comedic performance. That’s why I’m pulling for Short, whose Oliver Putnam consistently elicits laughter and genuine human emotion at an impressive clip on “Only Murders in the Building.”

Outstanding lead actress in a comedy series

Who will win: Quinta Brunson, “Abbott Elementary”

Who should win: Rachel Brosnahan, “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”

Brunson clearly grew as both a performer and writer in season two of “Abbott Elementary.” This isn’t Brunson the performer’s fault, but my frustrations over a certain storyline involving her character left a sour taste in my mouth. That’s why I’d be more excited to see Brosnahan receive a well-deserved second Emmy for expertly portraying her titular comedian’s present and future on the final season of “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.”

Advertise with us

Outstanding supporting actor in a comedy series

Who will win: Ebon Moss-Bachrach, “The Bear”

Who should win: Anthony Carrigan, “Barry”; James Marsden, “Jury Duty”

Moss-Bachrach is practically guaranteed to take this category at the next Emmys for his transformative work in season two of “The Bear.” This year, why not instead reward a Carnegie Mellon University graduate for the comedic tour de force he delivered yet again during the final season of “Barry”?  Alternatively, why not honor an actor brave enough to play a ludicrously amusing version of himself on 2023’s breakout original comedy?

Outstanding supporting actress in a comedy series

Advertise with us

Who will win: Hannah Waddingham, “Ted Lasso”

Who should win: Jessica Williams, “Shrinking”

If AFC Richmond truly has played its last match, the Emmys may very well opt to give Waddingham her second Emmy for portraying daffy club owner Rebecca Welton. There would be nothing wrong with that, but it would be a pleasant surprise if Williams broke through for her witty and well-rounded performance as effortlessly cool therapist Gaby on season one of “Shrinking.”

Outstanding limited or anthology series

Who will win: “Beef”

Advertise with us

Who should win: “Daisy Jones & the Six”

It’s me. Hi. I’m the yinzer saying I hope that the partially Pittsburgh-set “Daisy Jones & the Six” emerges victorious here. To be clear, I want to see that happen for its excellently staged concert scenes and the crackling chemistry between Sam Claflin’s Billy Dunne and Riley Keough’s Daisy Jones. Offhand references to Peppi’s and Hazelwood also didn’t hurt this show’s case.

All that said, Netflix’s “Beef” served up a wild smorgasbord of road-rage-fueled shenanigans, class warfare, and two incredible turns from Ali Wong and Steven Yeun. It would be a reasonable choice, even if that meant beating a show with a band who began all their shows with a “Pittsburgh on three!” pump-up chant.

Outstanding lead actor In a limited or anthology series or movie

Who will win: Evan Peters, “Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story”

Advertise with us

Who should win: Steven Yeun, “Beef”

Confession: I haven’t seen “Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story.” Awards-prediction site GoldDerby currently lists Peters’ take on that titular serial killer as the odds-on favorite in this field. Personally, I’d go with Yeun for imbuing his shady and fiery “Beef” character with enough earnest desperation that it’s impossible to not at least vaguely sympathize with his otherwise deplorable actions.

Outstanding lead actress In a limited or anthology series or movie

Who will win: Ali Wong, “Beef”

Who should win: Ali Wong, “Beef”

Advertise with us

With apologies to Riley Keough and her dazzling Daisy Jones, Wong proved to everyone that she has what it takes to handle multifaceted roles that require equal doses of physical exertion and emotional honesty. “Beef” was clearly designed as a showcase for her and Yeun, and those two absolutely nailed parts that could’ve gone spectacularly sideways in the wrong hands.

Outstanding supporting actor In a limited or anthology series or movie

Who will win: Paul Walter Hauser, “Black Bird”

Who should win: Paul Walter Hauser, “Black Bird”

This is probably the category I feel least strongly about. Hauser got a lot of buzz for his portrayal of a seductive psychopath in “Black Bird.” All yours, buddy.

Advertise with us

Outstanding supporting actress In a limited or anthology series or movie

Who will win: Niecy Nash, “Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story”

Who should win: Camila Morrone, “Daisy Jones & the Six”

Once again, GoldDerby feels a “Dahmer” performer has the inside track in this category. Morrone is probably a long shot here, but her ability to turn what could’ve been a standard put-upon wife archetype into a fully formed person and integral element of the band’s success was, dare I say, Emmy-worthy.

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.