*** This article contains light spoilers for multiple 2023 shows. •••
It’s impossible to talk about the year in television without beginning with the labor turmoil that upended the entire entertainment industry.
Most United States-based TV professionals had a rough 2023 due to the recently settled Writers Guild of America and SAG-AFTRA strikes that shut down most Hollywood production nationwide for the duration of those labor disputes.
That led to some shows releasing while their creative teams were still unable to promote them, others having their new seasons pushed into 2024 and beyond, and a few particularly unlucky ones — like the Western Pennsylvania-shot Amazon Prime Video series “A League of Their Own” — getting unceremoniously canceled despite previous assurances that their stories would be allowed to continue.
Let’s all cross our fingers and hope that 2024 will be a much smoother ride for the folks who make the TV we love. The least we can do for them after such a challenging 2023 is to celebrate all the incredible shows that did end up gracing the small screen this year.
Without further ado, here are my top 10 shows of 2023. Feel free to tell me about some of your favorites from this year in the comments!
Read More
Honorable mentions: “The Last of Us” (HBO), “Beef” (Netflix), “Scott Pilgrim Takes Off” (Netflix), “Justified: City Primeval” (FX), “Hijack” (AppleTV+), “Our Flag Means Death” (Max), “One Piece” (Netflix), “Mrs. Davis” (Peacock)

10.) “Dave” (FX)
If you had told me 10 years ago that the YouTube star who made the viral “Ex-Boyfriend” music video had an auteurist FX comedy in him, I would’ve laughed at you and gone back to my “Scandal” binge. That 21-year-old version of me may not have been totally surprised to find out that Dave “Lil Dicky” Burd wound up starring in three seasons of a show about, naturally, a struggling rapper desperate for attention and love.
He would, however, be both appalled and highly amused to discover that a guy who once proudly referred to himself as “Mr. Leftward-Sloping Penis” was capable of spearheading such an entertaining, creative and heartfelt show that has only gotten stronger with each subsequent season. The 2023 iteration of me is still reeling from the knowledge that Lil Dicky now has the kind of Hollywood sway to entice Rachel McAdams and Brad Pitt to make the TV cameos of the year in relatively meaty parts.
Even a plot twist that left a sour taste in my mouth wasn’t enough to erase how much fun season three of “Dave” was. I’m still waiting for someone to release an official version of “Mr. McAdams.” Tick tock!

9.) “Only Murders in the Building” (Hulu)
As you’re about to find out, I’m a sucker for a show that integrates music seamlessly into its overall narrative. The biggest surprise in that department this year by far was season three of “Only Murders in the Building.”
I was already excited for Paul Rudd and Meryl Streep to join Selena Gomez, Steve Martin and Martin Short in whatever Arconia-centered murder mystery they were forced into solving this go-around. I wasn’t expecting the show to enlist a cavalcade of Broadway veterans to write a fake musical that necessitated plenty of theater-based shenanigans and inspired some truly breathtaking sequences.
It’s hard to explain, but I felt the strangest sense of pride when Martin’s Charles-Haden Savage finally nailed his patter song to remarkable dramatic and comedic effect. Good luck getting “Which of the Pickwick Triplets Did It” out of your head. You’ll need it.

8.) “Shrinking” (AppleTV+)
This may be purely anecdotal, but it seemed for a while at least like “Shrinking” was the year’s biggest word-of-mouth hit. Whenever I asked someone what they were watching during the first half of 2023, “Shrinking” was inevitably among their current roster of shows. I hadn’t planned on checking it out, but I’m sure glad I did!
“Shrinking” is exactly the type of high-concept sitcom you would expect from “Scrubs” and “Ted Lasso” mastermind Bill Lawrence. That man is fantastic at introducing viewers to a set of characters you can’t help but immediately care about. Here, he trades in a hospital and futbol pitch for a therapists’ practice staffed by grieving and hapless Jimmy (Jason Segel), effortlessly cool Gaby (Jessica Williams), and gruff but kind Paul (Harrison Ford).
The dynamics those three and the other weirdos in their inner circle share made for a delightful inaugural season of television. Ford was particularly hilarious and ended up being arguably the most egregious snub during last summer’s Primetime Emmy Awards nominations.

7.) “Reservation Dogs” (FX)
FX cornered the market on groundbreaking half-hour dramedies over the last decade with the likes of “Atlanta,” “Baskets,” “Better Things” and three shows on this very year-end list. “Reservation Dogs” had the distinction of portraying all the nuances of life in a small Oklahoma town largely comprised of Native American residents in a way that had never been depicted before.
While some may have argued that its four young protagonists had completed their primary mission of honoring their dead friend in the show’s season two finale, creators Sterlin Harjo and Taika Waititi clearly felt their story wasn’t over yet. Its third outing was a bit more narratively uneven than its predecessors, but it still managed to capture the unique magic of watching multiple generations of this community interact, learn from each other and grow together.
Shout out to Devery Jacobs, who both wrote and delivered the television line of the year — “Everything I need from you fits on that piece of paper” — in the series’ penultimate episode.

6.) “Jury Duty” (Amazon Freevee)
Look at you, Amazon Freevee! Not only do you clearly enjoy filming your shows in the Pittsburgh area, but you managed to put out what was easily the breakout original comedy of 2023.
“Jury Duty” took hidden-camera hijinks to a new level this year by crafting a scenario where every member of a fake jury was an actor except poor, sweet Ronald Gladden. It’s a setup that could’ve gone off the rails in spectacular fashion. Luckily for everyone involved, it just served as an amazing vehicle for all sorts of antics centered around a completely oblivious Ronald.
What made “Jury Duty” extra special was how kind-hearted it was toward Ronald from start to finish. Well, that and James Marsden’s wonderfully meta turn as a heightened version of himself that rightfully earned him a 2023 Emmy nomination for supporting actor in a comedy series.

