This was an exceptional year at the movies, even if it was a tumultuous one for the folks who create, distribute and play them.

Both TV and film professionals spent much of 2023 out of work due to the SAG-AFTRA and Writers Guild of America strikes. Those labor disputes caused film studios to push a few anticipated titles — like “Dune: Part Two” and the Pittsburgh-shot comedy “Drive-Away Dolls” — into 2024 and upended the release calendar over the next few years due to strike-induced production delays.

Movie theaters were reasonably nervous about being able to fill their screens this fall, but both strikes were settled quickly enough to not totally disrupt most studios’ planned programming slates. Some films took a big financial hit without the necessary star power available to promote them, but bona fide phenomena like “Barbenheimer” and “Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour” kept the domestic box office afloat during its time of greatest need.

It also helped that most of 2023’s most-hyped films actually lived up to their creative potentials. Not every big swing succeeded, but even misses like (in this critic’s opinion) “Saltburn” and “Maestro” were admirable enough in their execution to warrant a certain level of respect.

Advertise with us

There were so many strong candidates this year that I had a tough time putting together a top-10 list. Here’s where I landed. Feel free to tell me about some of your favorite 2023 films in the comments!

Honorable mentions: ”Elemental,” “You Hurt My Feelings,” “May December,” “The Holdovers,” “Theater Camp,” “Creed III,” “Flora and Son,” “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Hayhem”

Alden Ehrenreich, left, as Luke and Phoebe Dynevor as Emily in the Netflix thriller "Fair Play." (Sergej Radovic / Netflix)

10.) “Fair Play”

Cinephiles were blessed this year with two extremely impressive debut features written and directed by women. One of them, Chloe Domont, burst onto the scene in early October with the Netflix original film “Fair Play.”

Her audacious twist on the erotic thriller genre follows the agonizing unraveling of Emily (Phoebe Dynevor) and Luke’s (Alden Ehrenreich) engagement after Emily is promoted at the hedge fund where they both work. Honestly, kudos to Ehrenreich for even taking this role and doing his best to not devolve too far into cartoon villainy. Dynevor is so riveting while portraying the full range of Emily’s distress that it’s unfortunate she appears to be an Academy Awards long shot.

Advertise with us

“Fair Play” isn’t the most subtle interrogation of how shifting power dynamics can doom otherwise loving relationships, but I was on the edge of my seat wondering what levels of depravity Luke would stoop to as he allowed this sudden inferiority complex to consume his every waking thought. Domont communicated her ideas so effectively and helmed “Fair Play” with such clear confidence in her own vision that I can’t wait to see what she does next.

Beyoncé at the opening show for the North American leg of her Renaissance World Tour at the Rogers Centre in Toronto in July. (The New York Times photos)

9.) “Renaissance: A Film by Beyoncé”

Of course freakin’ Beyoncé would swoop in on Dec. 1 with a concert film fit for a queen (Bey). Her “Renaissance” documentary was so dazzling and well-constructed that it immediately catapulted itself onto this list. (Sorry, “Elemental.” You’re still 2023’s best rom-com.)

Beyoncé not only gifted her fans with a compilation of multiple stops on her recently completed Renaissance World Tour, but she also granted them the kind of unprecedented behind-the-scenes access that you almost never see from musical megastars. Sure, it’s a tightly curated enterprise produced, written, and directed by its central figure. Still, it’s about as visually stunning and intimate as concert docs get.

Once again, shout out to the film’s editors for splicing together each rendition of various “Renaissance” songs so spectacularly that even the average moviegoer may leave the theater with a newfound appreciation for how good editing can elevate an already incredible cinematic experience.

Advertise with us
Michael Fassbender plays an assassin on a mission in director David Fincher's "The Killer." (Netflix via AP)

8.) “The Killer”

It may be trite to claim that “we don’t talk enough about [blank]” when discussing certain Hollywood heavyweights, but the lack of respect “The Killer” has been receiving this awards season is leading me to conclude that we really don’t talk nearly enough about what a masterful filmmaker David Fincher is and has always been.

The guy who directed “Se7en,” “Zodiac,” “The Social Network,” “Gone Girl” and many more sublime films drops his latest society-deconstructing thriller on Netflix this year in which he meticulously (and hilariously) chronicles a nameless assassin’s (Michael Fassbender) quest to ensure his lasting safety following a botched job and it’s nowhere near the best picture conversation? I would like to speak with the Academy’s manager!

In all seriousness, “The Killer” is yet another Fincher-helmed gem featuring amusingly droll Fassbender voiceovers, an epic one-on-one fight to the death, Tilda Swinton on her conversational A-game, and some expertly delivered commentary on rampant consumerism and what it truly means to devote oneself to your work. Sigh ... who needs an Oscar anyway?

