As Chelsea Laden plotted her revenge against her brother, she stumbled across an old, creepy building in Waynesburg that was perfect for what she had in mind for him.
Ms. Laden, 28, and her brother, Dakota, 25, are the hosts of Travel Channel show “Destination Fear,” which features those two and childhood friends Tanner Wiseman and Alex Schroeder exploring potentially haunted locales while testing each other’s limits in the process. A few seasons back, her brother picked a location with a dungeon and locked his sister there, an experience she has not forgotten.
“Destination Fear” is currently in its third season, and when it came time to select a site to investigate, she went with the Greene County Almshouse, a former home for the poor whose overseers tormented patients. With one particularly unsettling story of a mother accidentally killing her young child, it certainly had the kind of chilling backstory she was looking for, plus one other “major incentive” that sealed the deal: a dungeon.
You can catch Ms. Laden’s attempts to thoroughly scar her brother for life on the Greene County Almshouse episode of “Destination Fear” on the Travel Channel. It premieres Saturday on the streaming service Discovery+.
The Greene County Almshouse is actually a museum operated by the Greene County Historical Society.
“I really appreciate when buildings are preserved,” she told the Post-Gazette. “It almost feels like you’re stepping back in time, and I love that. There aren’t a lot of buildings that have that feel to it. It’s hard to find and very unique. It also totally surpassed my expectations when it came to the creepiness and fear factor. When you’re walking, you can hear the creeks of the whole floor.”
Read More
It was open from 1862 to 1964, according to Matt W. Cumberledge, executive director of the Greene County Historical Society. Cumberledge, whose family has been in the area since 1778, said the historical society took over the almshouse in 1968 and reopened it as a museum in 1971. He described the building as “remarkably haunted” by both the souls of those who died there and William Cage, a particularly sadistic almshouse worker.
Cumberledge said that well over 6,000 people lived there during the almshouse’s heyday, and while only 746 deaths were officially recorded in its ledger, he estimates that the number is probably closer to 1,500. One grisly story stands out: Around 1900, a resident named Sarah Knisely tried to warm her freezing baby by placing it in the almshouse’s oven. Residents woke up to a delicious smell, only to discover what really happened to her child.
“I love a location that has a dark story or something unique,” Ms. Laden said. “It doesn’t always have to be the biggest, baddest location, but I typically like to find places that are unexpected.... I really was intrigued by it.”

The Lakesville, Minn., natives have been fascinated with haunted structures their whole lives. As teenagers, they checked out abandoned buildings around Minnesota, Iowa and Wisconsin. He said that part of what took them down this spooky path was their father building a house on land that their neighbors said was haunted. Weird stuff happened around their home often enough that it “piqued our curiosity” for the paranormal, Mr. Laden said.
Fun fact: His first time living away from home after high school was when he moved to Pittsburgh for four months to be a production assistant on the Vin Diesel film “The Last Witch Hunter.” Another fun fact: She is a former National Women’s Hockey League goaltender who in 2016 was part of the first trade in NWHL history when she was sent from the Connecticut Whale to the New York Riveters.
Before they get to the Greene County Almshouse, Ms. Laden put her brother and friends through the wringer in an experiment that forced them to confront their fear of the unknown. If you end up wondering how he is still talking to his sister after that and being locked into the almshouse’s dungeon for hours, know that he understands.
“To be honest, the series of events leading into this episode, the way the rest of the road trip went down, I totally deserved it,” he said. “The episode that aired last week, all I got online was people so mad at me for what I put her through. I was mad though, I’m not going to lie.”
The filming took place over four days in late February and early March, according to Cumberledge. He “was overwhelmed by how respectful they were to the building and everything in it.” He hopes the episode will attract more tourists who can help fund repairs for 147 of its windows. Cumberledge briefly appears in the episode; he planned to watch it for the first time with his staff on Saturday at the almshouse.
“All I know is I heard a lot of screaming when the kids were in there filming,” he said.
Ms. Laden said that the almshouse is “in the top 50th percentile for sure” of the scariest places they’ve visited for “Destination Fear.” Having been locked in its dungeon for most of the episode, her brother concurred. Though it was one of the smaller buildings they have visited, it’s high on his list “considering the amount of activity and fear I felt in there.”
There was a moment off-camera where Ms. Laden was using one of the almshouse’s bathrooms in its library and a book fell off the shelf. She hopes that kind of after-hours fright plus her brother’s little payback will entice viewers to check out this “Destination Fear” episode.
“It’s good mix of comedy, scares — and a little revenge,” she said.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.