5.) “Schmigadoon!” (AppleTV+)
Only one show on this list had me running for a thesaurus halfway through its first episode. Thanks to “season two of “Schimagdoon!,” I feel like a more well-rounded person knowing that “farrago” means “a confused mixture.”
To be fair, there’s not much else in the English language that rhymes with “Schmicago,” season two’s Broadway-oriented town that traded in season one’s 1940s and ‘50s musical trappings for more ‘60s and ‘70s-inspired fare. In addition to being a pitch-perfect parody of that era’s Broadway offerings, “Schmigadoon!” season two continued the show’s tradition of funny, clever storylines and immaculately choreographed musical set pieces.
Titus Burgess was a great addition to a cast already bursting with Broadway talent as a “Pippin”-esque narrator. For my money, season two’s standout song was lawyer Bobbie Flanagan’s (Jane Krakowski) vivacious solo number in which she utilizes all the belles and whistles at her disposal to ensure that poor Josh (Keegan-MIchael Key) won’t be wrongly convicted of murder.

4.) “Daisy Jones & The Six” (Amazon Prime Video)
I admittedly only sought out “Daisy Jones & The Six” after realizing it was about a fictional Pittsburgh band’s rise to the greatest heights of rock-stardom during the 1970s. I enjoyed it so much, though, that I quickly obtained and devoured Taylor Jenkins Reid’s original 2019 novel of the same name.
Sure, it’s the kind of behind-the-music tale that will be almost too recognizable to anyone familiar with the real-life creative and personal foibles experienced by the members of Fleetwood Mac. But it’s pulled off with such aplomb in both its quieter character-building moments and the raucous concerts of all sizes that chart the band’s meteoritic ascendancy.
The whole ensemble is on point, and there’s a palpable romantic tension between Sam Claflin’s Billy Dunne and Riley Keough’s Daisy Jones that defines the whole series. Plus, the music rules. I’d pay good money to watch those two crush “Look at Us Now (Honeycomb)” in front of a sold-out Acrisure Stadium crowd.

3.) “Barry” (HBO)
No series made a better argument for why not all half-hour shows should be considered comedies than “Barry” did during its four-season run that wrapped up earlier this year. Bill Hader’s opus about a troubled hitman trying to establish a new life for himself in Los Angeles went in some insane directions that ultimately culminated in a suitably violent (and shockingly hopeful) conclusion.
That’s not to say the show gave up on generating laughter. The ease at which Hader’s Barry Berkman bought an arsenal of guns at a big-box store made for some memorable satire, and I maintain that Carnegie Mellon University graduate Anthony Carrigan continued to deliver the funniest pound-for-pound performance on television as jovial gangster NoHo Hank up until his character’s final scene.
“Barry” went to places in its explorations of performance, ambition and self-perpetuating cycles that most hour-long dramas would never dare to go. The greatest tragedy here is that it’s looking increasingly like neither Carrigan’s comedic master class nor Sarah Goldberg’s criminally underrated work as perpetually flustered actor Sally Reed will ever be properly recognized by the Emmys.

2.) “The Bear” (FX)
Watching a show level up from season to season is one of the greatest pleasures any avid TV consumer can experience. “The Bear” did exactly that in 2023 by following up its chaotically entertaining first season with a slightly more even-keeled sophomore outing that added dimension and heart to everyone’s favorite Chicago food purveyors while diving deep into the harsh realities of opening a restaurant.
“Fishes” has a solid claim to the title of 2023’s best episode thanks to how expertly it integrated a bevy of guest stars while fleshing out the extended Berzatto family’s underlying trauma. Personally, I was even more into the show’s very next installment in which Richie (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) finds his calling as a front-of-house manager. No TV scene in 2023 captured the essence of pure joy better than Richie singing along to Taylor Swift’s “Love Story” after clearly falling in love himself with his new role.
Season two of “The Bear” almost certainly would have topped this list any other year. I feel confident calling it the best still-ongoing series on television, mostly because its stiffest competition for that crown signed off in 2023 with a season for the ages.

1.) “Succession” (HBO)
“Succession” is the only show this year that I made a point to watch live, both to avoid spoilers and because I simply couldn’t wait to see what happened next. Creator Jesse Armstrong somehow crafted a swan song that didn’t fully match the show’s most soaring achievements while still solidifying itself as the most dramatically and comedically satisfying season of television released in 2023.
Is there a family in recent years that TV fans have formed a more intimately parasocial relationship with than the Roys? This show’s greatest trick was getting audiences to invest in their journeys despite the fact that Kendall (Jeremy Strong), Roman (Kieran Culkin) and Shiv (Sarah Snook) are objectively terrible people. Those three have crackling chemistry whenever they’re in the same room and are supported by razor-sharp writing, immaculate direction and one of the deepest benches of role-players ever assembled.
One has to marvel at how “Succession” gave us 2023’s most emotional beat in the form of a rare Roy sibling hug and its funniest scene that involved Roman desecrating a block of cheese. The fourth and final season of “Succession” cemented its status as an all-time great series and more than earned its designation as the Best TV Show of 2023.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.