Margot Robbie plays the titular character in "Barbie." (Warner Bros. Pictures)

7.) “Barbie”

Advertise with us

Like many casual and hardcore movie lovers worldwide, I felt the Kenergy this summer.

My initial go-around with Greta Gerwig’s first directorial effort since 2019’s “Little Women” took place at the Manor Theatre alongside a gaggle of yinzers decked out in pink and sipping their “Barbie Dream Car” cocktails. I left that experience having watched a legitimately funny film with immaculate production design that admittedly felt like a fairly basic examination of 21st-century gender politics.

I revisited “Barbie” a few months later and found it to be a much deeper and richer text on a subsequent viewing. I continued to be struck by Margot Robbie’s warmth and sincerity as the titular doll, Ryan Gosling’s wonderfully over-the-top take on Ken and Michael Cera’s scene-stealing work as the constantly overlooked Alan. “I’m Just Ken” remains a marvel of moviemaking that better get the best original song nomination (and win) it rightfully deserves.

Erika Alexander, left, as Coraline and Jeffrey Wright as Thelonious "Monk" Ellison in "American Fiction." (Clare Folger / Orion Pictures)

6.) “American Fiction”

This was a pleasant surprise! The buzz surrounding “American Fiction” was largely positive, but I had no idea what to expect going into writer-director Cord Jefferson’s biting satire of race, the publishing industry and modern pop entertainment.

Advertise with us

What I discovered was my current pick for 2023’s best adapted screenplay that made me laugh harder and more consistently than any other movie did this year. An extremely game ensemble is led by an Oscar-worthy Jeffrey Wright playing a cynical writer whose purposefully stereotypical “Black” manuscript becomes an overnight literary sensation.

Wright is so good as Thelonious “Monk” Ellison in “American Fiction” that I won’t even be mad if he ends up edging out Colman Domingo’s turn as the titular figure in Pittsburgh-shot “Rustin” for that final best actor spot. Awards-season junkies should also be paying close attention to Sterling K. Brown, who delivered a surprising yet heartbreaking performance as Monk’s out-of-control brother.

Keanu Reeves plays the titular character in "John Wick: Chapter 4.” (Murray Close / Lionsgate via AP)

5.) “John Wick: Chapter 4”

Let’s not mince words here: “John Wick: Chapter 4” has to be among the best American action movies ever made. I’m willing to be proven wrong in that assertion, but that’s definitely the sense I got watching this franchise’s fourth (and best) installment last spring.

Director Chad Stahelski has distilled operatic violence down to a science. There are so many things in this movie I’ve simply never seen before, from that pulse-pounding Arc de Triomphe shootout to everything Keanu Reeves’ John Wick goes through while climbing the many steps to reach the top of Sacre-Coeur.

Advertise with us

I first checked out “John Wick: Chapter 4” all the way back in March. I’ve seen a lot of movies since then, and yet very little has stuck with me more this year than that top-down sequence in which Reeves mows down assailant after assailant with a “dragon breath” shotgun. That’s total cinema, baby!!

Emma Stone, left, as Bella Baxter and Mark Ruffalo as Duncan Wedderburn in "Poor Things." (Atsushi Nishijima / Searchlight Pictures)

4.) “Poor Things”

I discussed the joys of watching a show level up from season to season in my Best TV Shows of 2023 roundup. The same principle applies to filmmakers, which is why it was so thrilling to leave “Poor Things” with the reassurance that Yorgos Lanthimos had officially made the leap from the guy responsible for quirky fare like 2015’s “The Lobster” and 2018’s “The Favourite” to someone who must now be considered one of Hollywood’s best working directors.

His warped Frankenstein-inspired tale about a dead woman who was brought back to life with an entirely new brain maintains the singular tone he cultivated in those previous efforts while upping the ante in terms of scale, lavish production design and sheer boldness. Lanthimos proved adept at handling every challenge this globetrotting adventure presented — including some of 2023’s most sexually explicit scenes that serve his larger narrative and will only scandalize the most squeamish of viewers.

While Mark Ruflalo and Willem Dafoe do excellent supporting work in “Poor Things,” the film’s main draw is Emma Stone’s acting tour de force as the wide-eyed and insatiable Bella Baxter. There’s not an ounce of fear in Stone’s performance as Bella explores life’s many pleasures and contradictions, adjusting her expectations accordingly as she goes. I’ll be genuinely shocked if Stone doesn’t leave the 2024 Oscars with her second best actress win.

