Netflix has gobbled up TV show creators who previously worked for broadcast and cable networks, offering nine-figure multiyear deals to the likes of Shonda Rhimes (“Grey’s Anatomy”), Kenya Barris (“black-ish”) and FX stalwart Ryan Murphy, who is the first to get a Netflix series out of the gate with “The Politician,” streaming Friday.
Packed with trademark Murphy casting — Jessica Lange! Gwyneth Paltrow! The chiseled male physique objectified! — “The Politician” marks the latest in what we can call Murphy’s camp oeuvre. We’ve seen high school/musical camp (“Popular,” “Glee”), spooky camp (“American Horror Story,” “Scream Queens”), period camp (“Feud,” “Pose”), and with “The Politician” we get cynical political camp. (His “American Crime Story” entries for FX are generally not campy and offer serious, politically pointed social commentary.)
Whether “The Politician” appeals probably depends on one’s tolerance for Mr. Murphy’s past campy series that too often begin with promise and then peter out halfway through their runs. “The Politician” does this, too, but then springs back from the dead at the end of its first-season run.
“The Politician” is sometimes a fun watch, but tonally it’s all over the place. The premiere offers some genuine emotions while episode two leans much harder into dark comedy and a Jessica Lange performance that’s so far over the top that viewers will have to squint to see beyond the cartoon in hopes of spotting something that resembles a real human being.
Ben Platt, who came to prominence in the original Broadway company of “Dear Evan Hansen,” stars in “The Politician” as Payton Hobart, a high school senior who’s declared his intention to become president of the United States. He’s read presidential biographies for insight and to fill the giant void at his own center.
Payton knows the right things to say and the political things to do, but it’s all calculated, not genuine or authentic, which presents a problem when his first step is to run for his school’s student body president and his competition, River (David Corenswet), is a soulful Adonis with whom Payton once had a romantic dalliance.
Authenticity — or the lack thereof — is a theme that runs through “The Politician.” River’s girlfriend fakes enjoying sex with him to his dismay.
“I will do better at appearing authentic from now on,” she attempts to assure him.
Payton’s most genuine moments are with his adoptive mother (Gwyneth Paltrow), who prefers Payton to her twin biological sons, Martin (Trevor Eason) and Luther (Trey Eason), privileged lunkheads who taunt Payton.
Unlike past TV antiheroes, Payton is more introspective. He struggles with his selfish nature.
“I help people because it serves me,” Payton says. “[It] feeds my ego and quest for power and ambition. … I try to do good things, but I am not a good person.”
Lange stars as the whirling dervish grandmother of Payton’s classmate Infinity (Zoey Deutch), whose story brings to mind a Hulu series from earlier this year.
Netflix made the entire first season of “The Politician” available for review, and the show careens from familiar, baroque plot turns and musical theater scenes reminiscent of “Glee” — the school stages Stephen Sondheim’s “Assassins” because it’s a Ryan Murphy show so of course it does! — to soulful, pathos-filled scenes of Payton at his most vulnerable when with his mom or River.
Episode seven feels like a season finale, but the show keeps going through one more hour that introduces characters played by Judith Light and Bette Midler who turn out to be the best parts of season one.
The season finale sets the scene for a more intriguing second season that Netflix has already ordered. The bulk of the first season is exhaustingly repetitive, but the promise of season two makes me want to return to “The Politician” even as I feel as if I’m likely to get duped and wind up exhausted and disappointed by the show all over again.
‘This is Us’ twist local tie
Tuesday’s fourth season premiere of NBC’s partially Pittsburgh-set “This is Us” offered a twist with a local tie (Spoilers for Tuesday’s episode are ahead).
The episode introduced several new characters, including one who turned out to be Jack (Blake Stadnik), the grown, blind rock star son of Kate (Chrissy Metz) and Toby (Chris Sullivan) in flash-forward scenes.
Beaver County native Stadnik, 27, who is visually impaired himself, is expected to return in future “This is Us” episodes, though not right away, according to executive producer Dan Fogelman, who spent part of his childhood in Bethel Park.
According to the Los Angeles Times, Stadnik, was diagnosed at 6 years of age with Stargardt disease, meaning the light-sensitive cells in his retina have deteriorated, making it difficult for him to focus. His vision, he said, is blurry and he has blind spots and trouble seeing colors.
In 2009 Stadnik, a Penn State musical theater grad, tied with Carter Redwood (National Geographic Channel’s 2017 limited series “The Long Road Home”) in the 15th annual Western Pennsylvania Shakespeare Monologue and Scene Contest for best monologue, grades 8-12.
Steelers pre-empt ABC
Next week marks the first of two Monday night Steelers games — the second is Oct. 28 —that WTAE will carry, pre-empting ABC programming.
“Jimmy Kimmel Live” bumps down to an 11:50 p.m. start time Monday, with “Nightline” at 12:50 a.m. Tuesday, followed by the pre-empted “Dancing With the Stars, 1:20-3:20 a.m. Tuesday, and “The Good Doctor” at 1:05 a.m. Wednesday.
Kept/canceled/revived
Upcoming streaming service HBO Max will revive Aaron McGruder’s former Adult Swim series “The Boondocks,” ordering two seasons (24 episodes total) that will kick off in late 2020 with a 50-minute special.
Netflix renewed “GLOW” for a fourth and final season.
The CW will air an episode of “Arrow” that’s a backdoor pilot for a potential spinoff series focused on Mia Smoak (Katherine McNamara), Laurel Lance (Katie Cassidy) and Dinah Drake (Juliana Harkavy).
Apple TV+ will revive “Oprah’s Book Club” with new episodes debuting very two months. Winfrey will interview author Ta-Nehisi Coates’ about his book “The Water Dancer” in the first episode, debuting Nov. 1.
Showtime picked up HBO’s canceled “VICE” newsmagazine, ordering 13 episodes to begin airing next spring.
Channel Surfing
Per Variety, Emmy-winning “Pose” star and Pittsburgh native Billy Porter will make his directorial debut with an episode in the third season of “Pose” that’s expected to air next summer. … The latest retransmission fight brewing pits Sinclair Broadcast Group against AT&T’s DIRECTV and AT&T TV NOW, which could result in AT&T subscribers losing access to local channels, including Pittsburgh’s WPGH and WPNT, if a deal is not hammered out by 5 p.m. Sept. 27 (the next Steelers game to air on WPGH is scheduled for Nov. 10). … Ratings for Sunday’s Emmy telecast — which featured some great surprising winners but was a terrible awards show production — hit a new low, drawing just 6.9 million viewers, well below the previous low of 10.2 million viewers in 2018. … Bravo’s revival of “Cash Cab” premieres at 11:30 p.m. Oct. 7. … Cable’s FXX debuted “Cake” (10:30 p.m. Wednesday), a weekly showcase of live-action and animated short-form comedy programs.
Tuned In online
Today's TV Q&A column responds to questions about “Better Call Saul,” “Bob [Hearts] Abishola,” “Life in Pieces” and AT&T SportsNet Pittsburgh. This week's Tuned In Journal includes posts on CBS’s “Evil.” Read online-only TV content at http://communityvoices.post-gazette.com/arts-entertainment-living/tuned-in.
TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook for breaking TV news.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.