Editor’s note: This article contains spoilers for season 20 of “The Bachelorette.”
Being on “The Bachelorette” was never an item on Tanner Courtad’s bucket list.
The 30-year-old Strip District resident only ended up on season 20 of the long-running ABC dating show because his brother anonymously applied for him. Courtad was hesitant when he got the call, but he was single and figured it couldn’t hurt to take the interview.
“Once I got to the end of that process, it’s one of those once-in-a-lifetime opportunities,” he told the Post-Gazette last week. “I’d be kicking myself as a 60-, 70-year-old man if I didn’t do something like that.”
Well, he did it, and as avid “Bachelorette” watchers already know, Courtad was one of five remaining contestants before Charity Lawson sent him home during a trip to New Orleans. He wishes he had gotten more time to show Lawson other sides of his personality, as well as his hometown. But overall, Courtad left his “Bachelorette” experience “with no regrets.”

Courtad is a South Fayette native and 2011 South Fayette High School graduate who was a senior linebacker on the Lions football team that reached the 2010 PIAA Class AA title game. He went on to study communications and business at the University of Pittsburgh and now works as a mortgage lender and fitness instructor.
Anyone can take his online classes through Walk at Home or the in-person ones he teaches at Walk Run Lift Studio in the Strip District’s produce terminal. He’s also pretty accessible via Instagram and his “Future Self” workout videos on YouTube.
“I love everything about Pittsburgh,” he said. “I love the people and the community aspect of it. Western Pennsylvania is obviously big in football and that was a huge part of my life growing up. Still is. I’m just a Pittsburgh guy.”
Anyone tuning in for the season 20 premiere of “The Bachelorette” probably also pegged Courtad as a classic yinzer when his first move after exiting the limousine was to present Lawson with a “Tanner Towel,” his riff on the Terrible Towel that consisted of a white cloth adorned with a big black “T” for Tanner. Courtad chuckled while recalling KISS 96.1 FM “Morning Freak Show” hosts Mikey and Big Bob tearing apart his gambit, with Mikey referring to it as “a sad bath towel.”
His original idea was to use a real Terrible Towel for that introduction, but that plan was nixed due to copyright issues. Courtad recognizes that it was a bold first impression to leave Lawson with, but considering that he didn’t really talk to her much that first night, it may have been what earned him a rose right out of the gate.
“You need to do something to stand out,” he said. “I came up with the Tanner Towel to be funny and memorable. I know Charity likes tailgates and football, so it made sense. Make it fun, make it playful.”

As someone who has never been the loudest guy in the room, Courtad was content to let events unfold organically. He never got a one-on-one date with Lawson, though his final appearance did include a two-on-one excursion with Lawson and fellow contestant Sean McLaughlin. Courtad didn’t realize McLaughlin had stolen a kiss with Lawson at the end of that date until he watched the finished episode.
In the end, he understands why Charity wasn’t comfortable with the notion of their first date involving visiting his hometown and meeting his family.
“I genuinely love Charity as a person,” Courtad said. “I’ll never say a bad word about her. It’s a super stressful and tough position to be in, and I thought she handled herself perfectly. ... I felt, and it looked like she felt, too, that if we had more time together we might have grown. But she had strong connections with other guys, and she had to explore that.”
In case you were wondering, Courtad had thought about what a Pittsburgh hometown would have looked like. Chances are good that it would have included a ride up an incline to take in the views from Mount Washington, “a Strip District Saturday or Sunday,” and going to South Fayette for a backyard cookout at his parents’ house.
Courtad may not be totally done with “The Bachelorette”-verse. He was on hand for “The Men Tell All” episode that aired Monday night in which, as Courtad put it, he and his fellow contestants were “all on the same page about” the behavior of ostensible season 20 villain Brayden Bowers. There are also rumors swirling that Courtad may have been shortlisted to appear on season nine of “Bachelor in Paradise,” to which he would only say, “Stay tuned.”
While he is still single and ready to find his person, he deemed it necessary to “focus on myself a little more” before starting to date again. He thanked all the Pittsburghers who showed him love during his “Bachelorette” run — “not so much from Mikey and Big Bob,” he joked — and welcomed anyone who sees him out and about to “come and say hi.”
He also had nothing but glowing reviews of his time with Lawson and the other men vying for her heart.
“I value relationships over anything in life,” Courtad said. “I’m so grateful to have met the guys from my season. I think they’ll be lifelong friends. I’m grateful to have met a woman like Charity. She showed me what it was like to really open up to someone ... and I feel like I grew as a person from this entire experience.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.