Advertise with us
Greta Lee, left, as Nora, John Magaro as Arthur and Teo Yoo as Jung Hae Sung in "Past Lives." (A24)

3.) “Past Lives”

This year’s other highly lauded debut film written and directed by a woman was Celine Song’s “Past Lives,” which hit theaters in June and ended up being the only movie on this list distributed by perennial awards-season darling A24. This modest romantic drama earned critics’ and audiences’ admiration this year thanks to its unique multicultural specificity and quiet but engrossing story centered around three compelling protagonists navigating tricky emotional entanglements.

I had no idea that Greta Lee of “Russian Doll” “sweet birthday baby” fame was capable of imbuing a character like Nora with such tenderness and internal complexity. Teo Yoo was appropriately lovelorn as Jung Hae Sung, Nora’s childhood friend in search of clarity and/or closure. Jon Magaro deserves credit for not playing Nora’s husband, Arthur, as a complete sad sack despite his increasing suspicions that he’s probably the other guy in this love triangle.

The way Song frames each shot is dripping with metaphorical intention, and she wrote what was easily my favorite piece of dialogue this year that came in the form of a charged exchange culminating in, “See you then.” Song is an exciting new cinematic voice who is practically guaranteed a best original screenplay nomination and thankfully still has an outside shot of sneaking into the Oscars’ best director field.

Cillian Murphy, left, as J. Robert Oppenheimer and Robert Downey Jr as Lewis Strauss in "Oppenheimer." (Melinda Sue Gordon / Universal Pictures)

2.) “Oppenheimer”

Advertise with us

Honestly, I was quite skeptical of Christopher Nolan’s ability to make a satisfying J. Robert Oppenheimer biopic. The three-hour run time and Nolan’s insistence that the best way to watch “Oppenheimer” was via a format available in only a handful of U.S. movie theaters left a sour taste in my mouth as “Barbenheimer” weekend drew ever closer.

The fact “Oppenheimer” narrowly missed the top spot on this list proves how emphatically wrong I was about this massive, gorgeous and phenomenally acted portrait of the atomic bomb’s primary architect and the political inquiries scrutinizing the contributions of that project’s key figures. Cillian Murphy’s brilliant but conflicted Oppenheimer and Robert Downey Jr.’s petty and ambitious government official Lewis Strauss are heavy Oscars favorites in their respective categories, and rightfully so.

I wasn’t surprised at Nolan’s magnificent re-creation of the world-changing Trinity test, but I had to tip my hat to the uncharacteristic restraint he displayed when “Oppenheimer” abruptly shifted from a gripping journey of scientific achievement to one of the most engrossing courtroom dramas of the 21st century.

Deciding between “Oppeneheimer” and my eventual choice for Best Movie of 2023 was a grueling task that ultimately came down to the baffling way two important female characters were written in Nolan’s otherwise near-perfect film. To be fair, there’s no shame in losing to a master of the medium.

Lily Gladstone, left, as Mollie Burkhart, Robert De Niro as William Hale and Leonardo DiCaprio as Ernest Burkhart in "Killers of the Flower Moon." (Apple)

1.) “Killers of the Flower Moon”

Advertise with us

“Killers of the Flower Moon” was already an all-time great example of literary journalism in which author David Grann thoroughly chronicled a series of horrifying 20th-century murders and the widespread conspiracy at the center of them. As of earlier this year, it’s now also a Martin Scorsese-directed feature film that took a different but equally captivating route in its depiction of the horrors inflicted upon members of the Osage Nation.

Scorsese’s towering, nearly 210-minute opus is set in early 20th-century Oklahoma and pulls no punches in showing the systematic manner in which (largely white) opportunists orchestrated the deaths of wealthy Osage members in order to obtain their headrights. Breathtakingly beautiful shots of sweeping plains and a dash of dark humor break up the chilling mundanity of how easy it can be for evil to operate in broad daylight.

Robert De Niro and Leonardo DiCaprio are both terrifying and infuriating as the bumbling masterminds behind this grisly scheme. Lily Gladstone steals the show as Mollie Burkhart, a smart but sickly Osage woman whose family has become a major target of a plot that unbeknownst to her has been largely carried out by her husband, Ernest (DiCaprio). That viewers are left to ponder whether there was ever any real love between them is a testament to DiCaprio and Gladstone’s combined chemistry.

Like “Oppeneheimer,” “Killers of the Flower Moon” is a well-paced epic capped off by a perfect final image. It also happens to include one of the most inventive pre-credit explanations of what happened to its main players that I’ve ever seen. For all of these accomplishments and more, “Killers of the Flower Moon” overcame some fierce competition to finish the year as my Best Movie of 2023.

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.